Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Ayr 21 - 7 Currie: Ayr manage to Climo all over Currie

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 08 November 2009
THIS was a result that Premier One needed. Ayr reduced Currie's advantage in the league such that the Edinburgh side remain on top but only thanks to their much superior points difference.
The match started with an early dust up between the two sets of forwards but after that Ayr made much the better fist of things, largely thanks to Frazier Climo. The flyhalf scored 16 points with three penalties, a conversion and a try. Not a bad
afternoon's work for someone who was so badly concussed last week at West of Scotland that he had to be carted from the field.

Currie can blame themselves for playing some brainless rugby but they weren't helped by a crucial injury one quarter of the way through the match when playmaker Andrew Binikos was stretchered off the field with a broken ankle. It may have made the difference because Currie had to rejig half their backline and Johnny Smith moved from fullback to flyhalf, where he was comprehensively outplayed by his opposite number, Climo, whose kicking from hand was the main difference between the two teams.

Currie drew first blood within five minutes of kick-off, although Chris Kinloch will still be pondering just how he managed to evade the five defenders who had him surrounded. Binikos took the ball up to the line and the Glasgow professional picked a line into the heart of the Ayr defence, which immediately downed tools. Any pretense at tackling Kinloch amounted to no more than a hearty slap on his back as he powered past. That proved Currie's first and their last score.

Ayr were roused from their slumbers and after that early shock the traffic was mostly one way, heading towards the Currie line. When Climo wasn't hoisting the ball into the clear winter skies, the flyhalf was plugging the corners, and Currie's back three ran it back almost every time with disastrous results.

While he is a strong runner, Kinloch's decision-making was abject after the centre was shuffled to fullback. Faced with a wall of pink and black Ayr shirts and without a friendly face in sight, the youngster didn't hesitate before charging headlong into the midst of the enemy when the ball was crying out to be hoofed up field, a sentiment shared by Currie's forwards. Little wonder that Currie coach Ally Donaldson asked Graham White to take over the 15 duties after the half-time break.

Kinloch was not the only guilty party. Dougie Fife ran the ball back at all the wrong times and his blind back flip to absolutely no-one won't have endeared him to his coach. Shifted to flyhalf, Smith was trying to score a try from his own 22 with almost every play in the second half. It was horribly naive.

Climo slotted two first-half penalties, the first when his side were reduced to 14 men with flanker Paul Burke making his habitual trip to the sin bin. The key score then came immediately before half time when Ayr stole a turnover at a set scrum and Climo burst through the No.10 channel to race 40 yards to the line. His conversion gave Ayr a 13-7 lead at the break.

It stayed that way for much of the remainder of the game until Climo eventually extended Ayr's lead by another three points on 65 minutes with a simple penalty conceded by Currie lock Ryan Wilson who was carded for his troubles.

Ayr's final try came from Dougie Steele who'd been on the field for just two minutes. It came, as you'd expect, from an inch-perfect cross-field kick courtesy of Climo.

Ayr: G Anderson, A Wilson, R Curle, M Stewart, C Taylor; F Climo, J Hunter; G Reid, S Fenwick, E Kalman, D Kelly, S Sutherland, J Crossan, P Burke, G Tippett.

Subs from: S Adair, A Dunlop, H Mitchell. D Steele, AJ MacFarlane.

Currie: J Smith, W Moala, C Kinloch, A McMahon, D Fife; A Binikos, R Sneddon; A Hamilton, A Walker, A Reekie, R Wilson, A Adam, S Burton, J Thompson, R Weston.

Subs from: N Scobie, M Cairns, S Forrest, G White, I Downie.

Scorers: Scorers: Ayr – Try: Climo, Steele Conv: Climo Pen: Climo (3) Currie – Try: Kinloch, Conv: Smith

Referee: A McPherson (Livingston)






Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 07 November 2009 9:12 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
 
1

John Brown,

Glasgow 08/11/2009 09:04:06
What a negative report. Nothing about the bright Currie start with sweeping movements leading to the score. Nothing about the way that Ayr came back into the game and took a stranglehold. Nothing about the intensity of the match. Nothing about the star players, Currie hooker Walker; Ayr prop Reid and flanker Crossan. Nothing about a positive referee in Andy McPherson. Nothing about a crowd of 2000 including ladies lunch for 180 before the game. Yet the press go on about the negativity within club rugby? Look to thyself about negativity and all editors start looking at what your reporters are actually producing for you!
2

calum,

08/11/2009 09:27:09
Taking nothing away from Ayr's deserved win, it is clear that Climo is vital to them and their game plan. But in my day when you were concussed, and some reports suggest he was actually unconscious last week, you were ruled out for 3 weeks. Has that changed now?
3

bobbi o,

prestwick 08/11/2009 10:13:56
Climo was wearing a scrum cap for the first time this season. i presume that against west,he just received a bang on the head and was not concussed, so as not to avoid the big one against currie!

His play has been sublime the last few games and he was a standout in winning m.o.m award. still only 22-what a player.

Apart fron the first 5 mins currie were fairly disappointing.the tongan boy just didnt see enough of the ball to do any damage and their forwards were simply no match for kellys 8.

4

Hermie,

Edinburgh 08/11/2009 12:25:42
Agree a very negative report, but I think the ref made some very bad calls and was instumental in the final score, I know he can ignore the touch judges advice and he did! on more than one occasion.
5

ballinj,

glasgow 08/11/2009 15:32:41
wonder how long before one of the pro teams picks up Climo
6

Hermie,

Edinburgh 08/11/2009 16:06:52
A few images of the game can be seen at the flickr site

http://www.flickr.com/groups/currierugbyclub/

7

big rugby fan,

Central 08/11/2009 21:15:33
Travelled south for this game and what a marvellous advert for rugby. Currie are a good team who like to throw the ball around but they more than met their match yesterday when confronted with a team who can defend and win the contact areas. Both teams produced some decent rugby at times but the high-scoring Currie wingers were completely anonymous and the Malleny Park brigade were left trying to change their game plan more than once. The young Currie hooker looked promising in bits of the game and threw in well but he was outplayed by his Ayr counterpart Fenwick who was outstanding. Climo seems to be taking the plaudits but he lived off the physically dominating Ayr pack who were definitely superior for the last 70 minutes. In particular, Crossan was my man of the match he really can do everything and has the highest of work rates. Currie's Kinloch looked useful but they tried to use him too much and Ayr had his measure apart from the early try. I had a very enjoyable afternoon with a huge crowd and the smart catering van did a roaring trade. Very good refereeing performance seemed to be in tune with the game. This is what rugby is about and both teams gave it their all. Thought the visiting team got away with quite a lot at the breakdown especially flying over but in any case Ayr turned them over quite a few times. Some very nice passing play from both sides coupled with passion that's what made the game so entertaining. Couldn't help thinking what a good training ground this would be for our Academy players both sides have very good coaching teams at their disposal. I'm sure I'll be back to Millbrae and Malleny Park if this is what's on offer it kind of restores your belief in the game. The fireworks at the end were a nice touch.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.