Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 5th July 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Melrose pair free to face Hawick as club appeal suspensions



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 05 April 2008
Three and six-week bans challenged
MELROSE forwards Kieran Cooney and John Dalziel will both be available for today's Scottish Hydro Electric National Cup quarter-final against Hawick at Mansfield Park despite being hit with bans by the Scottish Rugby Union this week.

Prop Cooney w
as given a six-week suspension (up to an including 10 May) at a disciplinary hearing on Tuesday after he was found guilty of deliberately stamping on the head of Boroughmuir winger Rory Couper, during Melrose's 16-0 win over the Meggetland side in the sixth round of the cup at the Greenyards last month.

Veteran former Gala and Borders flanker Dalziel was found guilty of reckless use of the boot on the same Boroughmuir player and was suspended for three weeks up to and including 19 April.

However, Melrose director of rugby Mike Dalgetty confirmed last night that the club has lodged an appeal on behalf of both players and they will be available for today's Borders derby clash at Mansfield Park.

On current form it would be an away banker but Melrose – who beat champions Boroughmuir 22-15 in the league last weekend, while the Greens were being thumped 55-6 by Watsonians in Edinburgh – will know that Hawick at home in a one-off cup tie is a dangerous proposition.

If Hawick do pull off a shock today it will be without the guidance of head coach Jim Hay, who will be on holiday in Tenerife. "This family holiday was booked back in October," explained Hay. "I'm gutted to be missing what is a massive game for the club.

"There is no doubt that Melrose will come as favourites, they have been beating everyone recently. But we know Mansfield Park is the last place they would want to come to try and secure a result. We beat them here earlier in the season and lost by only seven points at the Greenyards."

Off the pitch, Hawick will be hoping for a big crowd and club president Terence Froud explained: "This half of the season has been financially disastrous for the club and I'm sure we're not alone. This will be only our second home game since the middle of January and that's really not enough to keep clubs like us going.

"On Saturday, we split the gate money with Melrose so both clubs can benefit. Hopefully it will be a bumper crowd."

Elsewhere, it's a big day for Haddington on what has been billed 'Super Saturday' at Neilsen Park. They host fellow Premier Two side Jed-Forest in the cup quarter-finals at 1pm and that is followed at 3pm by the club's annual sevens tournament.

The East Lothian side defeated the Blues 39-17 in the league a couple of weeks ago and will start as favourites to reach the last four.

Biggar will try and lift themselves from the crushing disappointment of narrowly losing out on promotion back to the top division last weekend and turn their attentions to the cup. They have an extremely tough assignment, however, with a trip to Myreside to face Watsonians.

The re-arranged sixth-round fixture between Ayr and Currie will decide who faces Heriot's in the last eight.

The Shield, Bowl and Plate competitions also reach the quarter-final stage today, with the pick of the former being Royal High Corstorphine of National League Division 1 hosting Premier Three outfit Irvine at Barnton.

There is also a tasty-looking Ayrshire derby at Beith, where National League Division 1 title chasers Garnock host Kilmarnock from one division below.

In the Bowl, the highest-ranked survivors Preston Lodge and Dalziel of National League Division 1, will both be confident of reaching the semi-finals as they host Loch Lomond and Strathendrick respectively.

The pick of the Plate last eight is the all-student clash between St Andrews University and Aberdeen University.





The full article contains 656 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 04 April 2008 11:04 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Scottish Cup Final
 
1

JIM WHAE???,

Any suitable hotspot furth of Hawick on match day. 05/04/2008 09:54:59
Away at a big-time estate agent's convention, OK???

Someone tell Big Fat Terence to put the lights oot efter abuddy's gone.
2

Westcoaster,

perth 05/04/2008 10:33:55
when the going gets tough the tough go to spain eh jim?

3

SKEEDLE,

Hawick 05/04/2008 11:40:03
He's taking his bairns on holiday you MUPPETS 1&2.
Family first then rugby.
Hawick PLAYER!!
4

Manic Maroon,

05/04/2008 17:30:16
There is no more disgusting or cowardly act of foul play on a rugby pitch than the use of boot on head at a ruck, and there should be no appeal allowed in these circumstances.

Whilst you can't blame Melrose too much for using the rules to their advantage they would have gained more respect from other Clubs, players and spectators if they had sucked it up and told their players to accept their punishment.

Having just returned from seeing Hawick get beat, Dalziel was an important part of the Melrose win, particularly his playing of the ref with continual offsides etc. No doubt they will now be asking for the appeal decision to be delayed until after at least the semi-final.
5

Border Man,

Hawick 05/04/2008 21:49:42
Well Manic Maroon!!! You obviously didnt read the SRU statement correctly as your allegations are very close if not illegal. Are you aware JD was cleared of stamping and causing any injury?????????? Think there may be a Lawyers letter heading your way muppet!!!!
Mind you wont know very much about rugby coming from Gala! Are they still in the leagues??
6

Westcoaster,

perth 06/04/2008 09:13:35
3.SKEEDLE

Worth pointing out numb nuts the rugby season finishes in may. he's a RUGBY Coach whose going on holiday in april you do the math
7

SKEEDLE,

Hawick 06/04/2008 12:23:43
Nae s**t Sherlock!!!! You being from Perth, what's Hawick Rugby got to do with you? or have you fell out with Jim at some point and this is your own pathetic way of getting at him?
8

Westcoaster,

perth 06/04/2008 13:59:25
Its a global game and everyone loves hawick. Remember the hawick side that got destroyed by heriots at home by 70 odd points? the captain at the time roddy deans was on a skiing holiday? remember the S**t he got for it. Glass houses and all that.
9

Westcoaster,

perth 06/04/2008 14:01:52
I shall wait til ye local Libr'y oopens on Monday for ya r'ply. Broadbands coming and so's the train line!!!!
10

SKEEDLE,

Hawick 07/04/2008 11:58:11
Wee bit different the coach going away than the captain.
By f**k you do hold a big grudge!! Roddy's been away for ages and you dig that one up.
Move on, there are worse things in life than holding a grudge against a club or a coach.
11

Borders-will-always-be-best,

Hawick 07/04/2008 16:52:34
Skeedle if you are a Hawick player then you will know that Jim Hay is paid around £8000 a year to be your coach. Why are you trying to defend the fact that he went on holiday when he should have been helping his team to build up for the biggest game of the season. Yes it is a family holiday that he is away on, so what. At the end of the job he is being paid to do a job that he isn't doing very well. That date for the quarter final of the cup has been in the diary all season. Your coach obviously doesn't have much faith in you boys if he booked his holiday on that date, then again he done the same last year. Skeedle well done to you for defending Hay but at the end of the day your entitled to your opinion but this time im afraid Hay is very much in the wrong and I would upset if he is the Hawick RFC head coach next season, and i dont think i would be the only one.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.