Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Monday, 8th September 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Hearts assure support new manager will arrive shortly



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 08 July 2008
HEARTS have assured supporters that a new manager will be in place "shortly" in what is described as an "update from the board" on the club's official website.
There is precious little additional information on the imminent appointment, although the statement does promise to communicate through "tangible actions" rather than "hollow words".

The club's search for a new manager began at the start of January when the club released another statement to inform supporters that the search for a new manager had begun.

Stephen Frail assumed a 'caretaker' role and had been set to fulfil an assistant's position next to the new manager, who, it was stressed, would preferably have had experience of working in British football. Seven months later Frail has been put on gardening leave and still no manager has been appointed, although Mark McGhee, the Motherwell manager, turned down an approach from Hearts owner Vladimir Romanov earlier in the summer. Also said to have been targeted by Romanov were Bratislava Artmedia coach Vladimir Weiss and Jurgen Rober, formerly of Hertha Berlin. But they, too, have resisted the offer to take over at Tynecastle.

With the new Scottish Premier League season now just over a month away speed is of the essence and the Hearts board is confident that an appointment will be made soon.

"A team manager will be appointed shortly and the board of directors is confident that this manager should improve the situation on the pitch," said the statement. "The board is taking all necessary actions so that the right appointment is made."

At the club's agm in April chairman Roman Romanov asked fans to give Frail a chance in the long-term, and added that it was "very difficult" to find a new manager. The last comment has been proved very true, with few fans then believing that the club would still be without a manager by the start of pre-season training – as was the case.

But fans have been urged to judge the board based on actions and not words. Despite the working relationship between Vladimir Romanov and his spokesman Charlie Mann having recently come to an end the statement has assured fans they will be kept informed of each new development at the club. Mann cited a lack of communication between Romanov and the club's supporters as a reason for ending his association with the Lithuanian-based businessman.

"The board of directors states its desire to communicate through tangible actions, not hollow words," the statement said. "Supporters will be able to judge the board based on actions, which is how it should be.

"As each step is completed supporters can be assured that full information will be announced – direct to supporters. The club will continue to implement the right decisions despite criticism from the sceptics."

How the debt for equity conversion will work at Tynecastle
ANALYSIS


A 'DEBT for equity' conversion works by doing exactly what it says. Debt is paid off in exchange for shares in the company. In other words, part of the company is given away.

The shares that are transferred in exchange for debt are new shares, meaning that the total number of issued shares increases. This dilutes existing shareholdings, but in Hearts' case, this does not matter. Vladimir Romanov controls the club with a majority shareholding already, and any other parties have a tiny minority interest. And it is on the same basis that the proposal will be passed at the extraordinary general meeting on 31 July, with Romanov using his majority shareholding to push through his own motion.

Tellingly, the increase in Romanov's shareholding makes no difference to his level of control at Tynecastle, which is absolute already. Power is not his motivation this time.

David Murray took a similar approach to debt management in 2005 when he underwrote a shares issue to reduce Rangers' debt by £50 million.

The figures announced by Hearts yesterday represent a straightforward equation. UBIG – Ukio Banko Invest Grupe – guarantee the club's current debt, which was last recorded at £36 million. UBIG will now be issued with 34,285,714 ordinary shares, and these shares have a nominal value of 35 pence each. This gives the allocation a book value of £12 million, which brings the club's debt down by one third to £24 million.

The reduction in debt will save Hearts £600,000 per year in interest charges. But more significantly, the new level of debt puts the company on firmer footing, which is essential if external finance is to be raised to fund the estimated £50 million cost of ground redevelopment at Tynecastle.

In April this year, it was reported that the club's liabilities exceeded its assets by £25 million. In their assessment of Hearts as a going concern, auditors Johnston Carmichael reported: "These conditions ... indicate the existence of a material uncertainty which may cast significant doubt about the company's ability to continue as a going concern."

The company's sustainability will now improve, but it is by no means out of the woods yet.

Overall, the move should reinforce Romanov's commitment to Hearts. The conspiracy theory that he will walk away and close the club is not consistent with writing off £12 million in exchange for what would be a worthless shareholding. Likewise, for those who fear Romanov is an asset stripper, the level of debt would still wipe out the proceeds of a ground sale.

Chris Robinson, who was chief executive of Hearts before Romanov's takeover in 2005, tried to sell Tynecastle Stadium to property developers to cover the club's debt, which then stood at £18 million. The unpopular proposal led to Robinson's demise.


The full article contains 945 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 07 July 2008 11:01 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Heart of Midlothian FC
 
1

r1niceboy,

yankeeland 08/07/2008 00:56:35
What in god's name is gardening leave? Shaggy, take two weeks, lay down some turf, here's a gnome, he's called Deividas!

Manager? Gimme a break!
2

r1niceboy,

yankeeland 08/07/2008 01:03:10
our new manager's last Job was the manager of Spinal Tap, betcha a dollar?
3

bring them on,

08/07/2008 01:33:42
So Ally McCloud is coming out of retirement after all.
4

Ghenkis Khan,

Edinburgh 08/07/2008 05:36:44
Only two scenarios are likely.

Romanov will hire a yes man who allows Mad Vlad to influence team selection and results be as bad as they were last season OR a proper manager is hired who picks his the team and then gets fired after a few months because Vlad can't stand not being able to play at being a football manager.

The onnl long-term solution is VLAD MUST GO!
5

Ghenkis Khan,

Edinburgh 08/07/2008 05:37:40
Only two scenarios are likely.

Romanov will hire a yes man who allows Mad Vlad to influence team selection and results be as bad as they were last season OR a proper manager is hired who picks his the team and then gets fired after a few months because Vlad can't stand not being able to play at being a football manager.

The only long-term solution is VLAD MUST GO!
6

bring them on,

08/07/2008 05:40:24
So what does make the implied value of all of the shares.

10 million or so?
7

doris karloff,

08/07/2008 06:45:41
Why are alarm bells not ringing yet?

HoMFC are now almost wholly owned by a bank, the shares are worth £10-15M and the debts £12 -26M. Further talk of the need to be profitable, releasing players who apparently had an £8M contract buy-out clause only recently bought ..........

Romanov bailed out to reduce his own exposure, I suspect in this time of the global credit crunch all is not rosy in the Romanov financial garden.......Have we got another Gretna in Scottish football?
8

,

08/07/2008 06:48:47
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
9

scorchio,

West of the Pecos 08/07/2008 07:17:27
Once again it is the terminology in the press release which reeks of ambiguity..."the new manager SHOULD improve results"!!!
A bit like that word "Prefferably", from the earlier release.
It should be made clear that he MUST take the club forward.
The worry now, must be about Vlad relinquishing his 20% interference.
So keen is he to keep a stranglehold on team matters that three managers have turned theior backs on us . (So far!)
10

,

08/07/2008 07:35:20
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
11

Edinburgh's Big Team,

EH11 08/07/2008 08:30:24
I cant believe there's folk on here who are claiming this to be a negative. £12m of debt has been reduced and the debt currently sits at circa £15m when income is up and the wage bill is massively reduced. Off the field is ticking along nicely but the appointment of a mangager needs to be this week and it needs to be the right appointment - no puppets
12

,

08/07/2008 08:38:28
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
13

Glorious Hearts,

08/07/2008 08:43:40
#12 spot on
Some people are idiots.

This is money that Hearts have spent and now don't have to pay back. How on earth is Romanov going to sell up and make a quick profit when he's just dropped ANOTHER few million in?

Get your heads out of the sand, the guy has ambition, imagination and hard cash. His methods leave a lot to be desired at times but he wants to develop Hearts, end of story.

Great news, if nothing more it's a huge sign of commitment to the club IMO
14

bring them on,

08/07/2008 08:47:30
Debt to Equity Swap= End of the line, just a matter of time
15

Glorious Hearts,

08/07/2008 08:49:22
#15 that doesn't even make any sense. You can't just throw words together and make a coherent argument. You lose.
16

bring them on,

08/07/2008 08:54:49
#16

I win, all Hearts fans lose.

Just putting it into easier words for you to understand.
17

Glorious Hearts,

08/07/2008 08:56:30
#17 Nah, you don't win just because you say.
You suck.
You lose.
You wrong.
You'll see.
18

Jam Tarts 1874,

On the Rebound 08/07/2008 08:58:49
#8. Here is a newsflash for you moron. UBIG are not a bank, UKIO Bankas is a very small part of UBIG's holdings.

How is Romanov reducing his exposure? You don't know what you are talking about!

Global credit crunch? What has this got to do with UBIG? I can't wait to hear your expert opinion! lol!!!

I bet you don't even know what the credit crunch is.
19

Jam Tarts 1874,

On the Rebound 08/07/2008 09:00:41
#15. Another financial "expert", you don't have a clue what you are talking about son.

Maybe you should just get your carer to help you switch off your PC and go and lick some windows.
20

bring them on,

08/07/2008 09:03:27
#18

Yes, I can see now why you had problems with some of the big words I used in my earlier post.

Need to keep it simple for you.

I'll try and remember that for next time.

Here's a wee starter to see how you get on.

Having a class manager (or a manager) can be a good thing.

Not losing loads of money every year is a good thing.

Having a few decent players is also a good thing.

Some food for thought for the Hearts fans?
21

Darwin's Shoe,

08/07/2008 09:07:01
#tw@t
'Debt to Equity Swap= End of the line, just a matter of time'

so that means your beloved rankgers only have a matter of time as they were the first to do it and for a shed lot more £50M.

now jog on
22

Glorious Hearts,

08/07/2008 09:15:12
#21 wow I've never been patronised by a retard before!

Trust me, I know a LOT more about Hearts's situation that you do. As a Hearts fan you'd kinda expect that wouldn't you?

Come back in five years' time. Hearts will still be here, stronger than ever. Until then, your petty arguments are hollow and lame and not worthy of any more discussion.

"Think" what you like, your disapproval and unhappiness is sustenance to me.
23

GrahamL,

08/07/2008 09:16:47
"The board of directors states its desire to communicate through tangible actions, not hollow words. Supporters will be able to judge the board based on actions, which is how it should be."

Which is what I've been saying we should do for the last year. We have no choice but to do so, and there's been little tangible in respect of a new boss. So nothing new here. Except Vlad clearly isn't planning on letting us in on his big plan any time soon. Sigh.
24

Who?,

08/07/2008 09:21:56
I'm no fan of vlad and would rather see his influence at tynecastle reduced, however this move is a very good one. This same move has been made at ibrox by murray and at darkheid by desmond, the difference is that the gfa's love children will always get good press especially from tabloid minded individuals who have never had an origional though in their lives. Imagine the sun or record doing your thinking- shame on you!

The debt on the books is reduced, in theory vlad accumulated the £12m debt by making poor decision- this is paying for that mistake. When the accounts are released for the financial year 2008/9 hearts debt will look a lot better than predicted.

Also there is no such thing as a "global" credit crunch- its a western credit crunch. In asia, russia and the middle east there are no the financial problems that are currently being encountered in europe or the america's. Certain people need to do a bit reading up before opening their rather odious stupid mouths!
25

The Falcon,

08/07/2008 10:09:37
"These conditions indicate the existence of a material uncertainty which may cast significant doubt about the company's ability to continue as a going concern." - says it all doesn't it

Juggling debt like a circus clown will NOT change the situation at Tynecastle.

#14 GH
"Get your heads out of the sand, the guy has ambition, imagination and hard cash. His methods leave a lot to be desired at times but he wants to develop Hearts, end of story". - correction, he just wants to develop Tyncastle.

We ( may I say, all decent followers of Scottish footie ) do not like to see what is happening to your club, but surely there is a line in the sand where your pride and common sense must be qestioned.



When are you gonna smell the coffee ?

What business / football club takes over six months to appoint a manager ?





26

Weel Kent Jambo,

08/07/2008 10:25:16
#26 To answer your last question - one that has been strung along for five of these months and led up the garden path by its preferred choice perhaps? But I agree taking too long for plan B.

Anyway Vlad has done with our debt exactly what Murray did with RFC, so was that bad too?
27

Glorious Hearts,

08/07/2008 10:33:43
#26 your arguments are nonsense. Why drop ANOTHER 12 million in if the plan is to develop tynecastle? Actually, don't answer, I'm not going to give your response any credence anyway.

You'll forgive me if your "concern" is ignored I'm sure. I look deeply into everything about Hearts- most non-Hearts fans read the headlines. and sometimes the stories too.

I know much much more about Hearts' situation that you cos I'm a fan. I'm obsessed with my club and want to know everything I can possibly find out.
And you know what? I'm comfortable with the financial situation.

Could. Not. Care. Less about what ANY fan of ANY other club thinks.
28

bring them on,

08/07/2008 10:46:31
Hard to believe that there are still some die hard fans who think this is good news....
29

hibbyspurs,

08/07/2008 11:56:11
shesh...

The art of open debate is obviously dead and buried on these forums...
30

Jamboy,

Edinburgh 08/07/2008 11:56:28
#8

I'm sorry but I just can't let the bitter disapointment shrouded by desperation from Doris slip by unchallenged...

"Overall, the move should reinforce Romanov's commitment to Hearts. The conspiracy theory that he will walk away and close the club is not consistent with writing off £12 million in exchange for what would be a worthless shareholding. Likewise, for those who fear Romanov is an asset stripper, the level of debt would still wipe out the proceeds of a ground sale." (Johnston Carmichael)

Please could you state your case in response to the above opinions of the reputable auditor above... Please provide your rebuttle.

I wait on tenterhooks!
31

Pazuzu,

08/07/2008 11:58:26
Scary stuff!

GGTTH
32

Roscoe P Coltrane,

08/07/2008 12:31:29
#29 - hard to believe there are still some no-marks who think this is bad news.

Let me summarise:

Overall debt reduced
Overall shareholding diluted, but as Vlad directly or indirectly owns c95% of the shares, who gives a flying?
Vlad puts more money into Hearts at a time when he's allegedly "asset stripping" or running the club into the ground according to everybody that isn't a JT.

Yes, Vlad is a pr!ck, no, he doesn't know how to treat people in an honourable way, and no, he also doesn't have the first idea of what makes a decent footballer.

However, how is any of this bad news? Especially as, as other posters have pointed out, both Old Firm teams have done exactly the same (although for larger debt amounts) in recent years?

Go on Bring Them On, what's the negative there?
33

jamtart,

Beechboro Western Australia 08/07/2008 13:02:27
The RR thunders on BELIEVE

mon the JT'S

Eflsborg HA HA HA sounds just like hibs, small team.
34

AJ Fife,

08/07/2008 15:16:17
Radio Scotland have just announced that Stevie Archibald is being interviewed for the Jam Tarts jobs.

The East Fife legend could indeed be the man to turn the Edinburgh giant's fortunes around!
35

,

08/07/2008 15:33:29
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
36

LyonHearts,

le teil 08/07/2008 16:45:19
Seems like nothing but good news coming out of Tynie at the moment!

I think Frail needs a new hairstyle by the way!
37

Joak,

San Diego 08/07/2008 17:54:20
According to BBC Sport....Romanov would accept offers for the club.....Sir Sean and Billy Connoly, do us a favor and git rid of the galloot with some of your "loot". Do Scotland a favour, and bring some heart into the Hearts again.
38

Xacobeo Hearts,

Santiago de Compostela, but not feeling very holy! 08/07/2008 20:11:18
Ah right, so we've to judge the "board" on actions not words!

Well I'm more than happy to do that...

Weighed
Concluded
...and judged.

And for me, guilty on almost every single count I'm afraid to inform you Mr V Rom..erm "Board".

And as we all know the punishment HAS to fit the crime, and the crimes that you have subjected my football club to are legion.

So for the sentencing I'll just have to check to see if being Hung, Drawn and Quartered is still somewhere on the statute books. That should almost do it for thoroughly deserved down right nastiness.

Then again, on second thought maybe we could take a leaf out of our glorious leaders namesake's book. You know the one that inspired the Dracula legends and did absolutely unspeakable things to his subjects with stakes???

And that very adequately sums up my feelings on this particular case M'lud.
39

,

08/07/2008 20:39:00
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
40

Weel Kent Jambo,

08/07/2008 21:39:58
#40 Wrong again my cuious little friend - in fact Hearts humped everyone at one time or another last season. Had your access revoked yet again? Oh dear how sad what a shame never mind
41

GrahamH,

Edinburgh 08/07/2008 22:06:41
The website says someone will be in place soon.

The interview today with Romanov, when he went on again about a Scottish Mafia in football, said that there was no-one on the horizon but they wouldn't be Scottish.

The football doesn't matter to Romanov for 2 or 3 years until hge gets his building plans into place. Said it for 18 months, is great business sense but does nothing for the fans in the short to medium term.
42

Roscoe P Coltrane,

09/07/2008 10:02:49
Lovely to see all our resident street-sweepers and doleites have such a great grasp on corporate finance, it fills me with confidence for the country's future when people with no knowledge or experience are still able to see through Vlad's dastardly plans!

I'll reiterate. The man is a c*ck of the highest order, who needs a good kick up the backside and to learn the value of showing one's customers a bit of respect. However, I don't believe for one second he's mental enough to put £12m into a 'failing' project.
43

Roscoe P Coltrane,

09/07/2008 10:05:11
#39 - and I thought you couldn't get any less credible. For once quite glad to be proved wrong.

Did you manage to get into the high school your parents wanted then?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Features

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.