Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 17th May 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

It would have been stupid not to use Robinson, admits Hadden



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 11 March 2008
SCOTLAND coach Frank Hadden has tried to play down Andy Robinson's role in helping Scotland lift the Calcutta Cup, but admitted that it would have been foolish not to have involved the Edinburgh coach.
Hadden has continued with his long-term policy of involving the professional team coaches in Scotland and, alongside the vital work of his assistants George Graham and Alan Tait, Robinson joined Glasgow coach Sean Lineen at Murrayfield training sessions last week.

The former England coach, who stood down last year after an unhappy reign at Twickenham, was able to provide insight into England's style – particularly in the forwards – and his input helped contribute to Scotland securing a long-awaited first victory of the year. There was never a suggestion that Robinson had taken over from either Hadden or Graham, but merely that Hadden had tapped into his knowledge and reaped the benefit.

Scotland's head coach said: "Obviously, we have a number of people who we ask to assist us with our preparation. I actually wanted all the coaches in last week, but someone had to stay and coach Edinburgh and Glasgow, so Andy and Sean came in and are in with us again this week, and that's fairly normal practice.

"They didn't have a specific remit; they weren't focusing on one particular area, but were available for feedback, as it is when I go and watch them train. I watch Glasgow and Edinburgh play every week and I phone them during the week and we talk out the game, and we looked for that sort of feedback from both Sean and Andy last week.

"You would think we were stupid if we didn't ask Andy for some information in the build-up to the England game."

Scotland's head coach, who has drafted both Simon Danielli and Scott Lawson into the squad, was clearly pleased with the quality of his team's performance against England, but insisted that it would count for little were the team to fail to replicate that against Italy.

"In the weather conditions, we were not far off flawless (against England]," said Hadded. "I thought we played a bit of rugby as well. We haven't ever produced tackle and defence stats as good as we did on Saturday (two missed tackles in 105]. But I said to the guys that the work would be wasted if it was just because they had white jerseys in front of them. That has to be our benchmark. We have raised the bar and that was the reason so many people have been disappointed this season.

"People were bitterly disappointed that we couldn't beat France. That was really painful, which it wouldn't have been in the past. We're slowly raising the confidence levels of the supporters and the players. I expected more of a carry-over of momentum from the World Cup. I knew the preparations were not always good, that we had injuries and other problems, but I still thought there would be a carry-over. When there wasn't I was gutted. I thought, 'here we go; we're starting again.'

"If preparations continue to improve then I expect us to play better on Saturday. It would be incredibly disappointing if the players started to slacken off now, but I'm pretty confident they won't."

He added: "We didn't have to play out of our skins on Saturday – it wasn't a super-human effort – but the players all did their jobs really well for the first time. Previously we have had people letting us down who have been honest enough to hold their hand up in the aftermath, but on Saturday they could all be really chuffed with a job well done. Now that has got to be the benchmark; that has got to be the par.

"We're aware of how tough a challenge (Italy] are going to be because they are a side which has made a lot of progress over the last couple of years. They have a very, very impressive pack and they are beginning to move the ball around with a lot more confidence now. We actually believe that it is going to be a bigger challenge this week.

"We've got to a situation where I think we deserve the right to be confident whenever we play at home, which makes the biggest disappointment so far the French result. The real challenge for us is to win some of these incredibly difficult Six Nations away matches, and here we've got a great opportunity to try and do that this weekend."

The full article contains 767 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 10 March 2008 11:15 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Calcutta Cup , Six Nations
 
1

Saltireblue,

West of North Berwick, East of West Lothian: 11/03/2008 01:46:52
Brian Moore said...The most fantastic event at Murrayfield on Saturday was when the wife of former England coach Andy Robinson, after cheering as fanatically for Scotland as she used to for England, told me to "f*** off", adding that "my husband is a good coach"."

Welcome to Scotland Mrs. Robinson. You're going to fit in just fine!
2

Scotch on the rocks,

London 11/03/2008 07:38:19
This weekend will be tougher, however, the Italian team has only 6 days between matches (an excuse FH made after the Welsh game). Whether or not this is relevent, we must bring a bit more youth into the back line and play expansive running rugby to move the Italian pack around the pitch.

Same pack (with JW coming off the bench again)
Backs: Blair, Paterson, Webster, Morrison, Cairns, Danielli, Southwell.

Godman should replace Parks on the bench, surely!
3

Southsider once upon a time,

11/03/2008 07:44:11
http://thescotsman.scotsman.com/calcuttacup/Coach39s-wife-swore-at-me.3862965.jp
#2; the above should be enough
4

stringer,

edinburgh 11/03/2008 08:12:54
As Paul Simon once wrote: "...and here's to you Mrs Robinson".
5

Galasbest,

11/03/2008 08:32:05
Interesting Frank Hadden making comments about NOT being stupid. Leaving Patterson out for the first test, selecting Dan Parks over and over, these things are not stupid ????
6

gordonium,

weege 11/03/2008 08:44:41
can we get berbizier to help us this week ahead of italy game??

also #6, i fear hadden will pick the back line that played the majority of the england game, which would be blair, parks, paterson, morrison, webster, walker, southwell.

just a hunch!!!
7

W.Robertson,

11/03/2008 08:50:59
Funilly enough, Frank has the players to blame "Previously we have had people letting us down who have been honest enough to hold their hand up in the aftermath, but on Saturday they could all be really chuffed with a job well done."

So Frank, as a few have already said... how about the coaching decisions and awful calls made?!! Blame the players why don't you. Funny how the only game in which we actually did well involved other coaches, Robinson and Lineen!
8

John, W,

11/03/2008 09:29:38

Paterson should start at 10, fair to say he will. Parks should be left out (his performance on Saturday showed that he's so fallible and that will never change) and a young, upcoming, stand-off should be allowed a run in the last quarter of the match, match position/score depending, so as to 'blood' him at test level. We need to groom a stand-off for the future. Parks is not that man, of course. I doubt if many will disagree that Parks is not the future, so why do we still see his face in the Squad?
9

Galasbest,

11/03/2008 10:16:57
To revert to the business of being stupid, it does appear that when 7 subs have to be selected the norm is to have at least three backs stupid to have only two? maybe but when you select only two and they are both specialist ie one scrum half, one fly half, that is stupid. It also guarantees any injury will mean total disruption of the back line
10

Venachar,

11/03/2008 10:55:51
Now now guys we must not criticise the Great Leader.
I would like to point out that Edinburgh in competitive matches are averaging just under two tries per match, from the boot its averaging at least 12 points from Godman and David Blair . All but four of the tries have been scored by Scots. Leading try scorers by my rekoning Houston 4, De Luca 4, Cairns 4, Turnbull 3 and Webster 2, Godman 1 etc.
Thats 18 tries scored by backs ladies and gents from Edinburghs main guys. They have stood up Jauzion, Traille, O Driscoll, Hook, Henson and the other players playing in the 6 nations.
Perhaps someone would like to do similar stats for Glasgow.
How many tries have Scotland scored recently!!!
11

Hobbit5,

11/03/2008 11:33:44
Here's the team for Italy - as expected.

Southwell, Danielli, Webster, Morrison, Walker, Paterson, Blair (c), Jacobsen, Thomson, Murray, Hines, Macleod, Strokosch, Taylor, Hogg.
SUBS: Scott Lawson, Dickinson, Smith, White, Brown, Rory Lawson, Parks.
12

Saltireblue,

Somewhere over the Rainbows: 11/03/2008 12:46:52
#2: Mabawza:

Check out Brian Moore's column in The Telegraph.
13

Donasdhu,

Groveland, CA 11/03/2008 16:40:48
Hadden must go. His insistance in having Parks on the bench again is more than I can take. I hope at least that Patterson will complete the entire game in the fly half position(some hope)
Cairns and Dec Luca should be first picks.
14

,

11/03/2008 18:08:24
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
15

tatties n, neeps,

11/03/2008 18:36:30
Ex England player/manager and his wife is cheering for Scotland sounds like a mercenery to me.
16

jbascotinengland,

11/03/2008 21:04:10
#12 - please tell me that you made that team up as a horrible joke?

Has there ever been a better opportunity to try something new? Probably not.

Hadden is as blinkered and obstinant as a freaking 3 year old. Perhaps we should get that super nanny lass in to sort him out!
17

JonnyS,

Edinburgh 12/03/2008 10:14:13
#16 Andy Robinson works with Edinburgh and Scotland A players week in week out - he gives them tips and improves their play.... if it was me I would be overjoyed at seeing them put one over on a nation that gave me no support and then discarded me. If you had been to any Edinburgh games this year you will see he has made a huge difference to the guys this year.
18

THE MAN FROM DEL MONTE, he say....,

..stupid is an art form for Franklin D Haddock 12/03/2008 23:45:48
Faeces Frankie strikes again?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.