Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 12th October 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Barcelona 5-1 Dundee United: No half measures from Messi



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 27 July 2008
Dundee United 1
Buaben 26

Barcelona 5
Henry 27; Messi 54, 76, 79; Eto'o 61
BEFORE the match even kicked off there was talk of this one being a game of two halves. Barcelona, apparently deciding against the stop-start changes associated with pre-season friendlies, opting instead to name one XI for the first half and another for the second 45 minutes.

As it turned out, they settled for eight changes but it was the introduction of Lionel Messi after the interval which ensured the second period bore little resemblance to the first. A hat-trick and more trickery than could be stuffed into a top hat redefined the match.

Nine minutes after entering the fray he carved out his own scoring opening. Cutting in from the right-hand side and bursting across the box, although Lee Wilkie got a boot in, when it broke back into the path of the magical playmaker, he showed a thrilling surge of pace to scamper into space and then drive a low, angular shot beyond Michael McGovern. It was the beginning of the end for United.

By that stage it was 1-1 and United had been worthy of that scoreline but, come the final whistle, the score had a very different complexion. In the 76 minute, the Argentinian star had netted his second after a beautiful one-two with Samuel Eto'o, his volley into the net worthy of his reputation.

However, it is not all flair – there is a tenacity to the player as well, which renders him even more of a complete package. In the 79th minute, he refused to give up and despite a sea of tangerine shirts, he managed to wade through the mayhem, creating the space to shoot from fairly close range and drilling the ball through the legs of Lee Wilkie, who had back-tracked to the line. The only thing missing from the retreat was the white handkerchief. If the big defender had waved it, it would have been understandable, such was the merciless onslaught being conjured up by the Spanish side the longer the match progressed.

While Barcelona had thrown on substitutes of equal or arguably a better class than the players who had started, with Eto'o, Toure, Pique and Pinto also coming on at the interval, a tiring United side had no such luxuries on their bench.

For 45 minutes, though, the Tannadice outfit had done what Hibernian had failed to on Thursday night for any concerted period. They held their own, even surprising the Catalan side by taking the lead in the 26th minute.

The advantage may have been short-lived but it was enough to cheer the home support. If the Hibs fans could be forgiven for using their hands to hide behind as one goal after another left them embarrassed, the United supporters put theirs to more positive use, applauding their side's endeavour and ingenuity.

While Barcelona were always attractive to watch, their passing and movement reflective of their renowned style, Dundee United were not glaringly out-classed during that crucial opening period. They were more organised than the Edinburgh side had been, and more composed when they were presented with their own breaks. But then again, they hadn't been battered by the class of Messi before they even had a chance to bunker down.

The mercurial Argentinian had been an absentee when these two teams met at Tannadice in the build-up to last season and he only appeared in the second half of this one. It was a telling difference.

To begin with, the priority for United was simply keeping their own goal intact. Like Hibs before them, they too conceded corner after corner in the opening phase but that was as close as Barcelona got to a goal at that stage. And United had their own forays forward. In the fourth minute – the same time Hibs had conceding the first of their six – United were actually venturing upfield in search of a goal of their own.

Prince Buaben, who was to have a marvellous match, popping up all over the park to aid defence and attack played the ball through to John Daly and while he had options to take it on himself or slide it through, he delayed the ball through the defence a fraction too long and the move ended with the linesman's flag and an offside ruling. But it gave Barcelona a clue that United were determined to prove they were more than cameo players.

For a while they were. In that first half Warren Feeney broke in, and John Daly may have troubled Valdes had Martin Caceres not made a latch ditch tackle. But at the other end, Barcelona were always a danger. In the 16th minute only a combination of the back post and Buaben prevented Gudjohnsen's header from yet another corner finding the net.

But United were revelling in the work-out, doing the dirty work, chasing and harrying without losing their discipline or shape and when in possession they adhered to the passing principals of their guests, pressing forward and taking the game to them when the space or openings materialised.

Having denied Gudjohnsen at one end, Buaben gave him a run for his money at the other before being edged off the ball. But the big mistake was the United's fans jeering of Thierry Henry when he sent one chance off target.

Less than a minute after Buaben had opened the scoring, Wilkie's inability to clear his lines gifted the Frenchman, not one shot but two chances. If the initial close-range strike was blocked, the rebound fell kindly and allowed him to bury the follow up.

That was it until the Barca reshuffle. And while it soon became the Messi show after that, as the afternoon developed into the torturous affair most knew it could become, there was others contributing.

Before linking with Messi for Barcelona's fourth goal, Eto'o had weighed in with a goal of his own. That was in the 61st minute. By then United had made mass changes of their own and Andis Shala, on in the 57th minute, was too short with a pass-back, allowing Eto'o to dart in, wait for McGovern to commit himself before threading the ball into the net.

It gave the final scoreline a very lop-sided look. But that was possibly fitting for a match which could be described in much the same way.

MAN OF THE MATCH

Prince Buaben was looking like a prime candidate for man of the match until Lionel Messi (right) came on. After that there was no looking beyond a player blessed with skills and vision which can mesmerise.

QUICK FACT

Before yesterday's match Dundee United had played Barcelona on five occasions, losing just once.

TALKING POINT

After his performance at Murrayfield on Thursday the biggest talking point as the match kicked off was the absence of Lionel Messi from the Barcelona starting line-up. Those who wanted to marvel at his skills need not have worried though as he soon made his presence felt when came on for the second half.


The full article contains 1199 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 27 July 2008 11:10 AM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: SPL title race
 
1

hooped,

consumer hell 27/07/2008 00:08:32
please get the score right!!
2

badger,

Edinburgh 27/07/2008 00:11:22
well said hooped
3

mcaitchi,

Hibs 27/07/2008 00:18:46
Never Seen The GAME but Well Done for Not Getting Beat by 6 - a hibs fan
4

bring them on,

27/07/2008 01:39:34
Only saw the first half, and DU did well in taking the game to Barca.

No shame in what I saw.
5

Bleeding Heart...,

27/07/2008 03:18:10
#4 "No shame in what I saw."

You weren't watching Rangers, then..?
6

bring them on,

27/07/2008 03:24:59
#5

Would that be the same Rangers who won?
7

Ex-Pat Stanton,

Melbourne 27/07/2008 03:49:07
No doubt about it, the Catalonian Giants will be the team to beat in the CL this season.

As much as the scoreline from this game makes me feel a little better about the pumping Hibs took on THursday, it's cold comfort to say the least. Utd held their own in a way Hibs didn't and getting a score on the board will be enough to at least give the fans some happier memories of what is, at the end of the day, a complete tanking.5-1 is not quite as bad as 6-0 grantd but lets face face it we were both had our pants pulled down and bahookies felt by Messi et al...
8

Daillyman,

27/07/2008 05:32:21
7

How can you say that Barca will be the team to beat this year in the CL?

What do you base this on, beating 2 SPL also rans in pre season friendlies, come on get real.
9

Ex-Pat Stanton,

Melbourne 27/07/2008 05:49:05
Daillyman, on what basis would you say they are not?

They have been in training all of two weeks, Guardiola has them playing fabulous fitba. 11 goals in two games against two sides that may well be also rans in their league, but are not bad sides. The manner of both victories is only an indication of what they are capable of as they walked through both games and still handed out trouncings.

They had a bad year last year, they will not have another bad season this year. End of...

WHo do you think the team to beat are then?

10

FC Barcelona,

27/07/2008 07:33:10
#8 you are not suggesting there are any teams in scotland who will be at the nitty gritty of the CL ? no chance !!
11

James,

Dundee 27/07/2008 08:21:40
No team in Scotland could beat Barca.

PG is a Barca man and the Barca fans I spoke to yesterday said that he has them playing higher tempo the Rijkaard. They feel that final 4 in Champs League is on this year.

United looked great in the first half, and I feel the lesson of the second is not to make 10 subbies!
12

bring them on,

27/07/2008 08:25:41
Well said James
13

Ayegudyin,

27/07/2008 08:33:50
there is not a single indication from these two games as to Barca's potential in the champions league. of course they are one of the best teams in the world, and their early exits the last couple of years have been dissapointing, but to base anything on pre season friendlies with hibs and dundee is laughable (im a hibs fan btw...)

hearts beat some german regional select 6-0, which is about the same difference in class... does that mean barca will have to watch out for the mighty yams on their way?
14

Ayegudyin,

27/07/2008 08:34:47
(ps. i know that hearts arent in the CL, i was just making a point)
15

Ex-Pat Stanton,

27/07/2008 08:46:49
Ayeguidyin, In a word No...

The difference is huge there. Hearts beat a regional select and they're not very good. Barca have looked awesome in the games they've played in Scotland.

Hibs and Dundee Utd both finished in the the top half of one of the top 20 leagues in Europe. Both teams got well and truly humped.
16

Arab in Glasgow,

Glasgow 27/07/2008 09:45:34
Well done United a great performance - especially in the first half when we took the lead (Where was the great Scotsman headline writer? Still in the pub?)

It was a great atmosphere and a great day out. Well doen to both teams for puting on such a great performance.

Especially glad the Terrors didn't sit back and let Barca have the run of the game as Hibs did on Thursday.

Next time Scotsamn be more careful - just because the Edinburgh team couldn't score doesn't mean that you have to make the Hibbes happier by denying us our moment of glory! Look forward to the headline "Scotsman Headline Farce!"
17

GMCD,

dundee 27/07/2008 09:55:57
What rubbish journalism!!!
The sports editor should get blasted for this error....for heavens sake, we scored FIRST and led Barca for a glorious minute or so....

BTW James, Unitd did not make ten subbies until the damage was done...the key subby was Messi.....his second goal was world class....
18

Talk o' the Toun,

27/07/2008 10:13:45
The number of BASIC errors by the Sports writers at Scostsman/SoS is reflective of their generally sloppy journalism.

##15 EX- Pat(approve of change of name BTW) you are clearly correct.
19

sonofcosmos,

glasgow 27/07/2008 10:27:03
it really does reflrct badly that the paper cant get the score right on the headline..and then cant even change it..poor show..which is becoming sadly a weekly occurance..
20

Eddie the Eagle,

Aberdeen 27/07/2008 11:20:24
I don't think the Scotsman journo was at the same game as me. Utd were hardly "desperate to keep their goal intact" at the start, we were on the front foot for most of the first half and looked like we may go on to score a couple. After the break Barca's passing was a little sharper than utd's and they were able to create space for the goals. The scoreline was pretty harsh on utd who kept competeing well and created chances right up to the final whistle. It was a brilliant game to watch, both sides playing great entertaining football for the full 90 mins.

And why is this journo even mentioning utd fans jeering Henry for missing a sitter? He missed the easy shot, utd fans in the shed went WAY!! Nothing more. In 25 years of watching football I can't remember a single case of this not happening.
21

,

27/07/2008 11:34:19
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
22

Ex-Pat Stanton,

Melbourne 27/07/2008 13:27:43
#22 We Arce The People,

Is that the same Rangers that were beaten by all of the team you mention apart from Barca? That gulf in class was certainly apparent when we beat you at Ibrox, or when Celtic beat you to the league...

Rangers FC Scotlands Shame, Before, Now and Forever.
23

Daillyman,

27/07/2008 15:37:41
9 and 10

No where did I suggest any SPL team will do anything major in the CL.

As far Barca being the team to beat in the CL league this season, I would suggest the 2 finalists from this past season will have something to say about Barca winning the CL, and that's only 2 sides for a start.
24

frisnit,

Dundee 27/07/2008 16:12:55
We didn't just jeer Henry once, he missed a couple of sitters and rightly got "wahay"d for each of them, as did Alves when he was nutmegged by Gomis hehe. And the clown who fell to the ground screaming when he'd hardly been touched by Flood rightly got booed a couple of times too.

However the United fans were very sporting - clapping the Barca team on in the 2nd half, their goals even when there was some ropey defending going on from us, when Messi got Man of the Match, and even the Barca players were clapping back in response when they were getting subbied.

I don't think it's coincidence that we were playing them again. They clearly enjoyed the atmosphere and playing United, even if it was a bit too easy for them in the second half this year. It was still enjoyable though, and at least we weren't robbed by a dodgy Scottish ref like last year :)
25

Daillyman,

27/07/2008 16:29:06
You ahve to wonder what happens when Messi get another injury, he gets a major one every season.

The way he ripped apart Hibs and then United on Saturday he is the closest thing to a one man team we have seen in a while. Barca are not the same team when he is not on the park.
26

Der Kaiser,

27/07/2008 23:28:47
#28
"he is becoming a bit predictable and if he keeps doing it then defenders will find it easier to play against him"

So what you're saying is Messi isn't a great player, it's just all the defenders he plays against don't know he's gonna cut inside. You certainly deserve your name......you are indeed an expert in all things football.

Funniest thing I've read in ages. Well....actually only a couple of days since your last molten droplet of soccer wisdom.

Ho Ho


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Features

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.