Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Hamilton 0 - 1 Falkirk: Arfield puts safety in Falkirk's grasp

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 14 May 2009
FALKIRK climbed off the bottom of the SPL table for the first time in two months last night to put themselves within touching distance of securing their top-flight status for another year.
Scott Arfield's magnificent goal after an hour of a predictably tense contest was enough to beat a Hamilton Accies side who lacked a cutting edge to match their often more fluent football.

John Hughes' side have now taken seven points from their
first three post-split fixtures and will be safe from the threat of relegation if they defeat St Mirren at the Falkirk Stadium on Saturday.

Last night's defeat leaves Hamilton still in danger of the drop and they will head to Motherwell this weekend looking for at least a point to remove themselves from the equation.

Hughes believes his team's progress to the Scottish Cup final has been the key factor in their success in climbing off the foot of the table. "I think we have got the momentum now," said Hughes. "Getting to the Scottish Cup final was a real shot in the arm for us, the team have grown in confidence. I asked my boys a few weeks ago to put the situation into our own hands and that's what they have done."

Hamilton manager Billy Reid was again left to rue his side's bluntness in attack.

"I felt we deserved a point over the 90 minutes, but it's a great result for Falkirk," observed Reid. "Our destiny is still in our own hands, we are in a good position and we have the belief we will get what we need."

Hughes' reluctance to make any concessions to attacking football regardless of his team's predicament was evident once more as he deployed them in what was effectively a 4-2-4 formation. His bold approach recognised Falkirk's need for victory but his team struggled to secure enough possession to make it work with any great effect.

Arfield and Kevin McBride, the visitors' central midfield players, were often overrun as Hamilton dictated the tempo of the match for lengthy periods.

If James McCarthy had been at all distracted by Portsmouth's failed £500,000 bid to sign him this week, it didn't show as the Republic of Ireland under-21 international returned to the Accies starting line-up.

The PFA Scotland Young Player of the Year was prominent in much of his team's best work as they stretched the Falkirk defence, linking up cleverly with Brian Easton down the left to carve out the first clear opening of the night.

Neil McCann, who along with Carl Finnigan was required to track back from the attacking wide positions to reinforce the Falkirk defence, effected a good clearance when McCarthy delivered a threatening cross.

Mark McLaughlin could have given Hamilton an early lead when an Easton corner picked him out, but the big defender was unable to climb high enough as he sent his header over the crossbar.

More terrific work between McCarthy and Easton then presented Paul McGowan with an opportunity on the edge of the six yard box, but the on-loan Celtic striker took too long trying to set himself up for a shot and the chance was lost.

As the play continued to flow mainly one way, Falkirk goalkeeper Dani Mallo was at full stretch to touch Easton's sweetly struck 22 yard shot over for a corner. Steven Pressley then resorted to desperate measures in a bid to lessen McCarthy's influence on proceedings, the veteran defender rightly booked by referee Mike McCurry for a cynical foul on the teenager who had pushed the ball beyond him.

It was Pressley who was presented with Falkirk's first sniff of a chance when he headed a McCann free-kick over the crossbar and Falkirk almost snatched an unlikely lead on the stroke of half-time when Michael Higdon headed Finnigan's cross narrowly wide of Tomas Cerny's left hand post.

Hamilton were forced to make a change early in the second half when Richard Offiong limped off to be replaced by Joel Thomas and the substitute was given a rude introduction to proceedings when he was fouled by Pressley. The home support screamed for a second yellow card to be administered to the Scotland coach who had certainly led with his arm in making the challenge, but the referee decided a free-kick for Hamilton was sufficient punishment.

Having failed to translate their control of possession into anything tangible, Hamilton were running the risk of the match turning away from them and they were fortunate not to concede a penalty kick in the 57th minute. McCann raced onto Higdon's flick-on and as he looked to push the ball beyond Cerny, he appeared to be blatantly taken out by the goalkeeper.

But to the bewilderment of the Falkirk players and supporters, Mr McCurry saw nothing amiss and waved play on. The visitors soon forgot their sense of injustice, however, when Falkirk took the lead just three minutes later.

Cerny made a fine save to block Finnigan's shot as Hamilton found themselves stretched at the back and the ball broke to Arfield on the edge of the penalty area. The Scotland B international still had much to do but he was more than up to the task as, to the delight of the travelling fans behind Cerny's goal, he curled in a terrific left foot shot which beat Cerny off the inside of the keeper's right-hand post.

Hamilton sent on Kenny Deuchar for McGowan in an attempt to vary their attacking options and the substitute immediately carved out an opportunity for Thomas who wastefully headed the cross over from close range. McCarthy , less influential in the second half, volleyed narrowly over from a tight angle as Hamilton tried to get back on the front foot.

Hamilton: Cerny, Gibson (Taylor 73), Canning, McLaughlin, Easton, Neil, Mensing, McCarthy, McClenahan, Offiong (Thomas 54), McGowan (Deuchar 66). Subs not used: Murdoch, Swailes, Lyle, Asamoah. Booked: Taylor.

Falkirk: Dani Mallo, Bullen, Pressley, Barr, Scobbie, Finnigan, Arfield, McBride (O'Brien 59), McCann, Lovell (Riera 77), Higdon. Subs not used: Olejnik, Holden, Cregg, Aafjes, Mitchell. Booked: Scobbie, Pressley.

Referee: M McCurry





The full article contains 1036 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

,

14/05/2009 00:05:40
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

Shantaram,

14/05/2009 00:06:33
Urgent memo to Derek Riordan: Return to Celtic - Mission accomplished.
3

The Kids Are Alright,

14/05/2009 00:25:52
#1

Naw, it's just more tense now.


Goal difference on the last day....
4

The Kids Are Alright,

14/05/2009 00:27:16
#3

DV

Is that you officialy out of hibernation then.


Think about it....


5

Shape to Shoot,

14/05/2009 00:29:59
Sore one for the rangers fans, very , very sore. They say pride comes before a fall, and well, I don't think many would argue with that tonight.
A win against The Scottish Champions on Saturday at a rain soaked ibrox had convinced them that the title was there for the taking.

On Tuesday night, they watched anxiously as Dundee U put Celtic through the ringer for 30 minutes in the second half, but in the end, failed to take points.
Never mind thought the rangers fanz, we'll take the hi-beez nae bo'er....Alas.... 4 in a row has come back sharply into focus, and rangerz are in trouble.

They threw the kitchen sink at hibz, but could muster only a draw...the donz come along on Saturday having had an extra day's rest and a not nearly so exhausting a match to recover from...Weir, Dailly, Mendes...none of them spring chickens...how will they be feeling after 70 minutes on Saturday ? The dons generally don't win at ibrox, but they can on occassion take a point...and I suppose, their abysmal record at ibrox will come to an end some day....
6

,

14/05/2009 00:50:57
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
7

Shantaram,

14/05/2009 00:59:14
I think Celtic have just been toying with Rangers - allowing them to go top for a few days just to give them a taste of what they are missing, then BANG, Celtic leapfrog them again and stay there till the bitter end. It's kinda cruel really, but I love it.

There is no way Rangers will take 3 points at Tannadice.
8

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:10:34
Whoahhhhh!!!!!!!!!!!!
lets not mention the 'goal'!
As a Gers fan makes it interesting, level on points, 3-9 gers on sat, 1-0 septic on sunday, all is square!
88th minute in the last game septic score, at tannadice its 0-0!
89th minute the multiple world record holding Gers score!
who wins?
All tied.
Points.
Goal dif.
Down to the OF games........
9

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:13:26
Incidently, was working so only saw the last 30 mins or so, happened to watch it in a pub that is majority of sellick fans.
Not one disagreed that it was a goal.
But its done now, makes it interesting, loke i said.
Oh, and does anyone still think that the 'bigot; with the IRA flag didnt know who his butds uncle was & where his ticket came from?
10

,

14/05/2009 01:13:39
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
11

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:14:35
C'mon, wheres the debate?
12

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:16:13
#13
really?
lets talk bottle.
not kid on bottle but the last 2 times its been this close with a level playing field, whose bottle crashed?
13

,

14/05/2009 01:16:58
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
14

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:17:29
the 3-9 is a typo, 3-0 gers
15

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:19:47
Lets not pretend, it was over the line. But, like I said, makes it interesting.
Your right, Hibs was a good goal, both of ours were arthur montford stramsh's!
But hey, dont true world record holders just grind it out?
16

,

14/05/2009 01:20:50
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
17

Daillyman,

14/05/2009 01:22:01
6 Patrick

After Saturday the title was there for the taking.

Level on points 2 goal advantage to the tic with 2 matches left, the league is not over yet.

Maximum points required from 2 remaining fixtures with a few goals scored. I dont like the split, but it is making the league finish interesting.
18

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:24:05
#19
as I said, was working, I know its a foriegn concept at the san giro but I didnt see the full game, only the last 30 mins, if novo had been match sharp then different conversation tonight, no doubt all threads would be closed, not that you would be on anway.....
19

,

14/05/2009 01:24:44
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
20

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:25:13
Daily,

even the bottom 6, no one apart from motherwellis safe now!
21

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:27:00
#22 fair enough,
however if from a 2yrd angle from one sied you can see posts & net on the other with no sign of the ball its over.
Dont get me wrong, if it were you, I would feel the same
22

The Kids Are Alright,

14/05/2009 01:27:11
No point in whinging about the goal that wasn't given.

It wasn't. End of story.

Like Dailly says, it's not over yet.

Hope that Miller is fit for the last two games, though.
23

,

14/05/2009 01:27:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
24

The Kids Are Alright,

14/05/2009 01:28:30
#22

Aye, and he changed it at H-T, too.
25

,

14/05/2009 01:28:43
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
26

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:28:49
Not whinging, just stating a fact.
Read the original post, makes it interesting, 3-0 gers on sat, 1-0 tic on sun..........
27

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:30:17
#26
Mendes & Lafferty, sorry but I know you lot & facts....
28

The Kids Are Alright,

14/05/2009 01:30:40
McCoist will have lost a bit more hair last night.

Did you see him in the rain at the Celtic game.

He'll be needing to do a wee Bobby Charlton before long.


And for one so young....
29

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:31:07
#28
who cares bad call, but interesting now.
3-0 gers.
1-0 celts.
who wins?
30

Daillyman,

14/05/2009 01:31:59
25 bto

Hammer the sheep at Ibrox, Jimmy might let us score 6,lol.

The tic beat the Hibs 2-1 and we lead on goal average with United to play.
31

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:32:07
Its all looped around his waist making him seem fat so he can come in with a skin head in the last 2 games & score 30 each match!
32

,

14/05/2009 01:32:44
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
33

The Kids Are Alright,

14/05/2009 01:33:10
#32

Correct, Rangers would take the title having the better record against Celtic.
34

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:33:16
#33
would love taht but see it as 3-= for us, 1-0 for them.
Incidently, well done falkirk
35

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:34:03
#35
Whoever it was was possessed by the spirit of cardinal winning!
36

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:34:55
#36
but none will admit it!
37

,

14/05/2009 01:35:51
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
38

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:36:06
Sorry to the sellick fans,
I know I should be greeting on my pillow, BUT, aint over yet, like I said on sat night!
Didnt gloat, was merely optomistic....
39

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:36:41
#40
best you can come up with?
40

Shape to Shoot,

14/05/2009 01:37:46
39

Isn't it the team that has scored the most goals that wins if the goal difference is all square ?

If both teams have scored the same number of goals, then it goes to the head to heads methinks.
41

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:38:58
Time for a song....
42

Daillyman,

14/05/2009 01:39:04
38

Strange last year these threads were full with posters talking about the favours the Gers receive from match officials. Looking back to earlier in the season and some of the decisions that went the way of the tic, St.Mirren and United matches come to mind, then us having the goal at Aberdeen chalked off for a non offside call. Chr*st I had better stop this I am starting to sound like a tic supporter. lol
43

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:40:02
Nope, thats UFEA!
Here its record against then most goals
44

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:41:08
#45
Paranoia is only imagined, conspiracy has factual proof over a period of time....
45

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:42:10
such as the extension of the league & moving the cup final date in 67.....
46

Daillyman,

14/05/2009 01:42:13
43 Patrick

I think if both sides are level on points at seasons end, we should have a one game play off. We need the money.lol
47

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:42:53
Loovens staying on the park with no EGM called to ban him.....
48

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:43:14
MacDonald (see above).......
49

Shape to Shoot,

14/05/2009 01:43:34
Anyways, I had hitherto written off the dons' chances on Saturday...but after tonight, I think you'd have to say things are looking a bit brighter for them.

Rangers will be gutted after tonight's result, absolutely gutted....and knackered. Aberdeen were well beaten 3v1 by the champions 11 days ago, but several top players (now returned) were out through injury and suspension. They loathe and detest rangers as a rule and will be keenly determined to spoil the party at ibrox, just as they spoiled things for them at pittodrie last season.

Tonight's result was a real kick on the nachos for rangers, leaving a dull ache that will linger...Aberdeen will smell blood.
50

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:43:42
Robson (last year, see above).....
51

,

14/05/2009 01:43:57
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
52

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:44:12
Hartley (last season, see above).....
53

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:46:50
#52
Jimmy C & Jimmy Nic?
Sense blood?
Behave!
54

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:47:37
will be last day & whoever wins, most likely on GD will be the slightly better of a whole pile of shi...........
55

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:48:51
as for a play off?????
WHERE?
Imagine the polis with that????
56

Daillyman,

14/05/2009 01:48:58
Nite lads
57

,

14/05/2009 01:49:14
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
58

Shape to Shoot,

14/05/2009 01:49:22
46

Well the spl must have changed the rules since 2003, as although rangers won by just one goal, it was pointed out that even if Celtic scored another against killie, that wouldn't have been enough because rangers had scored more.
Celtic needed to be a goal ahead of rangers in 2003 to avoid losing the title...I think Celtic did better in the head to heads that season...fairly certain of that.
59

,

14/05/2009 01:50:55
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
60

Bemused and above it all,

14/05/2009 01:51:13
Anyway,
its late,
im working in the morning (thats paid employmetnt & purposeful non-criminal activituy to the San Giro comunity),
As such I say,
Goodnight,
and











As I was walking down the Copland Road.....
61

The Kids Are Alright,

14/05/2009 01:55:03
#61

Record against. Check your rule book.

Meanwhile, Rangers are working on their attacking line for the Aberdeen game.

Boyd has shown that we does best in his new defensive, mid-field, attacking role.

With Miller fit and Lafferty burning up turf, Novo always good for a goal or two, it's hard to be too concerned.
62

Shantaram,

14/05/2009 01:56:33
Bemused - Yes, it was a goal. The ball was in, but them's the breaks. Rangers had enough chances apart from that.

As for same points and same goal difference, the team with the higher number of goals scored is the winner. If THAT is all square, then it goes to a play-off.
63

Shantaram,

14/05/2009 02:04:52
If it were to go to a play-off, it wouldn't be any more of a headache for the police than a Celtic v Rangers end-of-season Scottish Cup Final at Hampden.
64

The Kids Are Alright,

14/05/2009 02:12:53
#65

I thought it was a to#s of the coin?
65

Shantaram,

14/05/2009 02:15:24
Anyway, a play-off is highly unlikely. Let's say Celtic beat Hibs and Hearts the minimum score of 1-0. That would make their goal difference 49 with 82 goals scored. For it to go to a replay, Rangers would need to win both their games by a margin of 4 goals, giving them also a goal difference of 49, but to ensure the same number of goals scored, Rangers would need to score a total of 10 goals in their 2 games, meaning an aggregate of 10-6, eg 5-3 v Aberdeen and 5-3 v Dundee United.

So forget a play-off. It can't happen.

Again, if Celtic were to win 1-0 and 1-0, Rangers would need to win by 5 goals over their 2 games to take the title on goal difference, eg 2-0 and 3-0 minimum.

So bottom line is, Celtic can only throw it away now, just like Rangers before last night.

A thrilling finish whatever happens.
66

The Kids Are Alright,

14/05/2009 02:28:23
It could be over by the weekend, but it won't be.

The story was written that way.

Who are the refs for the weekend games.

Anyone know?
67

Shantaram,

14/05/2009 02:28:53
Just lifted this from the SPL website, for anyone still doubting what I have said:

A6.3 If any two or more Clubs are equal in points at the end of the Season, the higher placed Club shall be the Club with the larger or largest positive goal
difference (or the lower or lowest negative goal difference where appropriate). Goal difference shall be determined by deducting the goals conceded from
the goals scored in all League Matches played during the Season. In the event of the goal difference being equal, the higher placed Club shall be the Club which has scored most goals in League Matches during the Season.

A6.4 If two or more Clubs have the same goal difference and have scored the same number of goals in the relevant Season and their positions in the League have a bearing on deciding which Club is the Champion Club or the relegation of any Club or qualification (or consideration for qualification) for any other competitions including UEFA Competitions, then the Clubs concerned shall play-off a deciding League Match on a date and at a neutral ground as determined by the Board in each case. Such deciding League Match shall be of 90 minutes duration with 30 minutes of extra time and kicks from the penalty mark if necessary.
68

Shantaram,

14/05/2009 02:32:55
I agree BTO. It will go down to the final day. I'd rather face Hearts at home than go to Tannadice, that's for sure.
69

The Kids Are Alright,

14/05/2009 02:32:58
From the Wee Red Book, in case anyone is in doubt.

"The team with the best record against the other one takes the trophy, and that is the rule so there is no doubt here."
70

The Kids Are Alright,

14/05/2009 02:34:38
#71

Can't argue there.

Will come down to luck, guts, weather conditions, refs, injuries, and to a much smaller extent, good football.
71

Shantaram,

14/05/2009 03:22:40
Wee Red Book? I thought you were in Japan, not China.
72

The Kids Are Alright,

14/05/2009 03:28:27


None of your "SPL web sites" for me. The Wee Red Book has more useful information per page than the AA Book of the Road.
73

The Kids Are Alright,

14/05/2009 06:53:03
Stuart Dougal to referee the Rangers game......


Ian Brines for the Celtic match.

Can only hope that weather conditions go our way.
74

,

14/05/2009 09:57:17
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
75

,

14/05/2009 10:02:39
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
76

Shape to Shoot,

14/05/2009 10:08:58
Who would want to be a rangers fan this morning ? Who would wish to be carrying the burden of 'paradise lost' ?

Berz wi' sore heads and belly-aches aujourd'hui methinks. If Celtic make it 4 in a row, this has been the season from hell for rangers fans. Their title hopes have been un 'n' doon like a wh ore's drawers since the start of the season....and for long, long periods, it's looked as though the title was virtually gone.

Then came Ibrox, and for the first time in a long time, rangers topped the spl and looked favourites to lift the title....the agony seemed over....rangers' fans even managed to squeeze in the odd non-racist song in celebration of a forthcoming title...now that is saying something .

But then came Easter road...rangers fans had reckoned it a banker that they'd bring three points back to glasgow...Alas....they squint their eyes at the table, and , on reflection of the remaining fixtures, exhale deeply through the nose, their faces etched in thunderous hues. Thoughts of 4 in a row, recently thought to be on their death bed, are alive and kicking.
77

,

14/05/2009 10:14:56
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
78

,

14/05/2009 10:17:19
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
79

Shape to Shoot,

14/05/2009 10:20:54
80

But if you genuinely felt that way, Celtic would have had two penalties at ibrox...and you're brief moment of joy at the top of the table might never have come to pass....perhaps, that would have been kinder alas.

My oh my....rangers missed so many chances to score last night....I suppose had any of the half dozen or so chances gone in, you wouldn't be reaching for the atomic microscope this morning in some hysterical forensic analysis of a video recording.

Bit more quality in the finish and you wouldn't be needing to go these rather extraordinary lengths.
80

,

14/05/2009 10:31:04
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
81

,

14/05/2009 10:32:17
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
82

TM, they'll never take away my freedom,

14/05/2009 11:45:48
If Celtic blow it now then they really don't deserve to be champions.

All eyes on Ibrox saturday, to witness another Calderwood capitulation.
83

TM, they'll never take away my freedom,

14/05/2009 12:49:45
morning vincent,

Do u think Calderwood will roll over?
84

,

14/05/2009 13:04:44
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
85

Fitba Krazy,

14/05/2009 13:07:04
Trombolt #19 The only problem with that is they are NOT pensioners are they? They are in their 20's and 30's as "pensioners" don't get a game in Scotland even when they are faster and two-footed compared with the many slow motion, one-footed funny hand-shakers who riddle Scottish football and contribute to the laughing stock we have become. Get them out and give their place to the REAL footballers they are Sooo jealous of because at even 50 odd years old they could show them how its done no bother at all.

Well done Falkirk and Hamilton look like they'll stay up anyway. Out with the bigots and ageist muppets, that's what I say.
86

Daillyman,

14/05/2009 13:20:35
86

It is quiet, the threads are similar to early in the week. I suppose results do matter.

2 dropped points last night have put the tic on top by plus 2 goals. Should be a great final 2 matches.

Anyone heard from Finnharp?
87

theguru,

14/05/2009 13:24:53
Great goal from riorden. Another one against celtic could be a big finger up and player of the month. Exactly the reason we bought him. Amazing what happens when this squad are played in the positions they were intended for. Bamba had his best game in a hibs jersey but always a worry when he gets booked- possible MotM. The 'goal' claim was 50/50 in my opinion so could not be given, the linesman was in the best place to call this, and made the right one.

Could mixu be getting the hand of this manager thing at last?

88

TM, they'll never take away my freedom,

14/05/2009 13:26:09
91 Brian

Do you think that's Rangers blown it. Or do you think there's more twists and turns.

89

TM, they'll never take away my freedom,

14/05/2009 13:27:01
90

I think Trombolt was quoting Richard Gough re "pensioners football"
90

,

14/05/2009 13:27:10
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
91

Daillyman,

14/05/2009 13:30:15
92

Riorden did take his goal well, the lad can score from anywhere, as for the non goal to tough to say if it was in and we get replays on the telly.

If referee/linesman were unsure all the ball crossed the line the correct decision was made.
92

Daillyman,

14/05/2009 13:33:59
93

Could be another upset on the cards, just looking at the things that have happened already this season, both OF sides lack top class quality and have been upset more than once this season, you never know!!

I dont like the split, but the matches have been exciting.
93

TM, they'll never take away my freedom,

14/05/2009 13:38:42
97 Brian

Why don't you like the split?

94

TM, they'll never take away my freedom,

14/05/2009 13:40:02
96 Brian

Don't you think a fairer rule would be if most of the ball is over the line?

Last night 95-99% of the ball was over the line.
95

Daillyman,

14/05/2009 13:42:15
98

I would prefer a larger SPL with 18 teams, home and away against one another. I find it to be be a bit boring seeing 4 or 5 league matches between the same sides, and even more with cup ties thrown in. Only my opinion.
96

Daillyman,

14/05/2009 13:47:09
99

I have no problem with the rule as it stands, the whole ball must be over the line.

With the technology they have today I would not be against a referee chief in the video replay booth to assist the referee in making decisions like that, if still inconclusive then its a no goal. The decision making time would be quicker than some players lying on the park faking injury.
97

,

14/05/2009 13:50:19
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
98

Daillyman,

14/05/2009 13:54:33
102

I dont think so, I saw the replay numerous times and still dont know if the entire ball was over the line. Hence with video replay it must be conclusive evidence that the ball crossed the line completely. I think the technology will be used, and probably start at the world cup in the near future.
99

TM, they'll never take away my freedom,

14/05/2009 14:03:31
Saturday now becomes a day of monumental proportions.

Rangers need to win by THREE goals in my opinion to have any chance.

If not and they lose the title, then the repercussions could be very grave indeed.

If Rangers don't get into the CL proper - the money lost will be too much to bear (no pun intended, add to this the banks closing in, the squad up for sale, the owner wanting to sell.

Saturday takes on a magnitude not seen since the days when Celtic faced going to the wall.

Rangers fans must be praying (even the heathen ones) that they can win this title. Celtic can afford to lose it - Rangers on the other might be staring into the abyss if this one slips away.
100

,

14/05/2009 14:48:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
101

Daillyman,

14/05/2009 14:51:26
104

So the tic can afford to lose the title?

If you are talking just money you may be correct, but to lose the league to RFC!!! After leading the league twice by 7 points, would not sit well

I have a feeling most of your fellow tic supporters would not agree with you.
102

,

14/05/2009 14:58:04
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
103

Daillyman,

14/05/2009 15:06:34
107

Almost a perfect day.

Shot an 87 my best 18 holes ever, disappointing result, but food was good(Chinky delivery), the wife never cooked.

Loads of rain today though. Looking forward to Saturday, 6-0 for the Gers and a job for life for Jimmy C.lol
104

,

14/05/2009 15:11:06
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
105

Daillyman,

14/05/2009 15:14:06
109

Definitely an 87, it was a good bluenose that signed my card.
106

Boyne Bhoy,

Off to the Irish Open 14/05/2009 16:09:30
Daillyman, bet you were particularly happy your best ever score wasn't 88! Keep going for a 73!
107

The Kids Are Alright,

14/05/2009 16:36:08
What a day... Lost my bag on the subway.

Had my wallet with my life savings in it, and my Wee Red Book.


Thankfully, I got the valuable stuff back.

Still not given up hope that the wallet my will reappear, too.
108

Boyne Bhoy,

14/05/2009 16:46:48
Games v the Sjheepies are always a bit 'strange' always have the feeling the Coaches would cope with a loss being 'good' Gers men but half the team support the Tic and the fans loathe the Gers-think if they put in a below Par(!) performance it would kick off big time!

Personally going to do a Denis Law and avoid the game by going to the Irish Open-if monty makes the cut i may have to wind him up....
109

,

14/05/2009 17:12:23
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
110

Fitba Krazy,

14/05/2009 18:26:42
# 94 TM, they'll never take away my freedom,

I gathered that Trombolt was not only quoting Richard "the water sprinkler beat me" Gough who should know better, but was also agreeing with him. If Rangers were playing slowly then he should simply say Rangers were too slow instead of stereotyping older players when there are older players around who could teach them how to put the ball in the net more often than the opposition which is what the game is really about more than anything else, or should be. If you have most of the possession and pressurise the opposition without scoring more than them it is hardly the fault of older players who are not even on the park but who should be in certain cases.

# 95 Hail Hail the Riot Survivor. I don't agree with you at all. D Riordan is obviously good enough to stop Rangers winning by being the goalscorer against them in a 1-1 so he obviously IS good enough at the top level AND he is well known for scoring regularly with either foot. I don't know why he could hardly get a game for Celtic, but that's the way it goes sometimes, especially with strikers, apparently, for some weird reason. Ask Kris Boyd and Ally McCoist if you don't believe me, they'll know what I mean I should think.
111

TM, they'll never take away my freedom,

14/05/2009 20:43:00
116

Sorry I can't remember Jess scoring the winner at Ibrox - I recall him scoring a screamer in a 1-1 draw. think that was the game Gazza was headbutting players in the rib cage.
112

TM, they'll never take away my freedom,

14/05/2009 21:13:20
119

What's funny is al the HOO HAA about technology...this coming all because ONE decsion has gone against Rangers - even though the decision was the correct one.

What about all the other clubs including Celtic who have suffered decisions going against them, when the decisions made by the ref was in fact wrong. What happened to all the media demands for new technology and new rules then???

This furore is all because it's Rangers. If the could get away with insisting the opposition must wear leg irons when playing against them then they would do it. Rangers fans and their club have to start learning the principles of sport - and forget this unhealthy win at all cost attitude.



113

TM, they'll never take away my freedom,

14/05/2009 21:14:30
Last night Daft Chick Young and Billy Boy Dodds showed themselves up for the biased bigots they are.

Do yourself a favour BBC - get rid of them!
114

Daillyman,

14/05/2009 23:46:53
121

What is bigoted about a pundit having an opinion?

I will say the referee and linesman got the decision correct in my opinion the entire ball never crossed the line.
115

The Kids Are Alright,

15/05/2009 00:14:40
Was the ball moving or not when it "crossed" the line.

For me, that's the key point
116

Daillyman,

15/05/2009 02:59:00
124 dv

Yes I have listened to them, and I did not hear their comments after the goal in question.

A former RFC player who had a cup of tea at Ibrox when tricky Dick was there, has an opinion, and is called a bigot.

Sad that people who dont follow a certain party line, or have a different point of view are classed as bigots.

ps. If you dont like them dont listen to them.
117

Fitba Krazy,

15/05/2009 18:56:18
#121 They didn't sound bigoted at all. Billy Dodds was trying his best to make all those sitters being missed sound exciting as commentators do and Chick Young seemed more worried about St. Mirren. Dodds thought the ball had crossed the line but that doesn't make him a bigot.
Anyway Novo had a few easy chances to score before he did and muffed them big time. Typical boring Scottish football game that ended up a boring 1-1 draw. Big Deal.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.