Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 17th May 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Portents point to a far more down-to-earth Old Firm collision


Sporting week

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 31 December 2007
SUGGESTING an Old Firm game might be a low-key affair is to become a hostage to all sorts of fortune. These games, while usually lacking in anything that resembles good football, rarely stint on passion, invective and commitment.
Nevertheless, the 2008 Just-After- Ne'er Day clash may be a little more subdued than normal. The death of Phil O'Donnell will cast a shadow over all Scottish football for a while yet, and you expect Wednesday's game to be an opportunity for Celtic fa
ns to remember one of their own, and for Rangers supporters to acknowledge a respected and honest opponent.

There is also the obvious consideration that neither side is at all fluent or powerful at present. In a sense this is the fault of the football calendar. To pull in the serious revenues that maintain their financial status on a lofty cloud far above the vulgar milling of their domestic rivals, Celtic and Rangers have to concentrate on European competition from September to December. This might not be deliberate policy, but it is inevitable that players who are looking forward to a game against Milan will find it difficult to concentrate on a tactical rundown on the strengths and weaknesses of a Gretna team.

The end effect is that, come December and January when the diet is strictly domestic, players take a while to work up an appetite for their Premier League mince and tatties.

This season, it has been interesting and encouraging to see other clubs have been ready to exploit this lack of focus. Going into Wednesday's game, Celtic have already dropped 17 points in the league and Rangers 13.

That can partly be explained by the improvement in the overall quality of the top division, but also by the relative ordinariness of the players now recruited by the Old Firm. In the not-too-distant past, the mere fielding of players of the calibre of Brian Laudrup, Paul Gascoigne or Henrik Larsson could secure three points for the Glasgow sides before they even needed to perform their party tricks. Now the Old Firm are substantially made up of players filched from domestic rivals. The likes of Kris Boyd, Scott McDonald, Kevin Thomson or Scott Brown are estimable players all, but they do not have the intimidating allure of the exotic. Motherwell and Kilmarnock defenders have played so many times against them in training they know exactly where they hate to be kicked.

Foreigners may be respected but they no longer carry an aura of invincibility. Jan Vennegoor of Hesselink is a big name only in the most prosaic sense. Gennaro Gattuso's Christmas spell on the Rangers training ground must have been a piquant reminder that the Ibrox roster no longer houses anyone of that charisma and stature.

It could be argued that both clubs have more cohesion, with a core of Scottish players lightly seasoned by a sprinkling of foreigners. Both put up eminently respectable showings in the Champions League in the autumn, with Celtic looking forward to a momentous encounter with Barcelona next year. It cannot be denied though that the teams rarely set the blood racing in the way a Larsson goal or a Gascoigne flick could.

In Gordon Strachan and Walter Smith, we see managers whose strong suit is pragmatism. You would look at both for a very long time before discerning any traces of quixotic romanticism. Smith hits 60 next February. As a Rangers fan from boyhood, you'd expect his feel for an Old Firm derby to run a little deeper in the blood than it might in the Edinburgh boy Strachan.

That said, he doesn't tend to send out his Rangers sides telling them to create havoc and let slip the dogs of war. His is a more tentative and studied approach, although his players occasionally forget it. Since he was carried back to Ibrox on clouds of glory at the start of last year, he has contested three Old Firm matches and won all of them.

Those obsessed by omens, hoodoos and superstition, i.e. most football supporters, will infer that Smith has some infernal hold over Celtic. The more rational, who accept the teams are pretty evenly matched, and neither of them possessed of a devastating match-winning individual, will suggest Smith has been statistically fortunate, and that anomaly should straighten itself out sooner rather than later.

If Smith wins again on Wednesday though, and puts Rangers in the title driving seat, even Strachan might start to believe in a hex.



The full article contains 765 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 30 December 2007 11:42 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Tom Lappin , The Old Firm
 
1

the boke,

31/12/2007 02:14:30
The game will be decided by who wants to win the most usually the one who needs it most). "Them" have home advantage, 30,000 funda-mentalist fans (Parkyerheid now usually half empty) and a knowledge that defeat will most probably concede the title, 1-3 new panic buys from Jan 1st, a referee anxious not to be the latest victim of the RUINS witchunt and the saintly,cuddlywuddly Scotty McD ( dont ye just love him) upfront.
Rangers have Paddy Powderpuffs now making them favourites for the match and the title. WaGS has Rangers for the title, Rangers wont be splashing the cash to panic buy a star in, they are the form club and were sensational at the weekend against the Senior Greens.Its a game they dont have to win and they can still go top later in the month. Not good old firm fodder.
Rangers made 17 passes before Cousins strike on Saturday and almost scored another after 25 (BF missing). The RAT-ics will not let this type of Tommy Burns play be played in their own back yard, The Boke expects the same WWE thuggery to be repeated on Gers a second time around and this time a scared Ref will not protect them (even WaGS has started the RUINS bleating such is his anxiousness).
Rangers a draw but most likely , see above, a win for "them", afterall there is no nobility in a sportsman like win.
2

Celtic Bhoy,

Carlisle 31/12/2007 03:02:24
You have got to fancy the Tic! Mon the Hoops!
3

San Francisco Bear,

San Mateo 31/12/2007 04:26:27
First and foremost.

Phil O Donnel a great guy. True professional. RIP.

Gers to win 2 to 1. Celtic without Mc Geady and Nakamura I dont fancy their chances. McGeady has been fantastic this season, a real playmaker and always a threat.

Go Rangers.
4

anti hun,

Fortress Ibrox...ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha 31/12/2007 04:52:07
The boke, more like the joke. What a moron.

Assuming that we get an honest ref, with a home tie, and even without McGeady and Naka (the 2 most gifted players in Scotland), the bhoys will triumph over evil.

The wives of the "no-one likes us, we don't care brigade" will have to make sure there are plenty of bandages in their hoose for Wednesday evening.
5

Carntyne,

Where I Can See You! 31/12/2007 07:12:14
A witchunt against referees?

I think it's the other way round!

It is Celtic who need protection from the Hun tendency!

The reverend Mike McCurry booked nine Celtic players at Ibrox.(All justified of course!)

I can't for the reaction to Father Paddy McGinty refereeing a match between Celtic and Rangers and booking nine Rangers players!

As for Rangers not making any 'panic buys' boke, (you give me the) that is hardly surprising since they are so skint!

Here's to three In A Row!
6

Media 1,

cape town 31/12/2007 07:32:24
Rangers are skint by comparison to Celtic, or so we are told, which begs the question as to how the very poor can compete with the very wealthy to the point that a Rangers win will almost certainly be game over for Celtic, and four defeats on the trot. One would assume that a team with so much wealth would have no problem disposing of less fortunate sides. I remember when Rangers had the money, they won 12 out of 14 titles. Celtic by comparison have won 4 out of 6 (I believe)
Bottom line is that Celtic MUST win, whereas Rangers can lose and the title race is still close...
I predict a draw
7

Royalty,

31/12/2007 09:42:23
Cousin, Darchville, Novo, Boyd, Naismith, Burke, McCulloch...take your pick. Any one of these players can cause serious damage to Celtics laughable defence. Its going to be a Rangers win on Wednesday, there is no doubt about that.

The sound from Parkhead in 2008? "Fail Fail"
8

Rouleur,

On ma bike 31/12/2007 09:43:15
I agree with the article concerning the portion relating to the edge surrounding the game will be subdued due to Phil's sad death. Not too sure that I agree with the portion about lack of superstars in Scottish football having a detrimental effect on the quality. We have three teams in Europe post xmas since 1970 which I think is a great barometer for the nation's improvement.
Back to the game, if Rangers get a draw I will be happy.
9

paulmac,

surrey 31/12/2007 11:42:41
Roll up! Roll up....the anti-football brigade are coming to CP on Wednesday!

Anybody know who the SFA are sending as back up for Wattie and his cluggers in the shape of the ref?
10

revsween,

In the Masonic Temple surrounded by Referees and L 31/12/2007 12:39:40
The mhanky mob in green and grey are getting their excuses in early. Ever predictable they are already accusing the Ref of bias even though Paulmac doesn't even know who he is.I grew up in the Celtic 9iar years and had to accept they were the top dogs because they had the best manager and players .But when the Gers are on top its always a conspiricy ,guys like Ideefix I can forgive he is a 49 year old virgin who hears voices in his head bless him,but some of you tims should have a word with yourselves
11

Blue Chip,

Brittania 31/12/2007 14:06:45
ah well, its all academic now.

celtc requested a postponement, rangers were left with no choice but to agree, end of story now.

There is no question this game should have gone ahead.

cant help but think celtc have been a tad cynical here. Some would call it running scared and used this terrible situation to their advantage... what a despicable spineless bunch they really are

follow follow





12

Hunky Dorey,

Glasgow 31/12/2007 14:43:45
#11.... It's plainly obvious that you have no respect for the dead!
13

the boke,

31/12/2007 17:16:21
#11 tut tut!
Just read the news in the posts above yours and then this! Why on earth go off in a tangent like that? Dignity and Respect are bedrocks of the Rangers Management, quote Walter: "It's a very difficult time for everyone, especially the lad's family.
"Our thoughts across football would go to his family first and foremost."
Perfect. Celtic have a player like McDonald (their chief dangerman) whos head must be spining at the moment. What about Tommy Burns, the same. Celtic, best placed to see the inner circle reaction of their players and fans, asked (Rangers did the right thing) end of story. Grab your nearest and dearest give them a "big squeezy" and count your blessings.




 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.