Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Tactical adjustments needed to break deadlock at Easter Road

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 05 January 2009
NEXT week is a different adventure, said Mixu Paatelainen. We're looking no further ahead than Wednesday's match against Motherwell, was the message from Csaba Laszlo.
Still, while both the Hibernian manager and his Hearts counterpart may wish to regard next Sunday's Scottish Cup match as unrelated to the scoreless draw in the league two days ago, there is evidently a strong connection between the two games. It is
a connection, moreover, which cannot be disregarded by either manager if they want to gain a crucial advantage at Easter Road in six days' time.

The teams will be very similar to the ones which fought out Saturday's stalemate at Tynecastle, and there is a limited number of tactical changes which the managers can adopt. What, then, will make the difference? What must each side do to give themselves the chance of settling the fourth-round tie at the first time of asking, and thus avoid a third Edinburgh derby this month?

The best thing Hearts could do, as they know full well themselves, is to get hold of a striker who can score. They had the better of the second half on Saturday, and hit the woodwork three times as well as creating several other decent chances. Christian Nade, who was again the lone front man in a 4-5-1 formation, has scored just one goal this season, and Jamie Mole, the other striker to have played most often, has also netted only once.

Presuming, however, that they are unlikely to sign a prolific hitman between now and Sunday, they can do little more than plug away at forging chances in the hope that one of them will eventually end up in the back of the net.

Gary Glen impressed when he came off the bench to take over the advanced midfield role, and as a natural striker he would give Laszlo the option of switching to 4-4-2. But Hearts' midfield has a well balanced look to it at present, and the manager would therefore be loath to disrupt it. He is thus likely to trust in Nade again, and to hope that his midfielders offer more of a scoring threat.

If Bruno Aguiar is fit to return that would be a big plus, as the playmaker has been in fine form. If Laryea Kingston finds a new club this week that would also be a bonus: the Ghanaian's lack of interest was all too apparent on Saturday, but his undeniable ability means he cannot readily be ruled out of consideration. In any case, Hearts were more of a threat when Deividas Cesnauskis came on for Kingston, and with the Lithuanian on one wing and Andy Driver on the other they have a good chance of pulling Hibs out of shape.

Laszlo will be forced into at least one change, as Robbie Neilson is suspended after picking up two bookings in the cup last season. Christos Karipidis, who played on against Hibs despite being injured in the first minute, is a major doubt, but Marius Zaliukas and Lee Wallace are expected to return after suspension.

Unlike Hearts, who have that league match at Fir Park to deal with, Hibs have a clear week. Even so, Paatelainen has some similar concerns to those which Laszlo has to deal with, as his side, too, played better after being forced into changes.

As centre-back and captain, Rob Jones is one of the first names on the Hibs team sheet, but on Saturday, with Steven Thicot playing alongside Chris Hogg, the heart of the visitors' defence looked more composed. It was interesting, too, to hear Yves Makalambay, the much-criticised goalkeeper, say he felt more in command of his box in the absence of Jones.

Omitting Jones may be too radical a move for Paatelainen to make, so his decision instead will be whether to drop Thicot, or move him forward into his usual midfield role instead of Lewis Stevenson. The latter was named man of the match by Setanta, but, while he got the better of Michael Stewart for much of the time, he was outshone by, among others, his team-mate Sol Bamba and the Hearts defender Eggert Jonsson, whose penalty-box tackle on Derek Riordan was the best seen by a Hearts player since Neilson's in the 2006 cup final against Gretna.

Jonatan Johansson, who made his Hibs debut at Tynecastle, will be that much sharper come Sunday and can be expected to start wide on the right again. Alan O'Brien, on the other hand, offered little on the left and could be the one to lose out in a recast midfield.

With Hearts likely to go for the same formula in the hope that they can bury at least one chance, the outcome of the game will probably depend on how exactly Paatelainen decides to redraw that midfield. As the teams effectively cancelled each other out two days ago, something has to be done to throw the cup match off balance. Playing Dean Shiels from the start and giving him licence to roam would certainly do that. Whether it would actually work in Hibs' favour, however, is far from certain.



Page 1 of 1

 
1

Neutral Observer,

05/01/2009 01:07:25
Give it up pundit, your comments are getting more and more divorced from reality each time. Johansson may come good in time, but on Saturday his contribution was almost non existant so to say he was a class above the several other very good players on show is absolute tripe (and you know it!).
2

Neutral Observer,

05/01/2009 01:24:04
#4

Did not notice he was wearing a Rangers top. Was he? The man of the match was between Makalambay and Johnsson. I would give it to Johnsson for his versatility and all round dsplay.
3

GeorgeCowieOrWalterKidd?,

05/01/2009 08:14:21
#7 Great shout - start with the team and formation that ended the Hibs game. Glen looks like someone who believes he can score whereas Nade's forgotten how. Glen reminds me of a young skinny Robbo - in the absence of a new striker we could do worse than bring Robbo in as specialist striker coach.
4

huggs,

05/01/2009 08:40:56
In totall agreement re Kingston he is a luxury we can afford to lose IMO would love to see the money used on Bruno instead
If we lose Berra Wilkie would be my choice also but he might be to expensive
have to admit to not seeing the game at the weekend due to working abroad but reading the reports and speaking to mates Hibs ones included
Doesnt look like Nade can score so why not start Glenn or dare i say it Elliot another goal from him at the weekend
Hibs mates reckon a stonewaller penalty but there you go
5

Jambo-ree,

05/01/2009 09:24:08
"If Bruno Aguiar is fit to return that would be a big plus". Complete understatement - his return would be absolutely crucial. We've looked a bit sad without him over the last couple of games and you just need to look back to the first derby of the season to see how he bossed the midfield against the Hibees - and that was his first game in 18 months!

We need to get his contract extended as a matter of priority but as I said yesterday maybe he's playing hardball on that and that's why he is suddenly 'unavailable'.

Hadn't realised Robbie was going to be suspended so that's a bit of blow. Poor Eggy will be dizzy if this carries on like this but what a vital player he's turning out to be.

Cesney for Larry midweek for sure and maybe Rapnik to cover for Kari - we need those three points.
6

Northern Hibby.,

05/01/2009 10:07:21
I thought that both JJ and AOB were empty shirts on saturday and i am not really sure that derby games and cup games are the correct place to let a player gain he match fitness. As for the Hearts, they need a forward to make best use of the space that Nade makes when he holds the ball up. Lucky for us that Nade is no finisher.
7

Dood,

05/01/2009 11:19:02
#11

Agree. Problem is that JJ is an out and out centre forward, best played straight through the middle. So why play him wider? Another tactical triumph Mixu.

The other problem is that we have so little in the middle. Great to see young Lewis back, as he should be starting week in week out, but who else do we have that can play in the middle?

Must sign midfielder Mixu. You've already said it yourself, now act for God's sake!!
8

9inro,

05/01/2009 12:28:19
Funny how the pro - Celtic mhedia in Scotland have started wae the Brown for Portsmouth or West Ham for £9m story when both clubs are in financial freefall ... could you silly bhoys not have linked him wae someone wae money before attempting tae spin the Brown wants tae stay at the Hoopy Loops and is turning down the EPL garbage ...
9

Alex Arnold,

East Lothian 05/01/2009 13:26:05
#11, #12

Agree. Put JJ on the bench, keep Lewis in, and sign a midfield playmaker. Could also be worth giving Yantorno a chance.
10

Paulmac2,

surrey 05/01/2009 14:22:02
13

Did you get that Celtic strip you wanted fur Christmas?


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.