Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 8th August 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Calderwood says Dons face struggle to lure players



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 15 April 2008
THIS time last week Aberdeen fans were on cloud nine and had good reason to consider that the 2007/08 season would be a pretty reasonable success.
A win over Falkirk in last Monday night's SPL match had secured a top-six finish for a team that had also made it to the last four of the League Cup and the last 32 of the Uefa Cup. Queen of the South would, of course, be dismissed at the weekend and the Dons would be looking forward to a Scottish Cup final and most probably a return to European competition.

But, as we now know, things unravelled at the weekend at Hampden and supporters of the Pittodrie club were brought down to earth with a bump. "I have never experienced such highs and lows as we have at this club this season – huge highs in the games against Bayern and also Copenhagen and then the huge lows in the two semifinals," said manager Jimmy Calderwood as he reflected on the 4-3 defeat to Queens.

Yesterday, Calderwood admitted that his team-building plans for the next campaign have been dealt a huge blow as a result of the semi-final humiliation. Already set to lose key members of his team in the coming weeks and with Aberdeen lying eight points off third place in the SPL, the manager fears that his summer targets will not fancy joining a squad who at this stage look almost certain to miss out on a place in Europe.

His spending power and the club's appeal to potential new signings may have been enhanced with victory at Hampden on Saturday. And the implications of the defeat look set to reach far beyond the short-term disappointment of booking a return trip to the national stadium.

Midfielder Barry Nicholson could be on his way south of the border, and is set to announce his plans before the end of the month. He may not be the only player seeking a move, with similar doubts over the future of influential striker Lee Miller.

Calderwood confirmed the defeat was a backwards step for the club. He said: "I think with regards to players staying and also attracting new players, the weekend's result is hugely disappointing as it is well nigh impossible for us to get back into Europe but it also comes down to finances.

"Things in this area should, either way, develop in the next couple of weeks."

Calderwood's frustration was obvious on Saturday as his side failed to perform against their opponents from the Irn-Bru First Division, just as they had been under par against Dundee United in their CIS Insurance Cup semi-final, losing 4-1 at Tynecastle in February. Losing eight goals in two semi-finals was typical of a season in which Aberdeen's defence has struggled for consistency.

The manager's dismay had not diminished yesterday, although he is determined to lift spirits in time for Saturday afternoon's SPL clash with Celtic, with the Dons returning to Parkhead a few weeks after their 1-0 Scottish Cup quarter-final replay win.

"It is just a massive, massive disappointment for everyone," added Calderwood. "We have had a meeting this morning in which we ironed a few things out and the lads are off to do a bit of light training just now, and by Thursday we will be looking forward to the huge game we have travelling down to Celtic Park.

"At this moment in time we all feel probably just as bad as the supporters do."

The full article contains 600 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 14 April 2008 11:06 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Aberdeen FC
 
1

Jon Bon Jovi,

15/04/2008 00:55:41

Maybe if calderwood hadnt scrapped the scouting network and neglected the youth set-up then he wouldnt have to put all his eggs in one basket...

he has papered over the cracks for to long and his downfall should be imminent...

you can always base how good a manager is on what other fans think of them, no one i know thinks JC is a good manager and none would touch him with a barge pole....

2

Jon Bon Jovi,

15/04/2008 00:57:47
"THIS time last week Aberdeen fans were on cloud nine"

absolute rubbish, most dons fans were relieved they got into the 6...
3

Hong Kong Phooey,

15/04/2008 02:00:22
Yesterday (and again today) there were a number of dons fans advocating to get rid of Calderwood. Questions is - who would want his job with such a disfunctional squad and no money to spend!

Watched the game online and I could have sworn that we had two central defenders sent off :-(

Hopefully the Jambos will 'do a Gretna' and cheer me up!!
4

Big Red,

Aberdeen 15/04/2008 06:54:17
Once again the fat burnt weegie seems to be passing the buck for his own failings.

Post number 1 has hit it on the head. The FBW is notoriously unable or unwilling to bring through youth players into the first team. We rely almost exclusively on a mixture of Dunfermline and Dundee United rejects, or Dutch amateurs that can't get a game anywhere in Holland.

The FBW should shut his greetin and get on with it. We're in no different a situation frm the likes of Hibs, Dundee United and Motherwell...all of whom have been/are able to attract plares to the squad who improve the side.

Levein in particular has a knack of picking up lower league players that Calderwood doesn't have, and I wonder sometimes what the hell the scouting network at Pittodrie is actually doing.

Of course, it seems that the scouting network consists mostly of The FBW's son in Holland.

Instead of bleating on, The FBW could have acted to prevent humiliation on Saturday by first of all hooking a hopeless Macnamara much earlier than he did (or even not playing him at all - he's useless), and making sure that our feckless captain took the game by the scrub of the neck.

Maybe as well if The FBW hadn't experimented with 20 different centre-back partnerships this season, Diamond and Considine would at least have been on first name terms.

This is Calderwood's side that capitulated on Saturday, and he should be man enough to take the blame for it.
But he isn't.

Instead we get more self-indulgent dovers about unfair it all is. Next thing it'll be 'it's the fault of the fans..they need to get behind the team more'.

Aye, Jimmy. We'll all be behind you soon enough, pushing you and your sunbed back down the A90 out of Aberdeen before you further humiliate the team that we love.




5

Hibby Heapy,

15/04/2008 07:56:47
#4 "Maybe as well if The FBW hadn't experimented with 20 different centre-back partnerships this season, Diamond and Considine would at least have been on first name terms."

Rubbish. They are just as bad as each other. I was in a pub in Blairgowrie on Saturday full of Sheep fans bleating for the blood of those two numpties! They all said to a sheep, that they have no redeeming qualities at all as defenders.

They then went on to vilify Calderwood and Nicol saying they weren’t fit to lace the boots of the Aberdeen greats.

Lets face it guys, you over achieved in the 70's and 80's and got very lucky. Now things are levelling out and you're going back to where you belong eg bottom of the SPL, or if we're all lucky enough, the 1st division.

I suggest you stop trying to play football and get back to what you do the best, "looking" and I mean that in the loosest terms, your sheep

Bah!

GGTTH
#4 "Maybe as well if The FBW hadn't experimented with 20 different centre-back partnerships this season, Diamond and Considine would at least have been on first name terms."

Rubbish. They are just as bad as each other. I was in a pub in Blairgowrie on Saturday full of Sheep fans bleeting for the blood of those two numpties! They all said to a sheep, that they have no redeming qualties at all as defenders.

They then went on to villify Calderwood and Nicol saying they were'nt fit to lace the boots of the Aberdeen greats.

Lets face it guys, you over acehieved in the 70's and 80's and got very lucky. Now things are leaveling out and you're going back to where you belong eg bottom of the SPL, or if we're all lucky enough, the 1st divison.

I suggest you stop trying to play football and get back to what you do the best, "looking" and I mean that in the loosest terms, your sheep

Baaaaaaaaaaah!

GGTTH
6

Hibby Heapy,

15/04/2008 07:57:35
Opps, never mind, ay least you can see where I corrected my hopeless spelling.

Still coments are valid!
7

Flip Hamburglar,

NI 15/04/2008 08:09:33
First of all Hibby, hope you enjoyed your time in Blairgowrie. I'm guessing from your name that you are a Hibbee in which case maybe you could bring to our attention your teams glorious period of domination. And i also recall that you are much more informed about 1st division football than any Dons fan. Shame if you are a Hibbe as I like many Dons fans have a lot of respect for your club and how they are run. Best in Scotland if you ask me.

Getting to the crux of it though there are a couple of spot on posts here. I also know of no sane fan (excluding the Pars) who rate Caldo. His quotes this week are infuriating, he definitely seems to be getting in his excuses early! You really do get the impression he only signed the contract cause he knew that there was nothing else out there for him. He obviously craves a shot at a decent sized Championship club but none will have him. The irony is the only way we will get rid is if he turns the club around and gets the positive results that give him his dream opportunity at Coventry City (no offence intended to the legion of CC fans reading an article on the Dons on the Scotsman online). I am awaiting his bothched summer transfer campaign in a cold sweat. Darren Young, Scott Wilson and whomever Levein deems surplus to his requirements would seem the most likely targets.
8

Bleeding Heart...,

15/04/2008 08:27:13
#3 "Hopefully the Jambos will 'do a Gretna' and cheer me up"

Dear, oh dear. What a mean-spirited comment.

But then, perhaps you're of the opinion that if Hearts disappear it'll make Aberdeen look better?

Maybe you should consider the fact that the only person on here (so far, at least) gloating about your team's gubbing on Saturday is a Hibs fan.

Not surprising really. Hibs fans generally seem to get more from revelling in others' misfortunes than from anything their team achieves.

But maybe that's OK since, according to your mate at #7, "many Dons fans have a lot of respect for" Hibs.
9

Starchief,

15/04/2008 08:48:25
Remember where Aberdeen were before Calderwood? Struggling against relegation. Always outside the top 6. No chance of Europe. Despite QoS (even Fergie and Wenger have had the odd horrific cup result), he's done a decent job for the Dons. A club with no money that has to sell players they can't adequately replace is only ever going to be striving for a top 6 place at best. What exactly are you hoping for?
10

Flip Hamburglar,

NI 15/04/2008 09:16:32
Hey Bleedding Heart!

1. I think you'll find I called Hibby on the gloating.
2. If you can't admire the way Hibs are being run what would you suggest is the ideal business model for a club? Surely not your crowd.

Anyway this is nothing to do with the Jambos although you obviously didn't start it. My only concern is the shocking position my club is in and the frustration at how its being run. I suspect that Jambo fans can simpathise with this view. Good luck to you dealing with your issues and we'll concentrate our ire on a excuse laiden failure that Caldo is fast becoming.
11

Prof,

15/04/2008 09:21:29
#8 Only one club in Edinburgh has come close to going bust, Hibs. Hearts are to big for that to happen.
The hibbies comments are probably related to the fact that Aberdeen managed to a Hibernian last week:- Supporters blowing and bragging before the semi, then turning up in empty seat outfits to watch their team make complete erses of themselves .
12

Dublin Don,

15/04/2008 09:25:33
Calderwood has put Aberdeen back on the map in terms of competing in high profile games . He has to be given a chance to rebuild . Some of his signings are actually decent - Nicholson, Smith, Miller etc have all been fairly good players . The likes of Mair and Young were only ever stop gaps and squad players that happened to be available at short notice.
13

Rambo_the_Jambo,

Edinburgh 15/04/2008 09:27:58
# 3 Hong Kong Phooey,


.........."Hopefully the Jambos will 'do a Gretna' and cheer me up"..please explain without using a Hobo dictionary.
14

jdships,

15/04/2008 09:31:17
As an outsider Calderwood has always come accross as an intelligent man.
He has a Phd in "Buck Passing" which has stood him in good stead over the years.
Unfortunately now it has turned out to be an "Honorary Degree" and he has been found out !

Big Wink !!!!!!
15

Dood,

15/04/2008 09:41:56
#11 Prof.

Not strictly true actually. Care to remember the mess that Hearts were in pre Mercer?

But of course, you'll probably deny that as well. Denial seems to be quite common in Gorgie now. This thread shows that it's not just the Hobos that have recognised your clubs dire financial situation. But again, you'll probably just deny it.

Keep beLIEving.
16

Rev. S. Campbell,

Bath 15/04/2008 09:53:28
#9 and #12 are correct. Calderwood's get the club in much better shape than it was when he found it, which is as much as you can ask with such limited resources. Unless he's sending the defence out with instructions to play like headless drunk chickens, the goals we've leaked aren't his fault - my mum could have done a better job against QoS on Saturday than our centre-backs and full-backs did. I watched with my head in my hands as they were skinned time and again by first-division opponents. £1m for Russell Anderson is looking more and more like the worst deal ever.
17

We love fitba,

google! 15/04/2008 09:55:17
Interesting comments here this morning (well, most of them), but surely Aberdeen's problems don't begin and end with Calderwood?

Aberdeen need to decide where the future lies - at the moment they seem to be drifting, with big decisions to be made on the stadium and investment but nothing happening. Tango man has delivered some decent results, but has also alienated many of the supporters. But I don't think it's all down to him. Surely a club with a Director of Football should have a proper scouting network?
18

Angoos,

Baku, Azerbaijan 15/04/2008 10:08:31
I have read this article and teh comments that followed it with great interest.

Surely everyone is missing the blatantly obvious ?

Aberdeen can't atract players of any great quality because they are p@sh and skint !!
19

Prof,

15/04/2008 10:12:20
#15 See you've caught the Hibbie disease- spend your life hoping Hearts go bust. Its not going to happen we're to big.
Thats not denial. Its the simple realisation that if push comes to shove we can always go the Hibbie way. Flog everything off to reduce the debt.
20

Gordieboy,

Musselburgh 15/04/2008 10:18:15
So Hibby, are you denying that the constant tinkering with our central defence ISN'T a contributory factor in why, after 50-odd games this season, we still haven't got it right? The '20 centre-half partnerships' thing isn't an exaggeration, you know.

Terrible, terrible management.
21

Bleeding Heart...,

15/04/2008 10:42:28
#10 My point was that "HKP" was having a gratuitous swipe at Hearts which was ironic given the appearance of the gloating hit-and-run poke at Aberdeen's plight from...a Hobo.

Nothing wrong with your admiration for Hibs' apparent business acumen, but I couldn't resist using your comment to sarcastically underline the point that perhaps HKP was aiming at the wrong target.

Thanks for the good wishes and let me reciprocate them. I fear Hearts are going to need all the luck they can get.
22

no fan of the sfa,

15/04/2008 11:02:45
I don't understand what all the fuss is about. Aberdeen's level in bottom 3-4 of the spl or top 3 of the first division.

They are a medium sized club in scottish terms, smaller than the OF, hearts, hibs, and dundee utd; if the owners of inverness decided to go that club then they would develop into a bigger team than aberdeen.

Aberdeen is a small, shrinking, aging city that is going to be facing a financial crisis is a few years once the oil runs out. The population with marketable skills will head to the central belt leaving the city resembling a very cold retirement complex, think of florida with snow and sheep.

The club can't pay its debts and has trouble servicing the those debts. Its stadium is a disaster which is badly dated (like the club) and looks like it has never been properly maintained. I really don't understand how pittodrie can get a saftey certificate.

Aberdeen fans continually go on about a new ground- but who is going to pay for it? Aberdeen fans talk about it being a community ground- which means the scottish taxpayer has to fork the bill. That will never happen as apart from the football team there is no other sporting entity in the area which could afford the rent.

Aberdeen fans are like celtic fans, they blame everybody else except themselves, they can't face the reality of the situation and feel the world owes them a living. They both have failed to realise that by talking/shouting/screaming their deluded opinions over everybody else's doesn't make them fact.
23

no fan of the sfa,

15/04/2008 11:06:38
I would also like to add that aberdeen have been saved from relegation twice through league re-construction and have avoided the relegation another time by winning a two legged playoff.

But then again why would aberdeen fans want to confuse their delusions with reality?
24

Robert Mason,

Larkhall 15/04/2008 11:48:56
Aberdeen fail to lure players because Calderwood is a buffoon.
25

Flip Hamburglar,

NI 15/04/2008 11:49:46
No fan...

That's good stuff there, you've obvioulsy got plenty of time on your hands to scribe that and sit back whilst steam blowing Dons fans respond. I hope you enjoyed the Christpher Brookmyre book by the way that inspired that rant. And please tell me exactly what jobs in the central belt Aberdonians will be rushing to take up. Has there been an oil strike in Falkirk or something? Unless you have a huge number of vacancies for professional grumblers I would doubt there is a huge opportunity for transferring skills. And yes, I am aware that I too have plenty of time to scribe away on this forum.
26

Robert Mason,

Larkhall 15/04/2008 11:50:28
22

A very shrewd analysis, no fan. The city of Aberdeen is already in financial crisis.
27

Dod fae Aiberdeen,

Aberdeen 15/04/2008 12:11:35
# 22 + 27. Which particular part of Planet Zorg are you from ?

Shrinking city ? In terms of what, the populations' height ? There are huge developments taking place in and outside the city which you obviously have no idea about. Canna get enough houses, min. Oil will be here for many, many years yet, then it'll be gas, so I'm not yet planning on selling up and moving to the Central Belt. To do what, anyway ? Sign on ? Wear ma imitation Burberry cap and trakkies - n'at, by the way ?

And please tell, what has more than half yer rubbish got to do with fitba ?



Shrewd analysis, my ar*e, wise up.
28

Drewsome,

Toronto 15/04/2008 12:39:01
Caldo,

Last I checked, the dons have 5 league games left this season & are 8 points out of 3rd! Batten down the hatches and get it done!

It's improbable but NOT impossible!
29

Lion-O "Lord Of The ThunderCats,

15/04/2008 12:49:51
Pretty sure that Wolves can't believe their luck that Zander Diamond turned down the chance of signing a pre-contract with them to pledge his future with Aberdeen.

Watching that display at Hampden I'm sure most Dons fans will be asking themselves how many they will see fly past Souter in the last 5 games of the season.

Lee Miller will surely be no loss? For a target man he appears to be very easily "brushed" off the ball and with Gordon Smith's diving ban coming in next season it's probably about time for Lee to continue to match Jim Hamilton's career path of playing for every SPL team.

Nicholson will be lucky to get an English club and IMHO will probably end up at Motherwell or Dundee Utd.

30

Nice 1 Simmy,

15/04/2008 12:58:42
#22 dirty biggoted muppet
31

Nice 1 Simmy,

Lying at Pittodrie 15/04/2008 13:06:07
#27 I hear road traffic accidents are up 10 fold in Larkhall following the decision by the locals to take a stand against traffic lights- in particular the green light - by smashing them. Delightful people. Delightful town.

Subway anyone?
32

occasional,

15/04/2008 13:38:03
#22 - that made me laugh out loud! Put yer fishing rod away man, your comedy posts aren't going to get too much catches today!

#27 - I feel sorry for you, though, as i genuinly believe you believe him.
33

Memyself&I,

15/04/2008 13:57:18
Both fat Jimmies must go now.
AFC will regret keeping this pair of muppets for another season.
JC has lost the respect of the dressing room (did he ever have it?). Once thats gone, you're doomed.

His signings are a joke.
34

no fan of the sfa,

15/04/2008 14:20:18
#32- truth hurt? Should it loud and maybe it will be true....

A few sheep bleating about my post, tough sh**!

The city is feeling the financial pinch, the club is feeling the finanial pinch. Aberdeen is going back to the 1950's- a wanabe 1 horse town which no horse will touch.
35

Royalty,

Zandvoort 15/04/2008 14:36:48
I honsestly think Aberdeen wil lbe relegated within the next 3 years.

Why would any half decent player want to live in Aberdeen let alone play there?

Its a beastly place & always cold.

Jimmy Calderwood & Jimmy Nicol will be the last decent managerial team at Aberdeen.

It'll be Z list managers from now on.

Cheery thought though,

Isnt it?
36

Scunner,

Aberdeen 15/04/2008 18:00:24
The Dons were in Europe last season and failed to attract new talent then. Even half way through this season players were leaving rather than play in Europe or the league cup semi Final. Stewart Milne is destroying the club and the quicker he sells Pittodrie (his real motivation) and builds flats on it the better. Once he leaves, the club can rebuild as he is bound to leave us in a right mess. He is the wealthiest and worst Chairman I have ever seen at Pittodrie.
37

Jock Wilson,

inverness 15/04/2008 18:11:19
no fan of the sfa, you mistake public sector wealth for private wealth, a common fault among weegies dependant on the State for their handouts. Aberdeen has more millionaires per square mile than any other area in Scotland and comes second only to London.

And why do you denigrate sheep so much? They produce the dairy products that could help rid weegies of their rickets and bad teeth.

So please show more gratitude, even though you will never be able to chew an apple or reach the top shelf in Sainsbury's. (Lidl's to you)
38

Bleeding Heart...,

15/04/2008 20:22:52
#40 - I ain't convinced sheep "produce (the) dairy products", but I think I understand your sentiments!

As a Scot, I want to see all our cities, all our communities, all our people, flourishing.

This childish carping is deplorable.

Slagging-off Aberdeen FC is one thing; denigrating parts of our our beautiful country is, in my view, both silly and unacceptable.
39

Rev. S. Campbell,

Bath 15/04/2008 22:17:14
#22 Top 3 of the Irn Bru league? For the ONLY team in Scotland outside the OF who've NEVER played outside the top division? You're having a larf. A few shocking defensive performances this season doesn't make us a bad side, certainly not compared to the rubbish in the bottom six (Falkirk excepted). We belong in mid-table this year, which is where we are. Or do you reckon Gretna, St Mirren and Inverness Caley could have held Bayern Munich and knocked the Tims out of the Scottish Cup at Parkhead?
40

occasional,

16/04/2008 08:35:42
#37 - "Its a beastly place & always cold."

My God, are you a 12 year old girl or a 75 year old pensioner? Get your longs johns on if your knees are cold and weak, you juvenile imbecile.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Features

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.