Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


sport - iphone

Howe shock Hawks with cup knock-out

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 23 February 2009
HOWE of Fife president Jock McDonald believes his side's shock Scottish Hydro Electric Cup triumph over Glasgow Hawks will prove a major embarrassment to the SRU.
Howe pulled off one of the biggest surprises in the history of the competition by knocking out a team three divisions above them.

The upset came just days after tournament officials sparked a storm by summarily expelling two clubs from the compet
ition in a bid to ease the fixture backlog. Their decision to boot out Cumbernauld and St Boswells was made purely on the grounds of league status.

McDonald said after Howe's 27-17 win at Duffus Park: "What we achieved has made a mockery of the SRU's edict.

"Obviously there was great celebrations in our clubhouse after the final whistle, but a lot of the chat was also about what they have done to the smaller clubs. I think we have made something of a statement for these teams, and it is definitely a big boost for sides outside the Premiership."

And McDonald is convinced his men can go even further. He said: "We face Edinburgh Accies next and we have to be quietly confident."

Howe snatched the initiative with two tries from flanker Pete Black and another from Ross Aitken, goaled by Iain Aitken, who then scored and converted himself. Hawks came right back into it with a try from hooker John Maclay in the opening minute of the second half.

The Howe widened their lead with a try from Scotland U19 stand-off Ross Aitken, converted by brother Iain before Ross knocked over a penalty himself.

All Hawks could manage in the dying embers of the game was a try from Ally Maxwell.

Howe might have caused the upset of the day, but Perthshire came within a touch of an even bigger shock as they were just edged out 34-30 by Selkirk at North Inch.

With three minutes remaining, Craig Wallace went over for a fourth Perthshire try, a signal for the home side to throw everything into the final minutes only for the try which would have sealed a famous victory to elude them. "The guys should be proud at walking away with a result like that even though they lost," said Perthshire coach Derek Busby.

Boroughmuir had to come from behind in an entertaining affair at Linlithgow. In a ding-dong opening spell Matt Dixon gave the hosts an early lead with two penalties, Muir then got into the expected lead but back came the locals to lead 18-17.

However, Muir had too much class and moved away to a 41-21 half-time lead which was stretched to a final winning score of 58-26 that takes them through to a fifth-round derby of a tie at home to Watsonians.

Another former cup winner Hawick had a long trip to Aberdeen in round four to take on Gordonians from the lower reaches of National Division 3 and the expected gap in class resulted in a 68-3 win for the Premier One club. The Greens, who led 26-3 at the pause, ran in a total of ten tries, two coming from John Coutts.

Stewart's Melville eased past a potential banana skin at Hawick YM, scoring tries through Nick Wood, Adam Broach and Hayden Lingard close to half time to turn 27-0 up. It was stoppage time before YM got on the score sheet with a converted try from Mark Young to make it 27-7 at full-time.

GHA led Lasswade only 7-6 at half-time at Braidholm, but, thanks mainly to the exertions of James Noonan – a try, three conversions and a penalty – the hosts got home 39-6.

Ardrossan Accies, for whom Alan Wilson with a try, two penalties and a conversion was the hero, lost out to Aberdeen Grammar 27-23 thanks to a last-minute try.





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 23 February 2009 12:23 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Corky,

23/02/2009 06:40:11
It not that surprising, Howe are putting in performances like that week in week out. This is a seriously talented side who've already lost four of their players to Prem One sides. They beat three Prem Three sides pre season and are unbeaten in the league for two years, already scoring over 500 points this season. Whether they can go further in this this competition against Edinburgh Accies - who knows? A lot depends on the referee - Frazer Balharry had a good match sin binning a Hawks player for persistant team infringements - sealing off and slowing down ball. The Accies fat boys may try the same trick, they did successfully last year.


Jock MacDonald's right in criticizing the heavy handed and unhelpful SRU - there are players in this years Howe team who were denied their chance to defend their title at Murrayfield in the John Lewis Cup last year because the SRU expected 18 year olds to turn up at 24 hours notice to fulfil a fixture, and then the SRU proceeded to spin the story away from reality to the press - they seem to forget that they are there for the players!

Antway - great result for the club and agreat advertisement for fast flowing rugby. Come down to Duffus Park - who knows they could get another scalp!
2

Kirkcaldy Bampot,

Cupar 23/02/2009 07:30:24
Whats going on up in thar hills? Howe clearing out every new challenge put in front of them, Kirkcaldy and Dunfermiline at top of Prem 3, Perthshire running Selkirk to the wire and Dundee looking as though they are on the way back to Prem 1. The common denominator is that all these clubs are playing with predominately local lads, and that part of the world still produces top quality players from their schools and youth systems. Cmon Accies your reputation is on the line, Hawks came and had no respect---Beware
3

jdships,

Edinburgh 23/02/2009 08:17:53
Well done "The Howe" ,always enjoyed playing there in the 50'60's !!

On the cup expulsions .
This SRU administartion has always been guilty of building from the top down instead of the other way .
Any club below Pro/Prem 1 does not seem to bre part of the "plan" - whatever that is !!
4

Honest Opinion 2,

Froggyland 23/02/2009 09:18:40
Positive and realistic posts above. Great stuff for and by the "wee" clubs; and this is the tournament that the bleeding SRU want to bin! This is what rugby used to be about - generating local support, spirit, excitement and comradeship in the clubhouse. Nuff said I think.
5

Kirkcaldy Player,

23/02/2009 10:41:44
Again no Kirkcaldy score, beat Bigger 29 - 3. Great game with some great talent on display
6

Kenny Boy,

23/02/2009 13:15:03
#2 Great points Bampot about rugby north of the Forth. Mainly local players throughout these teams and no one being paid. It would be great to get Dundee, Kirkcaldy and Howe through to the quarters. Dundee ran Watsonians close on Saturday in friendly that was a cracking advert for club rugby. The ref was asking for oxygen!!
7

Corky,

23/02/2009 13:44:21
Kenny,

Dumfries who are sitting just behind the Howe in Nat One, very nearly spoiled Watsonians party a few weeks ago. The gulf isn't as big as many think.


#5 - what do you expect from a parochial paper - read the Courier if you really want to know what's happening.
8

J.A.,

23/02/2009 15:18:15
#7
I think the gulf is bigger than some cup results suggest. Cups in all sports throw up surprises. Clubs in nat 1 would get minced in prem 1

Well done to Howe, a good club building from the bottom up. Look what Selkirk have achieved with limited resource of money and population.
9

Corky,

23/02/2009 18:40:26
I've just read Hugh Barrow's report of the match on the Hawk's website. I must commend him for him generous praise and kind words towards the Howe of Fife club, players and officials.

Good luck to the Hawks against Irvine in the Shield and in the league.
10

not-Hamish,

cupar 23/02/2009 20:44:48
Dare I say I looked at the report in the 'Herald' (oops sorry) to check out the Glasgow angle on the magnificent Howe display (I was there) - what an excellent and fair report which really put the boot in to the SRU officials big time re the dismissal of lower league clubs from the competition as lazy, overpaid incompetents who don't have the wit / imagination to sort a fixture clogging-up!! Promise I won't glance at the Weegie newspapers again for at least another 30 years - unless the Howe gub someone else from that area of course!
11

Corky,

23/02/2009 21:49:51
not-Hamish,cupar

Just read it - it's the same report on the Hawks website. Much better than the second hand stuff doled out by this Edinburgh rag.
12

Corky,

24/02/2009 13:07:29
THE HERALD REVEALS

MSP calls for ejected clubs to be reinstated
The row over the Scottish Rugby Union's summary ejection of Cumbernauld and St Boswells from the Scottish Cup has reached Holyrood, with an MSP calling for the clubs' reinstatement.

The missive from Cathie Craigie, who represents Cumbernauld and Kilsyth, to Jim Stevenson, the SRU's president and Gordon McKie, their chief executive, reflects the depth of feeling generated in that area by what is widely seen as a glaringly unfair decision.

The SRU have been working hard to improve their image among politicians, engaging in a charm offensive in trying to outline what they are doing for the wider community. However, in her missive, Craigie has turned their claims back on them, pointing out that this decision is not in line with SRU boasts about their efforts at grassroots level or their awareness of the economic benefits the sport can generate.

In relation to the work being done to widen interest in the sport, she observed: "With the dramatic increase in youth participation in Scottish rugby since 2006, I believe it is a poor example to grassroots participants to see clubs from the Scottish regional leagues removed from a competition in favour of teams from the national league."

As for economic benefits, the SRU have sought to lobby politicians for fiscal support on the basis of their contribution to the economy, yet Craigie pointed out that they have missed an opportunity to let clubs help themselves financially.

"Research shows matches will bring an estimated £50m net spending to the Edinburgh economy, benefiting all kinds of business in the area. It is disappointing that you do not recognise the economic benefits Cumbernauld RFC's participation in this tournament brings to the constituency I represent."

On Thursday, Cumbernauld are to submit a paper to the SRU board registering protest at the decision and asking for it to be reconsidered.

ns with laptops
Wee clubs deserve apolog
13

Corky,

24/02/2009 13:07:51
continued

Wee clubs deserve apology from SRU
I read with disbelief about the SRU's crass indifference to grassroots rugby when Cumbernauld and St Boswells, who had earned their place in the next round of the Scottish Cup, were dismissed out of hand because of fixture congestion. It was sheer arrogance.

I was delighted to see Howe of Fife's victory over Glasgow Hawks at Duffus Park at the weekend, not because Hawks were put out, but because the win serves to show that no team are safe.

The romance of the cup, even in rugby circles, is a great thing for lesser clubs. Had the SRU followed their line of thinking and Howe of Fife were dismissed because they were in a lower division, where would Scottish rugby be?

Rugby only survives at the top because of a strong base and we keep hearing how anxious the SRU are to encourage young men to take up this fine game.

I now hope the cowardly committe at Murrayfield can find some way to apologise to both St Boswells and Cumbernauld. They deserve nothing less.
14

william w,

24/02/2009 14:01:21
All of the howe backline was under 22 yo

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.