Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Drink Driving, Don't Risk It!

Scotland play Holland on March 28 - but who will win?

McGhee hopes Aberdeen have more tolerant match official

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 07 November 2009
MARK McGhee is hoping for a more "tolerant" referee for Aberdeen's Clydesdale Bank Premier League game against St Johnstone after the performance of match official Steven Nicholls dominated last week's defeat at Hibernian.
Nicholls' display proved to be the biggest talking point of the day when he showed red cards to Maurice Ross and Chris Maguire and cautioned six other players as the Dons ended the match with nine men.

McGhee admits the referee did stick to the le
tter of the law but the manager has called for more common sense in future, with Euan Norris set to take control of their match with Saints today.

"I think the referee was entitled within the rules to interpret all the bookings the way he did," he said. "Technically speaking, all of them could have been bookings and therefore he was entitled to send players off. What I would hope was that referees would look at it slightly differently and would be less inclined to book for such trivial and petty challenges. I hope for a more tolerant kind of referee, that's what I would hope for."

The Scottish Football Association has written to the club seeking an explanation after fierce criticism of Nicholls appeared on the official website in an unattributed article entitled 'Is common sense too much to hope for?'

McGhee added: "I've not read what was on the website, I've heard bits of it, and I'm not even sure who it has been attributed to yet. So there is an anonymous person at this football club who has made comments that have upset the authorities. There are guidelines which I think we are entitled to respect and if we've gone out of those guidelines – whoever the mystery man is – then we've obviously got something to answer. But I think the gist of what we were saying is that we are just looking for a bit of common sense."

Meanwhile, St Johnstone manager Derek McInnes has played down the prospect of his side easing into a top- six spot this weekend with a victory at Pittodrie today.

The SPL newcomers will complete the first quarter of the campaign against the Dons and if they pick up three points, and other results go their way, they will climb into the top half of the table. McInnes says it is too early to read anything into league placings, but admits his assessment of his side's performance in the first quarter has been mostly positive.

"If we can jump a few places it will be great but it would take three or four other results to go our way," he said.

"The first quarter can give you an indication of how you are doing but I think it will be the turn of the year before we get a fairer reflection of how things are going. However, in terms of performances this season I've been pleased. If we can take something from the Aberdeen game then it will be a good solid start to the campaign.

"I had every confidence that my players would perform in this league when we came up and we have acquitted ourselves well, although like every manager I am always looking for more points."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 06 November 2009 11:07 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Aberdeen FC
 
1

Fitba Krazy,

07/11/2009 00:10:49
I don't think a player should be booked for accidentally fouling an opponent in a 50-50 situation as one of them is bound to be late on the vast majority of occasions.

Having said that it is not in the interests of Scottish teams for the referee to be more lenient in Scottish games than continental referees are in European competitions as this leads to Scottish players being punished in European games and internationals where they wouldn't be in domestic games.

The players shouldn't be subjected to deliberate unfair challenges that go unpunished with at least a free kick or a penalty where it should be so. It is only right that the best players who can be singled out for extra "special" treatment are protected from serious injury as much as the rules allow and the same goes for any player who is subjected to outrageous challenges.
2

Edward Rooney,

07/11/2009 03:51:41
Mark McGhee - persistent logorrhea
3

Edward Rooney,

07/11/2009 03:55:25
He's basically saying that all the decisions last week were correct ( technically! ). So by a more "tolerant" ref does he mean one that will allow his thuggish team to kick < insert opponents > off the park and not send anyone off?

What a bel1 end.
4

Big Red,

Aberdeen 07/11/2009 07:45:42
#3.

No, that's not what he's saying because that's nowhere near what happened.

He's (correctly) saying that the referee was well out of his depth and tried to control the game by flashing cards from the off.
To deny that the game wasn't influenced by a referee who completely lost it would just be utter stupidity, wouldn't it ?

That's 15 cards in 2 games from this clown, and if he's let loose again on the SPL there'll be very few of his games finish up with 22 players on the park.

The first requirement of top class refereeing is common-sense. Nicholls has absolutely none and looked to be in panic mode from the off last week, in a game that had very little malice about it until he got involved.

Aberdeen are anything but thuggish. In fact, they couldn't kick their way out of a wet paper bag.

I suspect you're just annoyed because your own team were utter p*sh, and Aberdeen were the better team with 9 men until Hibs got another slice of luck in the last few minutes.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.