Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Montgomerie snaps again as he loses his cool in China

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 18 April 2009
COLIN Montgomerie's temper boiled over at the Volvo China Open yesterday as he berated a photographer and a television cameraman during his second round.
The Scot has talked about how being handed the task of winning back the Ryder Cup at Celtic Manor in 2010 has led to him taking a more relaxed approach on the course. But there was little evidence of that new mindset at the event in Beijing as Montgo
merie laboured to a one over par 73 and a two-over score at the halfway point in the Chinese capital.

Having covered his first four holes in even-par, Montgomerie was playing the 14th when he banished a photographer who had irritated him from inside the ropes. He then hooked his drive at the eighth into the water and as he trudged down the fairway to find his ball, barked at a cameraman: "Don't film me."

South Korean Choi Ho-sung produced four birdies over the back nine to establish a two-stroke lead in the event. On an afternoon that saw several names at the top of the leaderboard including the English trio of Nick Dougherty, Simon Dyson and Richard Finch, it was some inspired putting which put Choi in front on six-under.

Chapchai Nirat and 2007 winner Markus Brier share second on four-under, while Irishman Paul McGinley fired a sparkling 67 to climb to three-under alongside Gonzalo Fernandez-Castano in a tie for fourth.

Dyson and Finch finished two-under after rounds of 73 and 71, respectively, while Dougherty struggled over the back nine, coming home in 43 to sign for a 79 and three-over.

McGinley took advantage of benign morning conditions to sink five birdies over his opening nine holes before playing the last nine in even-par. "I played pretty well yesterday, but putted really, really poorly," he said. "Today, I played pretty much the same but putted fantastically, that's the difference."



The full article contains 333 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 17 April 2009 10:25 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Colin Montgomerie
 
1

Just an opinion,

USA 18/04/2009 01:23:46
This is news???
The guy is Jekyll and Hyde, and more's the pity considering how womderful a golfer he was.
Charlie Charming one moment,(when he is winning!! ) and Arrogant Alfie the next.
But golf requires too much mental stability or discipline for someone like Monty who obviously has a fragile streak between the ears.
Again, more's the pity.
You just hope the spectators who see this sort of conduct served up on an oh so steady diet do not think all Scots are like him.
2

Glasgow Expat,

Desert 18/04/2009 05:07:28
The man-child is obviously mentally ill. I feel sorry for him.
3

Rock Lobster,

18/04/2009 11:59:08

Eight times European Order of Merit winner, and now Ryder Cup Captain.

Why do so called journalists dish up this kind of junk about Colin Montgomerie? its been happening for years and the more successful Monty became the more flack came his way.

As for mental strength #1 his Ryder Cup record shoots done your spurious claims.
4

Black Five,

edinburgh 18/04/2009 12:01:37
no 1 comment says it .A complete Jekyll and Hide.There is definately something far wrong with his brain at times and really it is very sad.He will look back in later life and think of the lost chances he`s had in majors a lot to do with his temperement.To think of the likes of Cabrerra who is not the skilled golfer Monty is but he has won two majors must surely make him think.It`s about bottle and temperement.Monty has questionable bottle but his brain is short of a couple of cogs.
5

Rock Lobster,

18/04/2009 12:55:20

Monty has won 31 European Tournaments, only 3 golfers have a better record.

Seve, Bernhard and Tiger.

Says it all really.
6

Black Five,

edinburgh 18/04/2009 14:36:25
Rock Lobster.Says it all ...what ? That he`s not a bad golfer who has won some Mickey Mouse Tournaments plus a few others that have some prestige in a small pond.Where are the majors ? I bet he`d trade the lot for a brace like Cabrerra.Also doesn`t say that the man`s brain is not always in the right gear.
7

I used to love golf.... ,

18/04/2009 16:06:05
rubbish Rock... he never won anything in the states... didn't have what it took. I could accept him doing Eu for 5 Order of Merit's or something but staying this side so long either shows stupidity or lack of guts. If you've got what it takes then you want to play the best each week. Monty no majors.... will be forgotten in 20 odd years

Cabrerra's a great golfer..... none of this... the like of.. US Open/Masters... up there with the big boys... time to get more too
8

Rock Lobster,

18/04/2009 16:41:48

Monty's record speaks for its self, 8 Order of Merits,
31 European tournament wins, 20 million euros won by 2005, he did not play the American tour,why should he.

Colin Montgomerie can only be judged on his golfing record, and as far as I am concerned its very
impressive.

To compare Monty to other golfers is a waste of time,
and comments like, his brain is a short of a cog, are like this article, full of sh*t
9

Just an opinion,

USA 18/04/2009 20:07:49
Rock Lobster:When you are in the minority of one, surely you can see the criticisms of your hero are not without foundation.
As I said, a heck of a waste of talent.
And, yes, he certainly produced the goods in the Ryder Cup, but as Jack Nicklaus says, it is all about Majors and how many you have won at the end of your career that defines you as a player.
As I posted, a wonderful golfer who could not close on too many occasions, more is the pity.
But in addition to Lyle, Faldo, Langer, Woosnam, Ballasteros, Olazabal and Harrington winning Major Championships in America,they also won at least one other over there which, as anyone who knows the game, is the toughest Tour in the World.
Monty could not even do that, and now Paul Casey has joined Lee Westwood, Daniel Chopra, Jesper Pernevik, and Darren Clarke amongst others who have possessed that extra something that it takes to win in the Premier Tour.
You can be the best golfer in the world, and still have a lousy Ryder Cup record - re Tiger Woods.
So, sorry Rock, your hero's legacy is spoiled in so many fans eyes because of his consistent petulant behaviour.
Errr, didn't he sulk off the Old Course and get in a car leaving his first wif, caddie and manager standing on the pavement wondering what was going on?
Well they were still standing wondering when the sulking Monty flew back down to London.
Yep, not quite the full shilling in certain ways.
10

Rock Lobster,

18/04/2009 23:09:52

Just an Opinion,

Monty is not my hero, as I have said his record in golf stands for its self.

Why does Monty attrackt a headline like the one above when he's not in the top 100, surly the leading golfers should have the headline.

Monty has had poor media coverage for the last 15 years, and for it to continue to follow him at the tail end of his carreer is pathetic.

There are and have been better golfers than Colin Montgomerie, but he's the best to come out of Scotland
for the last 20 years.

As for Monty sulking? tittle tattle.





11

Rock Lobster,

18/04/2009 23:33:36

I will be supporting Colin Montgomerie and his team at the next Ryder Cup. No amount of media tittle tattle will sway my support in the slightest.

Hopefully I wont be in the minority.

12

Just an opinion,

USA 18/04/2009 23:42:24
#10 and #11.Well I guess in some peoples eyes what we saw on television was not quite the way to go about it number one, and some will say not the conduct of a Ryder Cup Captain, number two.
But with television being what it is, we have all seen too many incidents like this, and unfortunately the guy himself has recognzed it having admitted some years back he sought help.
But again, we all have different opinions.
But having seen him stomp off past his manager, wife and caddie with a huge scowl and totally ignoring them, I can asssure you it is not tittle tattle.
13

Rock Lobster,

19/04/2009 02:46:03

Just an opinion/ The Judge.

What I've been trying to point out is Montgomerie's record, and the fact he has had negative media spin for far to long.

You on the other hand have called him a Jekyll and Hyde
and Arrogant Alfie,with a fragile streak between the ears, all below the belt stuff.

I'm not qualified to judge Monty on anything, you obviously are.

14

Just an opinion,

USA 19/04/2009 03:47:06
#13 Aye, and the others who posted.
Remember this is the guy who was playing in a tournament around three years ago when play was stopped with his ball in a horrendous position atop a bunker.
It was imperative he did the business in order to get into the top 50 or whatever, to make the Masters.
Out he came the next morning when play was resumed, and the whole world saw him place his ball quite differently from where it was the previous night.
Even Peter Alliss was quoted as saying he must have known it was not in the same spot as he had a much easier lie.
More than me have judged Monty on his antics as seen by millions on TV, it is not difficult, switch it on, and be the judge.
As I said in my first posting, it is almost a tragedy that a guy with so much talent could not do the business at the highest level because of a brittle temperament.
Facts are facts, he has blown it on the bigger stage, and like Perry and Campbell last week, choked on a shot at the 72nd hole of a Major when any other time it would have been meat and drink to a player of his calibre - a 7 iron to the green?
Hope you enjoy Wales, of course we will be on the same page at that event, but otherwise I am with the other postings, the guy just has a problem between the ears.
15

common sense voice,

19/04/2009 07:12:26
I tend to agree the others Rock Lobster. Golf is known to be 90% mental at their level. Many guys bottle it at the end. Tom Kite won loads of regular tournaments and only 1 major, bottle can be the only excuse, he knew the game inside out.
I know it is not the same, but I was a very good monday to friday player in my teens. Saturday medal came.. 5 to 10 strokes worse, temper would go, bang NR. My mental game was lacking, match play I could relax and beat almost anyone.

Seve once said.... best player, everyone on their A game... Sandy Lyle. I love Sandy but he never did a quarter of what he should have... mental game. SL should have more majors than Faldo.

Maybe not a fair thing to say, but Monty came from a middle class family, went to Uni, the works. He's never had a real job from what I know. He likely lacks that bit of edge, figher instinct, street wiseness that other guys have. Others are the same, Justin Rose springs to mind, indeed many GB players.

I can see him all charm and smooch at the start of the Ryder Cup, but something will happen. Camera man or worse still a player will not obey his rules, then big bad Monty will return.


16

Rock Lobster,

19/04/2009 08:53:55

Just an Opinion/The Judge/ Phyciatrist.

Do you agree or not, Monty has a good record in Golf, and that he gets very poor media coverage? also
what was the outcome of the misplaced ball story you mentioned, was Monty disqualified as the rules state?

Common Sense

I think most pro golfers come from a middle class background, I also think he will make a good Ryder Cup Captain, win or lose.
17

Just an opinion,

USA 19/04/2009 16:08:35
Rock Lobster: As posted more than once, Monty was a wonderful golfer, nobody disputes that.
As for the ball replacement incident, well the camera did not lie, and nobody as venerable a character as Peter Alliss would say Monty must have known he was not replacing it in the same position because he was standing in a totally different position the next day.
So you conclude, without media influence, that he got away with it for whatever reason.
But you saw the pictures on TV of where his ball was the night before, and where he replaced it the next day.
The official decision???? In light of the evidence, go figure.
Media coverage? Pictures don't lie, and they reported it as such.
And that's all I'm saying.
18

Rock Lobster,

19/04/2009 18:58:39
Just.

During the Indonesian Open play was suspended due to lightning.Monty did not mark his ball but left it where it lay.Play was then abandoned for the day.On returning to the hole the following day, Monty's ball was missing.After talks with his playing partners he replaced the ball where they thought it was left.


After he completed his round, he was called to the referees room, and after viewing TV pictures agreed he misplaced his ball.The referee's agreed with Colin that as he did not mark his ball the previous day, his error was an honest mistake,and no action was taken against him.
Colin Mongomerie donated his prize money of $45000 to charity and thought that the incident was over.

A couple of months later he was reprimanded by a players committee for his mistake.

Thats all from me on this topic so, bye.
19

Rock Lobster,

19/04/2009 19:14:48

My mistake Monty was not reprimanded by the players committie.
20

Cpt Caveman,

20/04/2009 16:58:14
Sad when the only thing that gets comments in the Scotsman Golf section is about Monty. There have been many incidents in the past about players making questionable actions. Palmer in the Masters, Player in the Open......there are a few. Question is - did Monty get a real advantage? Not really, so the only reason this is still a story is because it is Monty. I hope he stays around forever, love reading the anti Monty posts, great stuff and hilarious reading. The only reason he is still in the press is because he is such a media draw and there is no one else of interest in Scottish Golf to write about.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.