Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

The hunt is On.
Sponsored by
Can you track down Scotland's wildest beastie?
 
 
Friday, 5th December 2008

Haggis Hunt is now on!

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Hearts' MacDonald tries to calm his itchy feet



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 08 September 2008
JAMIE MACDONALD today insisted it's vital for a club of Hearts' standing to have three goalkeepers in their ranks – he just wishes he had been given the chance to prove that he deserves the gloves.
The young goalkeeper, who spent last season on loan at First Division Queen of the South, was pitched into first-team action against Rangers at Ibrox last month and gave a good account of himself, despite the 2-0 defeat.

However, he was dropped to
the bench the following week in favour of new signing Marian Kello from Kaunas for the game against St Mirren and missed out on the squad entirely last weekend when the Jambos travelled to Hamilton on league business, Janos Balogh taking his place on the bench.

MacDonald has a maturity beyond his years and recognises the importance of having quality stoppers as back-up at this level, stressing that he always expected Csaba Laszlo to bring in new faces.

However, having played in front of 50,000 at Ibrox and gained vital experience from being farmed out with Queens, he also believes he has improved his game and confidence dramatically and deserved a fair crack at the whip. He feels that he merited at least another 90 minutes between the sticks and conceded that he has been left disappointed by the fact that he wasn't given a run in the side to allow him to prove his worth.

MacDonald said: "Obviously I always knew that he would bring other goalkeepers in. The manager is new to the job and he wants to look at everyone individually and I have still got hopes of playing for Hearts.

"I was disappointed to miss out the way that I did though because I played against Rangers and I felt that I did well enough to get a bit of a run in the team.

"But it wasn't to be and it is something that I need to deal with, these things happen in football."

However, having gone from the Tynecastle reserves to playing 40 games in the highly competitive First Division and Scottish Cup, including the showpiece final against Rangers, MacDonald knows he cannot allow himself to stagnate, or indeed, go backwards.

He continued: "I am still relatively young but I do feel now that I need to start playing first-team football, especially after spending the last year and a half out on loan.

"I was playing every week but now I have played the first two reserve games of this season and while they are games of football it is totally different. You really need to be involved in games where there is pressure on you, points at stake or a relegation or promotion battle to be played for."

And the 21-year-old goalie admitted that he may have to look elsewhere if he is to be considered first-choice keeper: "I don't think that playing in the reserves is really going to improve me any more, I think I need to be out playing to develop my game again.

"I don't want to lose the confidence and the experience that I have gained and I don't want to go stagnant by continuing to play in the reserves.

"The last year and a half has been unbelievable for me. I have become a better goalkeeper than I was when I was just travelling with the team as a third choice. Playing regularly gives you confidence.

"Obviously you don't get much better experience than playing in a Scottish Cup final. My last two games have been the Scottish Cup final and a league game against Rangers at Ibrox. I feel I can cope with that now whereas before it might have been a little bit daunting for me because I would maybe going into the game thinking about the fact that you're going to be running out in front of 50,000 people and you're a bit nervous about it.

"But once you have experienced that once or twice it is just another game of football really at the end of the day. I think that sometimes at the club I am still viewed as being a bit inexperienced but I would say now that I am experienced. Okay, I have not been playing week-in, week-out in the SPL but I feel that I have played regularly enough and in big games to say that I have done enough to be given a go. Obviously I would like to have the chance to come through and make my mark at Hearts, I would be delighted if that turned out to be the case.

"But at the same time there is only so long that you can wait for your chance to come along and it might be that I will have to look elsewhere to get first-team football in the future."

However, MacDonald stressed that his preferred option would still be to remain at Tynecastle and insisted that he is determined to do everything that he can to convince manager Laszlo that he can provide a safe pair of hands: "For now I am happy to give it a go at Hearts, but I am no longer a 19-year-old who is happy to sit and be a third choice.

"I am really looking to play first-team football and if it doesn't happen for me in the future then I will have to think about leaving."

The Tynecastle keeper was in action for Scotland under-21s last Thursday as they took on Slovenia at the Falkirk Stadium in a vital UEFA European Championships qualifier and came out 3-1 winners, with two goals from Hibs' Steven Fletcher sandwiched between one from Gary Kenneth.

MacDonald said: "To get the step up to the full squad is very difficult because for me, Scotland have got two of the best goalkeepers in Britain and maybe Europe in their ranks already (Craig Gordon and Allan McGregor].

"It is hard but at least it gives you something to aim for. If you can get anywhere near those two then you know that you are doing well because the standard is so high.

"No-one has really cemented the third place in the squad, so there is always the chance to go for that in the future because it has chopped and changed a little bit lately.

"But to do that I've got to be playing first-team football and that is my priority because if I don't do that then I won't have a chance of being picked."





The full article contains 1105 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 08 September 2008 11:20 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Heart of Midlothian FC
 
1

busbyfh,

08/09/2008 13:26:04
I hope he gets a chance as well , but if I was being cynical (which of course I won't be) McDonald is contracted to Hearts whereas the two new keepers have signed deals (one type or another) with Vlad's sporting company - A sell on gives the money directly to Vlad. If JM did well and was sold on the dosh would have to go through Hearts books and make dealings far more transparent. From a selfish point of view I do not care as long as the BEST keeper keeps goal for us.
We all know that Kello has the number one spot but the Slovakian standing in number two (messy) HAS to be given a run of games to find out just how capable he is before his loan deal expires in only three and a half months time.
A team will never keep three decent keepers happy - two maybe. JM should wait until January and then find out how the ground lies.
2

Newcastle Jambo,

08/09/2008 13:39:31
#1 Good post. I do care, however, and I feel that once again Romanov's business model of playing young loan players (regradless of ability or form) who he owns and can sell for his personal gain is likely to harm the team and I feel sorry for MacDonald who clearly deserves the chance to prove himself but won't get it.

I haven't been reading these columns much so appologies if this has already been discussed but how similar is the situation at Newcastle (and West Ham) to that at Hearts? The only difference is that their meglomaniac owners have invested real money in transfers and haven't picked the team, just relegated the role of "manager" to one of coach with no responsibility for transfers.

No manager with any self respect will tolerate that and like everyone else in Newcastle I applaud Kevin Keegan for sticking to his principles and telling them where to stick their job.
3

Stotty,

08/09/2008 13:44:15
#2 - "again Romanov's business model of playing young loan players (regradless of ability or form) who he owns and can sell for his personal gain" that will be the likes of Miko, Chesney etc who can't get into the team then is it?

You don't half spout some nonsense. Kello's form has been excellent, as has Zaliukas, they both deserve their starting places.
4

Johnny Jambo,

08/09/2008 16:43:35
#2 NJ Hi how r u?
I think we need to get used to this type of management, the more big money that comes into the game the less the manager will manage and the more he will coach.
The owner (s) will buy the best players they can afford and the "Coach" will prepare them to play, thats the sad fact but I think it will become more the norm.
5

Newcastle Jambo,

08/09/2008 17:00:56
#4 Hi JJ, I'm well thanks. Hope you are fine. I'm cautiously optimistic that there could be a better season ahead for the Jambos despite the cancerous presence of the Great Leader hiding on his yacht eyeing the fax machine.

I agree with you about the way football is going and I also find it sad. If I won £100m on the lottery and could buy the club, I'd appoint the best available people in each role and let them do their jobs without interference.

I wonder if these egomaniac "business men" feel Alex Ferguson would have been far more successful if they had decided who he could have in his squad for the past 20 years at Man Utd? Or if Jose Mouinho was more effective when Abramovitch personally started signing players?

In terms of Hearts, our best periods of the past 40 years were under Alex MacDonald in 85/86, Jim Jeffries in 97/98 and Burley in 2005. They got results by being managers not "bibs and cones" men.

Would the egomaniacs tell a plumber how to fix their washing machine, or perhpas insist that he communicates through a director who will select the parts that he decides the plumber will need for the job? Probably yes, come to think of it.
6

busbyfh,

08/09/2008 17:29:34
Newcastle - We are not the only club in Scotland to have Board members influence team matters.
Rangers had Cousin play against Celtic recently purely because Murray had been promised by two EPL managers that they would come and watch him with a possibility of taking DC off his hands. Talk about a lucky team change - Smith had no say.
FFFHibs signed Nish and Rankin between managers - how does that work.
Murray again - signed Webster - unless of course McLeish then Le Guen then Smith all happened to fancy him as a player. Right coincidence that would be.

Basically we all know it's wrong - but it does seem to happen - Just too much and too blatantly at our place.

Mind you - For all I have lacerated Miko in the past (Vlad's poodle) I reckon he should be starting just now as the last few games of last season plus any time he's been on this term - he has looked dangerous (OK not against Rangers)- The player we all knew he could be. I'm sure you noticed at the game you were at that Miko will now track back and put in decent challenges - long may it continue. The guy that should not be playing is Obua as his first two or three games should have been in the reserves - to get reasonably match fit - as so far he has looked woeful - fingers crossed he comes good. He is Casbah's choice - if Vlad was picking the team this guy would be dropped by now so maybe Vlad at last is not interfering as much. Playing him for a full 126 minute game against Airdrie while not fit was daft. It was like having 10 men on the pitch.
7

Newcastle Jambo,

08/09/2008 18:22:13
#6 I wasn't at the Airdie game but it does sound daft. Also, in 2 games the guy played at left back, left midfield and then up front which surely doesn't get the best from anyone. You're right though, the good thing is that Laszlo was able to personally sign at least 2 or 3 of the 4 who have joined and that has to be good news.

The game I was at Miko was suspended following his usual antics against Rangers. I was hoping that Chesny might get a deserved start but that's too much to hope for.

By all accounts MacDonald did well on his competitive debut and with a season's loan (including Cup final appearance) behind him as well as Scotland under 21 caps I would at least have him on the bench rather than two loanees in the squad. Oh well.

I do agree with your point that other owners have interfered in team matters but it's always wrong in my view. A football club (whether it's Cowdenbeath, Hearts, Rangers or Newcastle) should never be the plaything of an owner. These people have to understand that the club is far bigger than them. It was there before them and will be there long after they are gone. If anyone "owns" an institution like a football club it's the fans.

I have no respect for people with no background in football getting involved in team matters. I have followed football all my life but wouldn't presume to impose my view on a manager who has (or should have) played at a high level when I haven't. Sadly football is now going that way throughout the UK following the example of Italy and elsewhere. It's not a good thing in my view.

I have a dream for Hearts that the Board would contain legends like Gary Mackay and Donald Ford, that the team would be run by respected managers and Hearts legends like Levein, Robbo, Pressley and that the best available players within budget were brought to the club from anywhere in the world (but ideally from Scotland) and selected by the manager based entirely on merit and with nothing to do with contracts / sale
8

Bleeding Heart...,

08/09/2008 21:10:16
#2 NJ - "The only difference is that their meglomaniac owners have invested real money in transfers and haven't picked the team, just relegated the role of "manager" to one of coach with no responsibility for transfers."

You're right. Romanov is NOT like these other owners in that he won't (can't?) invest in the players necessary for Hearts to challenge the OF.

The OF understand full well that the way to profits is to regularly compete in Europe and to win domestic trophies.

I think that's the way you'd expect any football club - ran as a football club - to set out its stall.

The OF spend heavily to maintain the right to play in Europe year-on-year.

Plundering the best talent from their domestic challengers is also part of their strategy.

BUT, if Romanov doesn't see the OF strategy as the way to making a profit from his investment in HMFC, just how DOES he intend to make a financial return?

Whatever the answer to that question is, Hearts fans are witnessing a deliberate under-investment in their team.

Laszlo is having to "make do", and will be the one to carry the can for poor results.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Features

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.