Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Edinburgh target Dewey for return to Murrayfield

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 08 January 2009
EDINBURGH have confirmed that they are keen to re-sign Scotland centre Rob Dewey, who returns to Ulster's squad for tomorrow night's Magners League clash at Murrayfield.
Dewey left Edinburgh in the summer of discontent, when the SRU reclaimed the team from private owners in 2007. He has struggled both with injuries and form at Ravenhill and made only a handful of starts under Matt Williams, and though restored to an enlarged Ulster squad at the start of this week the powerful centre still may not feature in the matchday 22 which will be confirmed today.

There have been rumours that Edinburgh want him back as the SRU begins a new push to regain and keep as many international-calibre players inside their borders as they can, in the wake of the IRB's new regulation nine which hampers Scotland's Test preparations. With Dewey's international career having stalled on 13 caps weeks before he joined Ulster, a return with the potential to re-ignite Test hopes would be attractive.

Andy Robinson, the head coach, revealed that they would be talking with Dewey, though use of the word 'currently' suggested they already were, and he also threw into the conversation Ulster's Scotland winger Simon Danielli, who is also out of contract this year, but currently nursing a hamstring injury.

Robinson said: "We are always interested in bringing players to the squad, but if we do have dealings with players they are discussions that need to be held within the SRU and ourselves.

"Currently, there will be some discussions going on with Rob (Dewey] to bring him back if he's keen to come back to the SRU. We are always looking at bringing players, to chat to them; guys that have been here before and others. Guys like Simon Danielli you're looking at and asking 'Do they want to come back?' and 'What difference would they make if they did come back?'"

Glasgow were rumoured to be signing Jason White but the Sale flanker is understood to be heading to France at the end of this season, while Edinburgh are also understood to be interested in Scotland lock Scott MacLeod, who has not played for the Scarlets since he was cleared of a drugs offence in November and had a suspension lifted.

One definite new face to the Edinburgh line-up this week is Roddy Grant, the West of Scotland openside flanker, whose form in back-up games and with the Scotland sevens has propelled him through a back row injury crisis at the capital club to his Magners League debut.

Robinson admitted he had been impressed by Grant in training this week, and in pre-season, and felt his experience warranted a call-up ahead of Edinburgh's teenage prospect Chris Fusaro. There was no escaping the fact that Edinburgh were beaten off the ball by a more aggressive Glasgow back row in last week's Firhill defeat, and the hosts are hoping Grant's power and experience of intense sevens arenas will help them against an on-song Ulster side.

Edinburgh are also without Fraser McKenzie to a hamstring injury and this week lost Matt Mustchin and Alan MacDonald to knocks suffered in the Magners League defeat to Glasgow.

Mustchin has been carrying an ankle ligament problem since last season, but the chance to play for Scotland in Argentina and then the autumn Tests postponed an operation and he continued to play with his ankle heavily strapped. An operation is now being considered.

Craig Hamilton returns at lock for Mustchin, while Simon Cross, the club captain, makes his first start of the season in place of Scott Newlands at blindside flanker. Andrew Turnbull wins a recall on the right wing for Mark Robertson, who this week underwent a groin operation. Nick De Luca is dropped, however, with John Houston stepping in at inside centre.

Robinson said De Luca's poor performance against Glasgow was the result of him having played every minute of every game this season, as well as in Scotland's three autumn Test matches, something he had not planned but which was necessitated by injuries.

"I thought Nick under-performed last week, but it's about looking at why," said the coach. "We have put our arms around him, let him step away this week and come off the bench and perform from there. It was the same with Scott Newlands, who has had a couple of really good games and then dropped off a little, and it's being able to manage young players in their development.

"John Houston was one of our most consistent performers last year and I think it's right that he's given the opportunity in the midfield. We didn't get a good enough go-forward in the Glasgow game and I think the Ulster game will be a similar battle around the contact area and breakdown, and they have a good defence so we need to be able to attack them and pull them in a bit. And John Houston can maybe give us that."

Edinburgh (v Ulster at Murrayfield, tomorrow, 7.45pm): H Southwell; A Turnbull, B Cairns, J Houston, S Webster; P Godman, M Blair (capt); A Jacobsen, R Ford, G Cross, C Hamilton, J Hamilton, S Cross, A Hogg, R Grant. Substitutes: A Kelly, G Kerr, B Gissing, S Newlands, G Laidlaw, D Blair, N De Luca.

The full article contains 899 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 07 January 2009 11:03 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Edinburgh rugby
 
1

Robinski,

08/01/2009 04:09:33
With the SRU attempting to lure back exiled players to Scotland and building squads with young up and comings, 2 pro teams will surely be too few to have these players playing regularly.
2

RDW,

08/01/2009 10:14:47
I think this would be a bad move for all parties concerned. Do Edinburgh really need another centre?? They already have 6 or 7! Also in terms of Scotland, if all the Scottish players are concentrated in 2 teams then they aren't all going to get game time and will probably lead to players being shuffled around, like de Luca at fullback and things like that. And I think Dewey should try and stick it out - get fit and start putting his hand up for selection at Ulster and not do a Patterson and come back with his tail between his legs!
3

MT,

08/01/2009 10:51:13
A simply terrible idea. We already have two class 12ves in Deluca and Housten, why sign another?We cant start them all. I think it is best that as many Scottish Qualified players as possible should be starting for their club. Dewey should move to a club that will actually give him a start...I just dont beleive for a second he isnt good enough for Ulster...Its just favouritism. Weve seen this before. What we need is the borders or another Scottish side and sign on guys like Dewey, housten, Jackson, Turnball etc who cant get starts for their clubs
4

JonnyS,

Edinburgh 08/01/2009 11:57:23
Dewey has been hit by poor form and injury whilst at Ulster, nothing to do with favouritism. Dewey needs to regain the pace he once had (started on the wing for Heriots) and develop a step rather than trying to run over everyone... that trick was discovered second season!

Paterson has stepped up this season - settled into the #15 role and looking more dangerous than for years.
5

Arbroath1320,

Somewhereelse 08/01/2009 12:06:38
Same old argument about whether there should be a 3rd pro team. Of course there should be but where? Where is the support base? where is the financial support going to come from?
There seems to be a large number of decent Scottish players just now, they just need competitive teams to play in. Is it not the case that English based Scots are there to make up the numbers for when the RFU and Martin Johnson decide that England's elite players should be rested? For this reason it is even more important to get Scottish qualified players playing in Scotland for Scottish pro teams
6

johnnyscotsman,

Newcastle via Linlithgow 08/01/2009 12:20:38
Totally agree with Abroath 1320, there really needs to be a 3rd pro team in Scotland.

However if Rob Dewey can regain the form that got him he big money move to Ulster he would be a huge signing for Edinburgh, he was brilliant in that spell.

For me the Edinburgh midfield lacks beef, Godman, de Luca, Cairns & Houston are all pretty lightweight & a fit Dewey would certainly remedy that weakness.

Danielli is injury prone but when fit he is a better try scorer than Edinburgh have on their books currently.

Matt Williams is a clown.
7

Edinburgh Pete ,

08/01/2009 13:34:01
Agree that Dewey made add some beef but that extra beef he has put on has negated everything else that was good about his game when he first arrived. Why sign a player that is clearly injury prone and doesn't offer anything that DeLuca and Houston don't already offer at 12.

Fair enough if he was like a Henson who both carries the ball well and has a massive kick to help with defensive duties but Dewey doesn't have a kicking game and nowadays simply attempts to operate as a battering ram which back rowers and centres can cope easily with plus he has suspect defence. You only have to read the Ulster fans opinions of him to know they would gladly get rid of him.

Please if we are going to invest in players in the new season, lets bring in someone who will add to the team
8

wee leeves,

08/01/2009 22:11:00
A 3rd Pro team is needed........
9

Cave!,

Edinburgh 09/01/2009 11:34:31
Dewey's main problem is his attitude. Also, there is something of the Andy Henderson about him which I am very suspicious of.

Let him establish himself in the Ulster team before any talk of bringing him back.
10

John Brown,

Glasgow 09/01/2009 17:19:49
Dewey has not helped himself in Ulster with a reluctance to turn out for his associated club, Ballynahinch. Perhaps if he did he would benefit in many ways, not least from the coaching of former Ireland skills coach Brian McLaughlin.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.