Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 23rd November 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Let's get behind Burley



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 08 September 2008
ALONG with its Roman architecture and searing heat, the Macedonian capital of Skopje has one great note of interest.
It was the birthplace of Mother Teresa, winner of the 1979 Nobel Peace Prize and a woman who, following her death in 1997, was granted beatification, the first steps towards canonisation.

Yet in the wake of Saturday's defeat in the Republic, it wo
uld have taken much more than the patience of a saint to deal with post-match grilling that George Burley endured.

Already sections of the media are writing off his side, looking to the heavens for a saviour to steal his throne – just one game into his reign.

He gamely defended his players, even if he really knows he needs to work miracles to get Scotland's qualifying campaign back on track.

His job, however, won't be any easier if he has fans with typewriters sniping from the sidelines or encouraging fury on radio phone-in shows.

Burley is not everyone's cup of tea – that much is clear in some of the broadcasting and writing coming from some of the nation's higher-profile sports hacks.

Yet ask yourself who would you rather have. Would you prefer a manager who is prepared to defy the growing campaign to bring Neil Alexander in to replace Craig Gordon, or someone who shows faith with the current incumbent and is rewarded with a gravity-defying performances that spared even more blushes?

Would you prefer a manager who is prepared to take risks, to try things out, and to blood new players – such as Kris Commons, who rewarded him with a fine display in the second half – or someone who sticks to the same ageing relics on the basis that is the way it has always been?

Burley has shown bravery taking a job that neither his predecessors Walter Smith or Alex McLeish wanted when opportunity knocked elsewhere.

At least Burley had the good grace to say he was "proud" to be named Scotland manager.

Remember that, when the Scotland job used to be something managers aspired too, not something that was used only as a stop-gap to win a position more suited to a lifestyle?

I became friends with Burley while chairman at Hearts and he was our all-conquering new manager, so I feel suitably qualified to argue my case when I say he should have credit heaped on him for trying to be bold with a side that was ravaged with call-offs.

The weight of a nation cannot be an easy load to shoulder at the best of times, least of all when trying to follow in the steps of two almost successful managers before you.

Yes, the Scotland side that took the field in the first half against Macedonia failed to impress.

Yet it was only after George Burley's half-time talk that they were a team transformed, and only luck and the failure of the assembled strike force saw them falter in front of goal.

It was a cruel result in the sweltering Skopje heat, and one that I don't think merits relentless criticism.

Instead, it is those same players who have underachieved in the past who should come under close scrutiny.

Say what you like about Burley, but he will stand or fall on a record that will be achieved by doing things his way – which is, of course, a major reason why, despite his fantastic start at Hearts, Vladimir Romanov ditched him.

At that time, the owner didn't want someone who would think, act and do their own thing, or be their own man.

So, Burley paid the price for one man's inability to leave well alone at a time when his team were flying high.

Yet Romanov is not the only interfering owner. Look at Alan Curbishley at West Ham, resigning rather than be overruled by an Icelandic consortium and rich chairman Bjorgolfur Gudmundsson.

Curbishley wanted to retain players George McCartney and Anton Ferdinand, but both were sold to Sunderland. When he tried to broker replacements, he was told no.

At Newcastle, Kevin Keegan risked a £2 million penalty and walked out, rather than have his footballing vision challenged from above.

Keegan wanted to keep James Milner, but he was sold to Aston Villa.

Keegan appealed to the Board and the club's director of football for a left-back. Instead, a midfielder and a striker were imposed upon him.

So, my point is this: Scotland is lucky to have a manager like George Burley, and he, I am sure, will be grateful to have little destructive interference from above.

The nation risks shooting itself in the foot if it allows the press to take the place of the rich, autocratic owners that have made the life of traditional British managers so hard.

After all, an orchestra can't have three conductors.

So, instead of piling on the pressure ahead of Wednesday's World Cup qualifier against Iceland, perhaps some support from the headline writers may be more constructive.

Don't you think?





The full article contains 838 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 08 September 2008 11:24 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Heart of Midlothian FC
 
1

Chas Niceass,

08/09/2008 12:52:41
Who are you trying to kid George. The man appears to trust only Old Firm players or those who bum around the lower leagues of England.
The rest might as well forget it. Get Fletcher in on Weds, I see he is called up, I fear only to make up the numbers.
This is another Vogts in the making, we need someone with tactical nous, Burley by his own admission on arrival at Hearts touted himself as a manager who played carefree football.
That wont cut it at international level.
2

Bemused and above it all,

08/09/2008 13:10:09
Get rid of Gordon in Goal, the mannorexic has shown consitently that he is good at shot stopping then making a complete erchie of any rebounds. How long can someone make a career out of being almost good enough when there is a deputy who has shown that he IS good enough at the highest level?
3

Parsons,

08/09/2008 13:21:32
#3 I take it you must be part of the "growing campaign to bring Neil Alexander in to replace Craig Gordon"?

I must have missed that campaign myself!

4

Graham Rix ate my hamster,

08/09/2008 13:24:21
Parsons...

I must have missed it as well. Pretry sure it should have said McGregor.

Cant believe that the blatant mistake made it to print!

5

The Bee,

08/09/2008 13:27:31
#3

I’m bored so I’ll bite, just to see your comical reply. Enlighten us then, who is this fictional character who has consistently shown that they should be Scotland’s No.1?
6

Parsons,

08/09/2008 13:37:10
#5 It is a ridiculous mistake to make.

To be honest I've not really noticed a campaign in the media wanting Burley out. He has been criticised, but that is nothing personal as any Scotland manager would cop some flak for losing to Macedonia.

It will get worse if we lose to Iceland though and then parts of the media will start calling for him to be sacked. Although I don't think many managers would survive back to back losses to Macedonia and Iceland in any country!
7

Newcastle Jambo,

08/09/2008 13:44:58
I agree 100% with George Foulkes. I just posted on another thread how similar the Newcastle situation is to the Hearts one and how much everyone in the city admires Keegan for sticking to his principles.

Football clubs should never be run as the personal plaything of rich businessmen - either for their financial gain or just to maasage their enormous ego and let them play at fantasy football.

Kevin Keegan is 100 times that man that Mike Ashley is and the same applies to Burley vis a vis Romanov.

Burley is the right man for the Scotland job and will do as well as anyone could with what is a mediocre squad.
8

Jamtastik,

08/09/2008 13:53:47
#6 lol - too many ibrox diidys in the team, thats why we lost pundik ;)
9

Newcastle Jambo,

08/09/2008 14:50:18
I didn't think Scotland were that bad to be honest. Terrible conditions to play in (i.e. the heat), missing Barry Ferguson and maybe Alan Hutton could have made a difference, lost a goal to a dodgy free kick decision and denied a stone-wall penalty. And this against a team who recently beat Croatia and drew with England so we are not talking the Faroe Islands this time.

Burley got a better performance from them in the 2nd half and his substitutions were sound. Malone looked sharp and I'd like to see him start on the left instead of Robson who was ineffectual. Otherwise, what could you have changed? We don't have a Dalglish or Jordan anymore sadly.

Slow news day here.
10

gothenburg1983,

08/09/2008 15:21:14
it wasn't that bad a performance. We probably deserved to get beat but it was way better in the second half. Remember how poor we were against some Georgian teenagers under Mcleish? Things are improving.
11

Jonas Jonaitis,

08/09/2008 15:26:40
Why the need to bring vlad into his story, its not him in the papers saying that burley is 90 min away from the sack.

Yeah burley got ditched at a bad time at hearts, but its now in the past, move on foulkes.
12

Newcastle Jambo,

08/09/2008 15:59:57
#14 I for one will never forgive or trust Romanov as a result of the series of disasterous decisions that he made, starting with the Burley sacking.

Football is not the same anymore sadly. Clubs are run purely for the objectives of their rich, overseas-based owners and managers are expected to be forelock-tugging serfs with no authority. As for the fans, we are an irrelevance.
13

Chas Niceass,

08/09/2008 16:18:07
#15 Appears its not only Vlad that mistrusts Burley, the Scotland team are apparently on the verge of rebellion with at least 4 players rumoured ready not to play for him.
Only McCulloch has gone public so far but more to follow apparently.
2 sides to every story.
14

Parsons,

08/09/2008 16:39:30
#16 That's interesting! Is that a new story? I've not heard anything like that.

15

Stotty,

08/09/2008 16:41:05
Scotland are mince and always were. We punched above our weight in the last qualifiers, yet despite 2 unexpected (and a wee bit spawny)wins against France, we still couldn't qualify.

We are now just showing our true form, and I don't blame Burley for that.
16

Newcastle Jambo,

08/09/2008 16:43:12
#16 If that's true my view would be fine - don't play for Scotland if you don't want to. Burley is very much respected by players he has coached at Motherwell, Ayr, Ipswich, Derby, Hearts and Southampton. If someone has a problem with their motivation to play for Scotland that says a lot about them in my view.

Burley has had ONE competitive game. Have people forgotten about the dismal Roxbury and Brown era, the embarassment of Berti and great enthusiasm (not) for the job of the Blue Noses, Smith and Eck? Burley is the best bet for a long time in my view and surely Terry Butcher and Steven Pressley are also very capable on the training ground and have the kind of authority and respect that's needed?
17

Parsons,

08/09/2008 16:58:36
#19 I agree don't play for Scotland if you don't want to. They should no longer be selected if the manager changes in the future.

As a Rangers fan I'd be delighted if McCulloch made a similar pledge not to play for Rangers!!

On your other points, to be fair to Roxburgh and Broon at least we managed to qualify for tournaments under them. I remember watching us beat Greece then Finland both 1-0 at Hampden in the Euro 96 qualifiers and being gutted as we were negative and played off the park in both games. We still qualified for the tournament though. I never thought those would actually be glory days to look back on with envy!!
18

FC Barcelona,

08/09/2008 16:59:53
burley's just another sychophantic old firm soothsayer, can i ask burley if shaun maloney had signed for lets say dundee utd, would he have got straight into the scotland sqaud ??? nae chance !!! the guys a phoney lets get rid now !!!
19

Newcastle Jambo,

08/09/2008 17:06:33
#21 A bit harsh - and based on Malone's brief appearance it was our main highlight of the day (along with Gordon's saves and a couple of flashes from McFadden).

#20 I know what you mean and I hope we never have to go back to 5-4-1 home and away again. We had better players and easier qualifying groups in that era too remember. I think Craig Gordon is the only Scot who gets a regular game in the EPL. Could we have imagined that in the days of the great Leeds and Liverpool sides of the 70s and 80s full of Scots?
20

Der Kaiser,

08/09/2008 23:47:09
thepundit,
BURLEY MUST GO!...

Bemused and above it all,
Get rid of Gordon in Goal, the mannorexic has shown consitently that he is good at shot stopping then making a complete erchie of any rebounds.

thepundit,
mcgregor should be scotland number 1

thepundit
nobody will be able to fire the players up and get full respect from everyone like walter and mcleish
why? because they were good rangers men

============================================

Seriously who are these people? Oh wait, that's right...they're Rangers fans with their blinkers firmly on. You guys give Rangers fans a bad name...as if they didn't have enough trouble already.

Gordon is Scotlands best keeper. The End.
I liked the comment about Gordon being a good shot stopper...he is!...cos that's kinda his job. Macedonia scored because after Gordons excellent save not one single defender followed back leaving the Macedonia boy free to tap it home. McGregor will be a good deputy...if Craig is ever injured. Just because McGregor wears a Rangers top doesn't mean he gets picked first for Scotland. There's a reason he doesn't get the number 1 shirt....if you think about it...you may even work it out.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Features

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.