Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 23rd November 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Ibrahim Tall: Romanov acts like 'dictator'



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 21 May 2008
IBRAHIM TALL has spoken candidly for the first time about his treatment at the hands of Vladimir Romanov.
The defender returned to his home in Paris last week at the end of his Hearts contract. Whilst retaining fond memories of the club, he explained how Romanov left him embittered by his dictatorial methods.

The majority shareholder ordered Stephen F
rail, Hearts' interim manager, not to play Tall during the second half of this season.

The Frenchman had refused the offer of a contract extension on reduced terms and therefore became subject to exclusion from the team at Romanov's request. He appeared only once at first-team level following the defeat at Falkirk on December 29 last year. Despite finding the process disturbing, he maintained a dignified silence on the issue until severing his ties with Hearts.

Tall spoke exclusively to the Evening News to reveal the extent of Romanov's ruthlessness during negotiations and subsequent interference in team matters.

His three-year, £10,000-a-week contract was sanctioned in 2005 against the wishes of Hearts' then-manager George Burley, so keen was Romanov to have the Senegalese internationalist involved in his Tynecastle revolution. However, when a proposed extension was rejected earlier this year, the owner's mindset altered.

"When we were to talk about a new contract I was open to discuss it with Mr Romanov, but he told my agent he would give me one offer and if I didn't sign I would never play again," said Tall.

"I was hoping to talk normally but with him it's like a dictator. You have to do what he says.

"He offered me less money, but the problem wasn't money, it was the way he spoke.

"I think it was very arrogant. It was a problem because I would not sign the new contract so Mr Romanov said to Stephen Frail not to put me in the team. I knew I wouldn't play after that and it was difficult."

In that sense, the 26-year-old's Hearts career petered out in similar fashion to the way it began, inconspicuously. Eight months lapsed between him arriving in Edinburgh from the French club Sochaux and his first-team debut, as first Burley, then Graham Rix, deemed him not good enough for Tynecastle. Romanov required to sack both managers and place Valdas Ivanauskas in temporary charge before he could facilitate Tall's promotion.

The defender's case was helped, ironically, when Romanov banished Andy Webster from the team following a contract wrangle with the Scotland internationalist and his agent in spring 2006.

The acrimony surrounding Tall's departure means that, for varying reasons, he was considered "unselectable" for a full year in total at Hearts.

He stressed that several players had received similar unethical treatment to that which tainted his final five months in Edinburgh. "My situation was like Julien's (Brellier]. But it's not only him, I think a lot of players have gone through this," he said.

"Hearts is a very good club, the people who love the club work very hard and they are nice people. But the owner, I don't think he does his job well.

"He did many bad things to me. A lot of players were happy there but they didn't stay because of Mr Romanov."

Tall managed to etch his name in Hearts folklore by helping the club win the 2006 Scottish Cup and enter the Champions League qualifying rounds for the first time.

He is now seeking a new club in France's Ligue 1 for next season. Waiting by the telephone in his Parisian residence, he has time to ponder some poignant memories from Scotland.

"I have a lot of good thoughts and a lot of bad ones.

"I don't forget the tough times," he continued. "I remember my first year at Hearts. I waited about eight months to play.

"That was difficult but after that I had good experiences.

"Beating Aberdeen to qualify for the Champions League was a great memory, as was winning the Scottish Cup.

"I played a lot more first-team games in my second season, which was better for me.

"I started this season well and was playing well for the first five months. I thought everything was okay but then I got injured in December and played only one game after that because of the contract situation.

"The Scottish Cup final was the best memory. You play football to win trophies and the fans were fantastic that day, right behind the team. I don't know if it was the biggest day of my career because I won the League Cup in France, but after the match being with the supporters was the best feeling in my career."

Tall had an inkling to return to France, where he was born to Senegalese parents, for family reasons. He watched Hearts undergo a moderate transformation earlier this year when Frail was appointed caretaker manager but believes Romanov's managerial rotation policy has undermined the efforts of everyone at the club.

"Mr Romanov must not change the manager all the time, it's not good for the team.

"This season was bad for us and results were not good enough, but things improved when Shaggy took over.

"I hope Mr Romanov keeps him and brings in two or three good players because this is what the team needs.

" Some new players with good quality will improve results for next season. "Shaggy taking the team from January was a good idea, he loves the club and works very hard for the club.

"I hope he can continue with Hearts because all the players like him and want to work hard for him.

"I had mixed memories from my time in Scotland but that's in the past and I'm looking forward.

"The French league season is finished now and clubs will start to talk to players about next season.

"I haven't heard any more from Strasbourg, they were interested before but they are relegated now. I would prefer to stay in Ligue 1. I'm at home in Paris and waiting for the telephone to ring."





The full article contains 1017 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

Jam Tarts 1874,

On the Rebound 21/05/2008 11:31:04
So, reading between the lines, Hearts didn't want to keep paying you £10k per week.

As for Banderson suggesting that Romanov sacked two managers just so as Tall could get a game, that has to be the most ridiculous statement Banderson has ever come out with.

I regarded Tall as the best centre-half at the club, but £10k per week? Even if he was available for selection Frail would not have picked him anyway, that would have been too sensible for "Shaggy".
2

Conran,

Husref Musemic's twin brother 21/05/2008 11:31:26
It was always very strange that he didn't play much and always seemed a capable centre half and a decent character.

An example of the poor management structure paying him 10 grand not to play (like so many others) but from memory Tall was the first and was an early warning sign.

Goodluck to him in anycase, can't blame him for leaving but wish Vlad had accepted the reported £400,000 offer rather than running up more Hearts debt for him to sit in the stand. Crazy.
3

snudge,

21/05/2008 11:53:16
Apparently Kingston gets £25k a week.
4

Away down In Gorgie (2),

21/05/2008 11:57:54
Remember that if was his wife that wanted to return to France and thus he was never going to stay.

Was heading for player of the season at Hearts until his injury but not worth 10k a week.

Good luck Ibby.
5

FINLAYBAR,

21/05/2008 12:09:20
10 grand a week for tall!!! no better than average! no wonder we are skint. don t blame vlad for banning him from the side if he is not to committed to the club. i blame vlad for signing him and a lot of other stuff.
6

Jamboy,

Edinburgh 21/05/2008 12:18:27
Okay so maybe he is not worth keeping at 10, 000 a week but seriously people need to start listening to the overwhelming amount of ex-Hearts players, managers, directors etc and stop just thinking it is everyone else's fault but Vlad's over the shambles of a club we have been for two years.

We lost the chance to finish at least second again the season before this one when Rangers were in transition, messed up Europe through lack of a settled team and a manager to pick it, sold every good player Burley brought in, and suffered our worst season since the SPL began this year while running up a huge debt.

Vlad's mess and his activity on sorting it out is quietly innefective to say the least.

Friend of friend of friend quoting McGhee again and yes that would be a great start but not if he is treated the way George was.

I can accept the situation if it is a case of we need to bring in and move on players for profit in order to service the debt or build the stand but we need to be made aware of this and not left to speculate by an arrogant pr1ck who treats us with contempt. perhaps Vlad needed to showcase players to sell on in order to balance the books but these prev managers wanted to play the ones that were best for the team and this is where the problems eminate from.

Thing is we need to be better informed of the situation.
7

Lenny,

21/05/2008 12:25:43
Jam Tarts 1874

No reading between the lines 'Mr Romanov' offered Tall a take it or leave it contract with orders to sign or he wont play again. No negotiation, 'MR' Romanovs way or the high way!

Do you think this is an acceptable way to deal with players? You can go on about him not worth £10K a week etc. But answer this, who gave him a contract for £10K a week in the first place?
8

Indie Rep Kid,

21/05/2008 12:26:01
Well done Ibby for speaking out!

Unfortunately, judging by the first few posters (Jamboy apart), most people are going to get hung up on the salary rather than the way he was treated (or, more importantly, the influence of Vlad on team affairs)
9

Indie Rep Kid,

21/05/2008 12:27:50
#7 Rhetorical question there, Lenny - of course it is unacceptable.

10

Randan,

21/05/2008 12:30:27
Everyone knows Vlad is a dictator, but we're stuck with him.
That's why I won't be back. Just like thousands of other fans.
11

Johnny Jambo,

21/05/2008 12:31:10
#8 well said Indie, the treatment of players at Hearts is appalling.
12

GrahamL,

21/05/2008 12:31:31
Once again the old "Vlad has final say" thing comes out. It appeared when Basso wouldn't sign a new contract, same for Tall.
Whether Vlad is saying "pick these 11 players" or saying "pick from this pre-approved list", it is still interference and is not acceptable at the club. SF clearly hasn't been acting like a real manager, and hasn't had full authority to pick the team - despite the promises in January.
Not good enough guys. Still waiting for a sign that things will change significantly, or - as #6 says - just tell us what the plans are. If we know the truth we can deal with it, we're grown ups.
13

capy,

21/05/2008 12:48:22
#6 couldnt agree more there are still far to many suporters behaving like ostriches over the happenings at tyncastle.i dont have any real answers but i will pick the odd game to go to rather than buy a season. maybe we need to start the same kind of demos that were directed at chris robinson. i know he has got us over a financial barrel but we as supporters cant let this clown ruin the club.and he will sonner or latter.
can you really see Maghee or any other manager worth his salt coming to hearts? we need answers and we need them now. but we will left to the odd tit bit and be expected to lump it. time to fight back boys...& girls.
14

Maroon tinted glasses,

21/05/2008 12:48:53
Guys, i know i shouldnt but i keep being drawn to the footy rumours website SO how about this fro breaking news........
in the space of about 9 various rumours it says

Mark McGhee for the hearts manager after he held talks with mad vlad.

Craig Levein for hearts manager.

and

Jim Jeffries (3rd choice) for the hearts manager with frail as his 2nd after McGhee and levein both told mad vlad to eff off.

Also take a look at the in's and out's BRILLIANT.

15

KingKenny,

21/05/2008 12:50:11
Good Luck Tall.
16

,

21/05/2008 12:51:48
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
17

Maroon tinted glasses,

21/05/2008 12:51:48
it also says there is a english boy going on loan to Gretna HMMMMMMMMMM.
18

Jamboy,

Edinburgh 21/05/2008 12:56:03
Eighteen months eh Serg'?... Makes you wonder.
19

Maroon tinted glasses,

21/05/2008 12:56:17
#16 sad serg,
Yep and you being a little bit unhinged and sad for the last 18 months has deprived you of GETTING A LIFE.
20

,

21/05/2008 12:57:50
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
21

Jamboy,

Edinburgh 21/05/2008 12:57:51
#17

The evidence is overwhelming though Vic' mate... We will not improve unless the situation is sorted out soon... Another season like this and I will be in the room next to Serg' or Riley at the funny farm!
22

,

21/05/2008 12:59:57
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
23

Ichabod,

21/05/2008 13:00:20
Well said Tall!
Vlads interference is ruining Heart of Midlothian. It is time he learned how to run the club. In spite of Tall's support Frail is just not good enough for this team, but he is a lackey, so I expect he will still be boss next season.

Vlad must stand back or the club will suffer!
24

scorchio,

West of the Pecos 21/05/2008 13:00:36
#17 bang on the money there "victorian".
The guy was overpaid, underworked, and sure, he was persona non gata at times, but how "The Scotsman" love something like this.
Hearts could sign a guy every bit as good as him for less than half the wage.
NEXT?
25

,

21/05/2008 13:01:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
26

Jamboy,

Edinburgh 21/05/2008 13:03:19
#25

We need to hear the truth... Like GrahamL says we are adults we can take it.
27

,

21/05/2008 13:07:11
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
28

The Wookie,

Edinburgh 21/05/2008 13:10:06
21~...I totally agree - we only ever hear one side of a story as Vlad refuses to talk - and to tell the truth I think Tall was over rated and never worth 10k per week

The big story today however from a very very good source is - Mark Mcgee has told the Mortherwell players he is taking the Hearts job
29

scorchio,

West of the Pecos 21/05/2008 13:12:21
#27 The "Truth" is never the be all and end all in the sports pages here.
Hearts supporters are now less interested in how Mr Romanov operated, because, they are interested only in seeing if he's going to sort out the current mess.
If he gets the calibre manager we all hope for, and keeps his interfering wee neb out of team matters, I will not worry about past indiscresions.
30

LionheartFodithman,

21/05/2008 13:12:27
If Tall really was enjoying himself and loving the fans blablabla.
Then why not take a wage cut and keep playing in the team.
Had that sort of statement been released then he would have been hero worshipped for eternity.
Shape up or ship out.
31

Lenny,

21/05/2008 13:15:52
JamboThrough&Through

Hi mate. Couldnt agree more re agents. But unfortunately they are not going away.

My point was more that a player speaks out against Romanov and straight away the first few posters are slating the player. Too many players speak out about your owner, this doesnt seem to happen at other clubs. As the saying goes, there is no smoke without fire.
32

,

21/05/2008 13:19:51
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
33

Chas Niceass,

21/05/2008 13:21:15
I'm not one for listening to tell tales but I think fans using the loaf should be relieved at least some players are telling us what we know now and not clouding the issue by signing secrecy agreements.
Once more Romanov, this is the West people dont need to tolerate the way Dictators ride roughshod in the East. If you cant adapt then you are lost and more to the point Hearts are lost.
34

LionheartFodithman,

21/05/2008 13:21:21
#32
Dont you think maybe that the hacks in question will be on their mobiles pestering these guys for any gossip on Vlad then ???
35

Old Reekies Big Team,

21/05/2008 13:22:32
#6 Well done mate someone else that isn't living in a bubble like the tool that is Jam Tarts 1874.
36

,

21/05/2008 13:24:45
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
37

Salvatori,

21/05/2008 13:32:50
32 - There is smouldering though ;)
38

Dragonlord,

21/05/2008 13:33:50
Romanov's metheods are bizare to say the least, but he wants players that are committed to the club. Why then are the first team still here? Commitment was lacking in every game this seasn.
39

Eckles,

Edinburgh 21/05/2008 13:33:50
What ever happened to the Sheriff Officers fiasco that occurred several months ago? Could Mr Barry Anderson enquire into this for the Hearts fans. If the company that called in the Sheriff Officers made a false claim then it would be nice to know. Also, if Hearts hadn't paid their bills then it's abundantly clear that there is more than just Romanov wrong at the club.
That would be one story that some Hearts fans would like to know the answer to, however, I presume that the answer will not be posted on Hearts website and may require investigation.
40

Lenny,

21/05/2008 13:39:46
TT&T

Problem being that Football is not really like your usual busines. It may be the way Vlad deals with his other businesses but Ukio doesnt have thousands (400K to be exact...) of fans who watch his every move.

The simple fact is his silence shows you guys no respect whatsoever. He must be aware when players talk about the club and puts the club in a bad light. But he certainly doesnt care enough to put his side across.
41

Langenburger,

21/05/2008 13:40:30
Our club is dying and is in an even worse state than it was even during the final days of the pieman.
We are now part of a properties development (land and players) business model that is unsustainable. The meglamaniac at the helm will run out of options and then the real fans will be needed.
42

Old Reekies Big Team,

21/05/2008 13:46:21
Taking us for mugs!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The Board of Heart of Midlothian Football Club (Hearts) has begun the search for a football manager to fill the current vacant post at Tynecastle.
The manager, who will have full responsibility for team selection, will be an experienced football manager and will preferably have experience of management in British football.
The new manager will work with sport director Anatoly Korobochka and assistant head coach Stephen Frail.
In the interim Stephen Frail will assume the "caretaker manager" role at Hearts with full responsibility for team selection and coaching of the first team squad.
The Board of Directors of Hearts acknowledges it is not acceptable for Hearts to be in its current position in the league.
The new manager's task will be to drive the club forward on the playing side to fulfill the club's ambitions.
The move by the Board of Directors has the full backing of Hearts majority shareholder Vladimir Romanov.
43

Rolland,

21/05/2008 13:52:07
42 - Spot on !!!

Post of the week so far !!
44

Johnny Jambo,

21/05/2008 13:55:58
Victorian, once again having a pop at JJ I am not a wrist slitter or anything even close to it, I am relating only my honest view of what i see (my opinion) going on. I don't ask anyone to follow me or agree with me, I just happen to think that Romanov will kill our club if he hasn't already done so.
45

,

21/05/2008 13:56:55
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
46

deeks rearend,

21/05/2008 13:58:10
sir serg walter mitty more like ?
47

,

21/05/2008 13:59:05
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
48

deeks rearend,

21/05/2008 13:59:14
who is really sir serg ? mickey weir, keith wright,??who
49

Skiver,

21/05/2008 14:00:05
Good to see all the usual heads stuck in the sand...

More worrying for me is a point that's been raised a few times when something like this has happened - what players will want to sign for Hearts if this is the case?

It's basically signing a contract for life on Romanov's terms, with the only get-out clause being an undisclosed amount of time where you are frozen out of the game.

Can't see any players worth their salt being up for that, only the usual dodgy Lithuanians and money grabbing ba3tards.
50

tommy the jambo,

21/05/2008 14:03:10
romanov acts like dictator!no s@!t sherlock
tommorows exclusive red rum was a horse.
51

Indie Rep Kid,

21/05/2008 14:05:40
Ibby: "I would not sign the new contract so Mr Romanov said to Stephen Frail not to put me in the team"

So Vlad is willing to spend £200k on wages for a player to sit in the stand when he is fit instead of using his qualities to move us up the table where we would have received more prize money to cover those wages?

And this guy is a businessman?

I'm sorry, but Vlad may not end up destroying this club but we can forget all about challenging for 3rd place anytime soon.

Unlike some, I simply cannot see him changing.
52

GGTTH#1,

21/05/2008 14:06:02
Cant believe that certain members on this post are STILL trying to justify these actions. Fairplay to IRK, Jamboy and MTG for at least trying to talk some sense. It seems to a few that the fault lies with the EEN reporter, the player, the football agent etc etc Completely unbelievable!! I said it a few weeks ago that I bet Basso's new offer was a substantial drop in salary and the comments were "how do you know, where's your proof bla, bla, bla" This story has just confirmed what I thought and it seems to be across the board!

FFS in any walk of life if you were to take up a post and then 18 months later your salary was decreased what would you be thinking!! It is complete tyranny of the highest order and the list of "players shaggy canny play" is growing every week!

Nothing at all has changed from what I can see and if any of McGhee/Levein/Jefferies join this shower of completely incompetent idiots then they are playing russian roulette with their careers.

53

GGTTH#1,

21/05/2008 14:15:49
Well Serg, that is clear to see! Tall would never have arrived in the first place if the manager had any say!!



54

Jam Tarts 1874,

On the Rebound 21/05/2008 14:27:47
#36. It is you and others like you who form the noisy minority who have to be the most fickle people around. Rather than bash your gums on stupid forums like this one, why not organise a protest? How many do you honestly think will turn up? Most Hearts fans have the intelligence and emotional maturity to see beyond all this rubbish that the media love spouting out about Romanov. I seriously wonder if any of you actually go to games or know anything about Hearts.

I almost hope that Hearts have another terrible season just so that I can watch you and others like you have their heads explode!

Finally, do you feel like a big man now that you have called me a tool? I guarantee that I have spent more time and money following my team for over 30 years from all over the UK, in short, you know nothing son!
55

,

21/05/2008 14:31:45
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
56

,

21/05/2008 14:42:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
57

Royalty,

Zandvoort 21/05/2008 14:44:29
It must be fun being a Hibby these days, what with the sate of sorry old Hearts.

Bring back the pie man!
58

Rolland,

21/05/2008 14:46:27
No worries LTJ - McGhee on his way, likely the Mothers team bus will just drop him a Tynie after humping the hobo's.
59

ValdasTheMan,

Edinburgh 21/05/2008 14:46:46
#53 Russian roulette worked for George? In fact, for which of our previous managers has it not worked?
Rix - unemployable before he joined us,
Valdas - left with head held high (and SC win), even Shaggy must get some credit for taking us up from 11th?

The problems with our club are nothing to do with any of the managers, the problems are with the directors and owners, and failure to put a proper and effective management structure in place. That has solely caused us to have the worst season in a decade.
60

UrbanFox,

21/05/2008 14:47:52
Does not look good for next season. How could any manager with character and ability work with the dictatorial Moronov. McGhee would be an idiot to accept the position. But if things dont radically change at Tynecastle then Hearts are going nowhere and 2008/9 will be a long miserable season played out to a half empty stadium.
61

Langenburger,

21/05/2008 14:53:24
CJ Our club is as dead as Gretna were while they had a sugar daddy who owned all the aces. And look where it took them when he stopped spending.
We're Vlad's own personal football and one day he will just stop the game.
I don't blame you and anyone else who has bought/renewed STs - I just wish we could have collectively held back because it is cash (lack of)that will be his (our) eventual downfall and by witholding we might bring the new beginning we all need faster.
Hearts will outlive this Vlad clown and be the stronger for it.
62

,

21/05/2008 14:54:44
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
63

I.J,

The Diggers 21/05/2008 14:55:50
Rod Petrie is also a dictator.

The way he treated Paul Fenwick was sickening.
64

,

21/05/2008 14:58:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
65

GrahamL,

21/05/2008 15:02:51
#68 Well. We put up with you and your pals every day, is that what you meant?
66

The Wookie,

Edinburgh 21/05/2008 15:03:52
68#......who mentioned your mum and your sister
67

,

21/05/2008 15:05:05
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
68

,

21/05/2008 15:06:33
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
69

1875 true,

21/05/2008 15:08:13
If Mcgee does take the job then i think hearts should be back in the top 6 and pushing on next year but i feel he could be sacked after not giving in to Vlad and another costly payout through the courts,still believe the dream,as on the Tall story i thought he looked good better than whats there now.
Camt wait for the 1st derby of next season
70

Johnny Jambo,

21/05/2008 15:15:30
#59 CJ - The VR Actions are "Unjustifiable", but acceptable by some is that right??
71

Indie Rep Kid,

21/05/2008 15:17:15
#60 It's not the fact we failed to reach an agreement with Tall to renew his contract (presumably at reduced terms), but the way he was frozen out on Vlad's orders when talks broke down.

It should be the Head Coach's job to ascertain whether a player is mentally right to keep his place in the team - not a man who is thousands of miles away.

THAT'S the issue for me - not Tall's contract, not his ability, but the fact that Vlad appeared to issue an order not to play him.

To blame Banderson, Frail, Foulkes or whoever is seriously losing their focus on what is wrong.

This is NOT standard practice for owners and is completely unjustifiable.
72

UrbanFox,

Edinburgh 21/05/2008 15:18:14
1875true, If McGhee really is interested he should have an eyeball to eyeball showdown with Moronov BEFORE he accepts the job. Afterwards its too late.
73

edinbob,

21/05/2008 15:19:27
Any players that my fellow jambos could see being brought in? (realistically)!
74

,

21/05/2008 15:19:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
75

GrahamL,

21/05/2008 15:22:37
#76 Exactly, there's still interference from Vlad, which isn't acceptable.
Had the same thing when the same story about Basso surfaced. Apparently that was OK because most people didn't want Basso in the team. This seems to be the same thing, Tall couldn't be bothered, or wouldn't take a pay cut, so Vlad was right to tell SF not to pick him.
So Vlad was wrong when he was saying "don't pick Brellier" or "don't pick Skacel" because the fans thought they should play. But it's OK for him to interfere now, because there's no good players left for him to freeze out - so he's only freezing out ones we don't want at the club. Everything's fine and dandy again. Hurrah hurrah!
76

Lenny,

21/05/2008 15:23:45
If McGhee does get the job I think I will be putting a wee tenner on him being the first managerial casualty of the season. Not that I dont rate him, I just cant see Vlad handing over full control, and likewise I can't see McGhee taking any nonsense.

Good manager though, and I can see why you all want him so much. There seems to be a patern on here where people slag of a manager purely becouse he is at the rival club. i.e Collins was cr@p when at Hibs but apparently a great manager after he left. You wont find me changing my tune if McGhee gets the job.
77

Johnny Jambo,

21/05/2008 15:28:14
Am I reading things right here Tall is too expensive and not good enough so it's OK for Vlad to treat him like a leper.

Whilst he sits on his backside not playing we still have to pay him his 10K a week anyway.

I am still of the opinion that Vlad is wasting the club and no one is doing anything about it, some are willing to give him another season. Lets see what he delivers in that season then.

I have a question then, what happens if our "New Manager" Mark McGhee wants to play Tall because he thinks he is OK, will he play or not??

Just playing devils advocate here.
78

Johnny Jambo,

21/05/2008 15:30:04
in my post 82 I was speaking metaphorically regarding Tall it could be any player.
79

,

21/05/2008 15:31:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
80

Indie Rep Kid,

21/05/2008 15:31:51
#82 #83

That's the huge question and it's one that any new manager should be looking to test on day 1 of the season.

81

Johnny Jambo,

21/05/2008 15:33:15
#85 any manager worth his salt should have asked that question already and if he hasn't then I dont know if he is the right man for the job.
82

,

21/05/2008 15:34:09
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
83

East at Easter,

Edinburgh 21/05/2008 15:36:04
Ibrahim Tall: Romanov acts like 'dictator'


tell us something we didnt know.....
84

East at Easter,

Edinburgh 21/05/2008 15:37:02
my my no 79. you are a bitter toad.
85

Lenny,

21/05/2008 15:39:19
Vic

Im pretty sure that Burley was told he would have full control. This didnt stop Vlad getting involved afterwards.

I assume that McGhee would be told he has full control. However, would you trust Vlad to keep his hands off? There is nothing at all to indicate he will let a manager get on with it.

I get the feeling that its hope more than expectance in your case. (not being patronising, appologies if you really do expect Vlad to keep hands off)

86

GGTTH#1,

21/05/2008 15:41:55
They would have got away with it aswell if it wasnt for that pesky Barry Anderson!!
87

Johnny Jambo,

21/05/2008 15:42:53
Lenny, Question I have is why would any Manager trust Vlad after the way he has treated previous Managers, Burley, Rix, Valdas, Maloveev.

Frail the puppet has been treated OK because he did exactly what he was told and didn't rock the boat.
88

GGTTH#1,

21/05/2008 15:44:56
not just the manager Johnny but why would any player trust him either?
89

GrahamL,

21/05/2008 15:45:29
#87 Aye. You have to assume that, if we get a manager like McGhee (one who knows whats going on at Tynie and has left a real job to come here) then he's been assured he'll be making the decisions. And that's got to be a good thing. And then if Vlad turns round and starts meddling - at that point surely all the Hearts fans would have had enough?
90

Indie Rep Kid,

21/05/2008 15:46:17
#90 I understand Burley was ready to walk before the season even started.

I too cannot see Vlad keeping his sticky fingers out of it - he is 'hands' on in everything he does and is not going to change his entire business methods just because a few thousand 'shareholders' want him to.
91

Johnny Jambo,

21/05/2008 15:47:52
#94 GrahamL surely Vlad assured Burley and Rix that they would have full control over playing matters before they came in. I know Riox was a different situation just wanting to get back into the gamne but after them surely everyone in football knew what to expect from Romanov.
92

StockportJambo,

21/05/2008 15:48:30
Rix said on many occasions that "we didn't have another right back at the club" when talking about Robbie's continual selection. Burley clearly didn't rate him either.

How strange then that when he did eventually play, he turned out to be our most accomplished & capable defender. Romanov was proven right, then?

Something not right there...
93

,

21/05/2008 15:49:04
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
94

GrahamL,

21/05/2008 15:50:08
#79 LATJ (hang on a minute.... nah, couldn't be.... coincidence?)

Crossed a line there. As annoying as Dublin Hibs may be, he does do a fine line in weegie-hating. You play nice now.
95

,

21/05/2008 15:51:36
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
96

Lenny,

21/05/2008 15:51:38
Johnny Jambo #92

The simple answer their mate is ££££££.
97

Johnny Jambo,

21/05/2008 15:52:44
#100 - Vic you are having a laugh arn't you????
98

,

21/05/2008 15:53:20
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
99

Johnny Jambo,

21/05/2008 15:53:45
Lenny, theres more to life than cash my friend, I see too many managers walking away from thir jobs for cash to be the main motivator.
100

,

21/05/2008 15:54:22
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
101

Johnny Jambo,

21/05/2008 15:55:05
Vic "a couple of years of normality???????"
102

Lenny,

21/05/2008 15:55:06
Vic

I honestly dont think that Vlad gives two hoots if he upsets the Hearts fans. Look at the way Roman spoke to you guys at the AGM.

103

,

21/05/2008 15:56:11
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
104

GrahamL,

21/05/2008 15:56:23
#96 It wouldn't surprise me if Burley didn't ask. It's pretty unusual for this level of interference. Rix... he was the one who really broke the interfering story, so he may not have asked either. I don't know. As you say, he was in a different situaion. When ever I've taken a new job I've not explicitly asked if I'd be given the freedom to do my job, it's been implied by the fact that my boss isn't (that) mental.
Again, as you say, everyone knows of the interference from Vlad now, so I assume it'll be explictly mentioned at the inteview, if not actually a condition of the contract. If we get a proper manager he'll demand no interference - and if Vlad goes back on that one then I really hope it gets all the Hearts fans motivated.
We will see I guess...
105

Lenny,

21/05/2008 16:00:02
GrahamL #109

Thats all makes sense. However I get the feeling certain Hearts fans will still support Vlad regardless.
106

GrahamL,

21/05/2008 16:07:31
#111 Maybe.
I'd have thought the actions to date would have started an uprising, but it seems to have been pretty minor so far, it may take something pretty dramatic to change the apathy round the club. Or - hey - lets not be negative, maybe everything will turn out just fine after all. None of us know for sure...
107

Eckles,

Edinburgh 21/05/2008 16:09:28
#108 Rankers FC.

Do the SFA referees go onto your official wage bill or not?
108

The RESURRECTIONISTS,

21/05/2008 16:16:02
#6 JAMBOY

Nice to see MOTHY that you've finally come round to agreeing totally with what Riley has been saying to you jambos since JANUARY.
Not quick on the uptake Jambos though, are they??..........Eh,Muchacho
109

,

21/05/2008 16:16:38
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
110

The RESURRECTIONISTS,

21/05/2008 16:18:11
#20 MTG
18 Months??
"Get a Life"????...you've got some nerve CORGY
...surely you've been a jambo longer than that?
111

The RESURRECTIONISTS,

21/05/2008 16:19:57
#27 JAMBOY

That's prcisely the trouble MOTHY...YOU of all people CAN'T take it. That's why they now laugh at you at the Scotsman as well as here Muchacho.
112

,

21/05/2008 16:20:36
Comment Removed B